Giving Sarah a show

Dan saw that his girlfriend's ass was slick due to her excitement at playing with Sienna. He teased her asshole with his cock, pressing the head in very gently. He could feel that Nicole was incredibly tight back there, and there was a lot of resistance. He felt her sphincter giving very slightly as he gently pushed into her.

“I know you want to, babe. I'm still not quite ready to try.” Nicole warned.

Dan was willing to wait until Nicole was ready to explore that with him. He positioned her legs on his shoulders and plunged himself deep into her. She was soaking wet, which he loved. Went fully inside her, causing her to let out a muffled moan as Sienna sat on her face. The sight of his seed dripping out of the brunette cheerleader really turned him on. He started fucking Nicole really fast, making sure he gave her his entire length with each thrust. He watched as Nicole was lapping at Sienna's clit and sucking on her pussy lips. Nicole was devouring every drop of cum as it slowly dripped out of Sienna and onto her lips and tongue.

Dan looked over his shoulder at Maddie and Angelo. Maddie was now on her side sucking Angela's cock, she was deepthroating him, but for the first time Dan saw that Angelo was not huge. Angela was leaning into the sofa with his eyes closed while he enjoyed getting oral from the redhead cheerleader. He looked over at Sarah, who smiled at Dan as he saw she was still playing with herself as she watched everyone.

Dan resumed fucking his girlfriend. Pounding away at her, which made her moans intensify. He heard Sienna calling out in pleasure as Nicole brought her to climax. This spurred Dan on and started touching Nicole's clit while he penetrated her. He heard muffled cries from Nicole as she came on his cock.

Sienna turned around and leaned forward to grab Dan's cock. She put it in her mouth and sucked on it a little before licking his shaft to savour Nicole's wetness. Dan fucked Sienna's mouth a little so he was deep in her throat.

“Can I feel you inside me again? Sienna asked.

He placed Sienna on her back so she was lying next to Nicole. The girls started kissing and teasing each other's pussies. He was happy watching for a moment as Sienna inserted several fingers into his girlfriend. She fucked Nicole really quick and hard with her fingers, while also rubbing her clit. Nicole cried out as Sienna made her climax again before pushing her hands away from her due to feeling too sensitive.

Dan eased himself back inside Sienna. He fucked her slower the second time. He very slowly pumped in and out of her, making her feel every inch and hitting all of her sensitive spots. He could hear Sienna moaning into Nicole's mouth. Nicole started rubbing Sienna's clit really hard as Dan fucked her. She massaged her with her fingers in a quick circular motion. Dan maintained the same pace, pulling all the way out of Sienna and then slowly sliding back inside her. He loved how tight the cheerleader was. He felt her begin to quiver very slightly as the pair of them made Sienna cum for a second time.

Dan pulled out and moved over to Nicole. He started fucking her again, going slow as he had with Sienna. Dan could feel another orgasm building. He kept easing himself in and out of his girlfriend until he felt he was ready to burst. He slipped out of her and brought his cock to her face. Nicole switched from kissing Sienna to accepting Dan's cock into her mouth. She locked her lips around the head as Dan let out a long, low groan. He filled Nicole's mouth with cum. He heard her cough and splutter slightly, and some of it started dripping out of the corner of her mouth. Dan stepped back and watched Nicole and Sienna resume kissing. He loved the sight of Nicole doing this, sharing his cum with another girl. They both kissed really deeply and passionately, swapping it back and forth before they both eventually swallowed. Dan sat between the two of them half erect, with both girls gently rubbing his length.

He looked over and saw that Maddie was riding Angelo. It sounded like she was experiencing another orgasm. This proved to be too intense for Angelo, who pushed Maddie off him and made her take his cock into her mouth. She accepted his cock without issue and was soon gulping down the last of Angelo's seed.

“Dan, come over here,” Sarah told him.

He stood up and walked over to Sarah. She reached for his cock and started stroking him and getting him hard for her. Dan had no complaints about her touching him like this was very willing to have a second time with Sarah. She took him into her mouth and swallowed his entire length with ease, she hummed, which felt really good. Sarah worked her lips up and down his shaft, while teasing him with her tongue. She let him slip from her mouth and went back to jerking it. With her free hand, Sarah reached for the tube under her chair.

“I think you said you want to fuck me in the ass?” Sarah said wantonly

Sarah coated Dan's cock in lube. When she felt he was sufficiently lubricated, she stood up and bent over for him. Dan returned the favour and liberally coated Sarah's asshole in lube, he pressed a finger in gently to apply a little inside her as well. Dan saw that everyone was watching them intently. Dan started pressing the head of his cock into Sarah but she stopped him.

“I want to ride you.” Sarah told him.

Dan sat in the chair, and Sarah straddled him in Reverse Cowgirl. She reached for his cock and guided it to her asshole. Dan pressed it into her, and they both moaned as her ass yielded to his cock. Dan did not move further for the moment, loving the sensation of how Sarah's ass felt around his cock. He could feel her stretching a little, but how tightly she was wrapped around him. She sank onto it until he was fully inside her.

“How does my boyfriend's cock feel in your ass?” Nicole asked.

“He's really stretching me and feels really good when he's deep,” Sarah murmured.

Dan watched as Nicole turned to Sienna. “Would you lick my ass again?”

Sienna placed Nicole on all fours in a position so she could watch Dan and Sarah. Nicole had her ass up in the air and face down on the sofa. Dan slowly started to slide himself in and out of Sarah. He left just the tip inside and penetrated deeply when he went back into her. He felt that Sarah was rubbing herself as they fucked. Dan looked over at Maddie and Angelo again, but the couple appeared to be spent, with Maddie lazily rubbing Angelo's soft cock.

Sarah started riding Dan, easing herself up and down on his cock. The blonde was loving how Dan felt inside her, his cock pulsing deep within her. He heard Sarah cry out as she made herself cum. She collapsed back onto Dan with him remaining inside her. Dan was nowhere near finished and hoped that Sarah was not either. He went faster and a lot harder. Sarah leaned back against him, moaning loudly.

“Don't stop. Please fuck me hard like this.” Sarah begged.

Dan did not need any further encouragement and continued fucking Sarah's ass in the way that she wanted. He buried it in with each stroke, back inside her. Playing with her large breasts while doing so. He squeezed the flesh of her breasts and pinched her nipples between his fingers. Sarah's fingers continued to tease herself, and Dan knew she was dripping wet. Dan had orgasmed twice now and knew it would be some time before he was close again. He was not complaining he wanted to savour every second of this. He had not been with many girls who enjoyed doing anal like this, so Sarah begging to be fucked mercilessly was arousing. Sarah let out a piercing shriek as she experienced a very powerful orgasm. Dan felt her entire body shaking as she came several times. This brought Dan over the edge, and he just held Sarah in place while he unloaded inside her. Sarah had gone limp in Dan's arms and was breathing really heavily.

“I think your entire neighbourhood just heard you cum, girl.” Sienna teased.

Sarah moved a little so Dan was not inside her and just lay there on him for several minutes.

“Thank you, Dan, that was incredible.” Sarah complimented him.

Sarah groggily got up and went over to Nicole and Sienna. The three of them cuddled and kissed, and Dan was content to watch them. He was it was very late at this point and all of them were a little exhausted.

“You guys don't need to go home. You can stay over in the guest room.” Sarah advised.

All of them stayed there a little longer. The girls were basking in the warmth of each other's bodies. Slowly, they gathered their discarded clothing and headed back inside the house. Angelo declined to stay over and headed home. Sarah showed Dan and Nicole to a spacious guest bedroom. They both got naked and kissed and cuddled on the bed before Nicole told him that she had to go pee. He sat there thinking about tonight when the door opened. He could hear talking, and that Nicole was not alone.