Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 9 by I.am.all I.am.all

What do you do?

Encourage Mitchell to fuck CJ

"Then you can fuck CJ." You say.

"Dude, what the fuck?" he says, face contorting to disgust.

"Yeah, what the hell man?" CJ joins in.

"Well I can't fuck him." you say, feigning obviousness, "I just did and if I do it again straight away, it would be weird."

"Why does anyone need to fuck me?" CJ conplained.

"Because..." you say, quickly trying to think of an excuse, "I just cleaned your ass, but lubed it at the same time. It was unavoidable. It'd be a waste to just to leave it lubed and unfucked."

"Then why do I have to do it?" Mitchell asked, his erection softening.

"Do you prefer fucking or masterbating?" you ask.

Mitchell shrugged, as if to say "fair enough" before pulling CJ out of the shower. CJ seemed slightly annoyed and nervous as his older brother bent him over the sink. Positioning his cock, Mitchell began easing into his brother.

"Ohh..." both men groaned, connecting sexually for the first time.

As Mitchell slowly began to develop a rhythm, you weighed up whether you stay and watch, join in, or leave to find someone else.

What do you decide?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)