Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4 by sierrawritessmut sierrawritessmut

Which girl comes first? What's the reward? What happens next?

Ella comes first, Mia gets a reward (assisted deepthroat)

Mia went to work, first drawing her tongue up Ella’s labia and then sucking intensely on her clit. Ella put up a feeble attempt to stop Mia from devouring her pussy, but her will wavered as the intense pressure on her clit sent waves of pleasure running through her body. Ella’s back arched high, her hand grasped tightly in Mia’s hair. Mia reached a hand up Ella’s naked body as she sucked and licked, grasping Ella’s tit.

“W-wait, noooo…” In a moment of clarity, Ella attempted to push Mia face out of her flower, but her attempt was quickly ended when Mia pinched Ella’s pink nipple, hard.

“Ahhhh!” Ella moaned as Mia thrust her tongue deeper into Ella’s snatch, rolling her nipples with one hand and using the other to caress Ella’s thigh. Ella was lost in ecstasy as her best friend tonguefucked her pussy, licking and sucking her most sensitive area in a steady rhythm.

“Oh fuck, Miaaaa!!!” Ella’s legs wrapped around Mia’s head and clenched tight, suffocating her best friend in her own wet folds. Mia just kept sucking, determined to win the battle and escape Carter’s ire.

Ella bucked her hips repeatedly. Her eyes rolled back in her skull as she pressed Mia’s face deeper into her snatch. Carter smirked as he jacked off his huge dick, causing it to grow to full mast.

Finally, Ella’s grip released, and she splayed out on her back, totally relaxed. Mia stood up, her face wet with Ella’s pussy juices, a triumphant smile on her face.

“Well, what do I win, Carter?” Mia said, eyeing Carter’s growing wood.

“Get on your knees.” Carter said gruffly.

“But, I deserve something good, right?” Mia asked as she obediently dropped to her knees.

“Get up, Ella.” Carter said, ignoring Mia. “You’re going to help with Mia’s reward.”

Mia could feel her own pussy dripping wet after the eroticism of forcing Ella to cum. It ached for a cock to fill it.

“Can I have your cock fill my pussy, as my rewa-MMF?” Mia said sweetly.

“I’ll decide what your reward is.” Carter grabbed Mia by the hair roughly and shoved his cock in her mouth mid-sentence, interrupting her. Behind Mia, Ella slowly picked herself up, eyes wide as the full length of Carter’s dick disappeared into Mia’s open mouth.

“Ella!” Carter said commandingly. “Get over here and help your friend take her reward.”

Hesitantly, Ella placed her hands on Mia’s head, lightly guiding it back and forth on Carter’s cock.

“Snggfh, gack, GACK chhggggg ACK!” Mia tried to protest but Carter kept thrusting forward into Mia’s mouth-hole.

“Don’t forget you’re going to get punished for losing now, Ella.” Carter reached over and spanked Ella across the ass.

“Ack!” Ella shrieked at the unexpected pain. She looked up at Carter, not sure what to do.

In response, Carter took out his phone and started a stopwatch. At the same time, he stopped thrusting forward, letting his cock sit still in Mia’s mouth.

“Ella, I’m going to give you a spanking just like that for every 10 seconds it takes for Mia’s throat to make me cum.” Carter waved the stopwatch at her. “You better get helping her.”

Mia opened her mouth a little wider in protest, attempting to complain around Carter’s dick. But before Mia could manage a full word, Ella had forcefully grabbed Mia’s blonde hair and pushed her throat fully onto Carter’s cock. Ella held her there as Mia slapped against Carter’s legs wildly. Mia’s nose was pressed up against Carter’s pubes, his throbbing cock lodged down her throat hole.

“Mmm, yeah, Ella. Fuck me with your friend’s throat.” Carter stood there, his cock growing even harder inside Mia’s throat. He drank in the sight of Ella’s naked body restraining her best friend’s head in place.

When Mia’s struggles began to weaken, Ella pulled back on Mia’s hair, maintaining her vice-like grip on her skull. With renewed energy and fear in her eyes as she watched the stopwatch tick upwards, Ella slammed Mia forward repeatedly, skullfucking her best friend on Carter’s cock.

“MmgACK GACK GGGACKACKACKAMMFFFFF!!!” Mia’s face became a watery mess as a combination of spit, precum, and tears covered her face. Ella yanked her hair back and then shoved her forward relentlessly, keeping her affixed on Carter’s well-lubricated rod. Carter could feel the pleasure begin to build in his groin as his cock was squeezed over and over again by Mia’s constricting throat hole.

“Cum for me, Carter!” Ella said in desperation as she continued to fuck Mia’s throat hole. Ella could feel her own pussy dripping in response to what she was doing - using her best friend’s mouth like a fleshlight to make Carter cum.

“Oh, yeah, I’m getting close, baby.” Carter began to thrust forward, trying to lodge his cock even deeper in Mia’s tight throat. Mia just coughed up even more drool.

Ella slammed Mia forward again. This time, she stepped forward, used her crotch to secure Mia’s throat against Carter’s cock, and wrapped her own hands around Carter’s broad shoulders. Ella began to hump the back of Mia’s head, burying her friend’s face in Carter’s crotch.

“Cum for me, Carter.” Ella kissed Carter, exploring his mouth with her tongue. Down below, Mia’s skull was sandwiched between Ella’s wet pussy and Carter’s pulsating cock. She felt the oxygen leaving her lungs. Carter’s cock choked her as she struggled to breathe. Then, she felt his cock jerk and twitch wildly inside her mouth. Mia sucked as hard as she could, taking Carter’s jizz straight down her throat.

Ella felt Mia’s movements begin to slow as Carter let out a massive moan. Fearful her friend would pass out, Ella pulled Mia backwards, tumbling onto the floor. Carter was still cumming. His cock continued to jerk itself several times, spurting cum onto Mia’s tits and tummy. Finally, Carter was satisfied and he stopped the clock.

“Impressive. 2 minutes.” He showed the stopwatch to Ella. Mia collapsed on the floor, covered in cum and struggling to regain her breath. Ella gulped.

“But I think I want to do something different for your punishment…” Carter said with a smile.

What is Ella’s punishment?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)