Cynthia

Ava is the first to fall. Her body feels weak and awkward as she climbs on the floating **** device, no doubt the result of a week's worth of malnourishment and increasing mistreatment. As a result she's shaky right from the start lifting herself over the edge threatening her pussy. When her arms give out for just a second and her her already abused pussy hits the edge she shrieks and falls off sideways, into the water.

The others fair better, but it quickly becomes apparent that Cynthia has a significant advantage. She grins confidently as she shoots the girls flanking her quick looks, her years of gymnastics training helping her both in terms of balance and holding her body weight up with her hands. She's still looking surprisingly comfortable a few minutes in when the other girls have been **** down onto the painful device.

Andrea is the second to go. Even in the best of times, balance has never been her specialty. Now, distracted by the peculiar mix of pain and pleasure she grits her teeth and bears it for as long as she can. But when her body starts screaming for escape she makes her move, intentionally throwing herself sideways towards Cynthia.

While she doesn't manage to hit the other girl or the device she's riding, she gets close enough to make it rock quite a bit. Cynthia's cunt finally hits the hard edge hard and she cries out. It seems for a moment that she's doomed, struggling to keep her legs tight against the slippery sides and contorting her body to avoid tipping over. Gary and Kat both gasp in shock when Cynthia manages to regain her grip with her hands, throw her legs out in the splits and hoist herself back up.

While Cynthia is making it through the challenge with incredible grace and physical ability, Simone seems to be doing it by **** of will alone. By this point in the contest she's given up on holding herself over the edge contraption, simply closing her eyes and scrunching her face up in concentration as pressure tears her lower lips open. She's finding the pain of the experience is blending quite a bit with the pleasure for her and the knowledge that she's being watched by everyone is getting her off.

The two stay like this for over ten minutes, everyone stares in rapt attention beside the pool as both girls become increasingly exhausted, drenched in sweat. They're both grunting and groaning by the end, though Simone's are decidedly more erotic in nature. In the end, Simone's pleasure is her undoing. She just can't stop thinking about how she's doing this for Gary. Enduring this pain for him, her master. She thinks of his cock penetrating her pussy through the pain. The thought puts her over the edge and with a cry she cums. Her legs go numb momentarily and that's all it takes, she slides off the horse into the water with a splash. Red faced and gasping for air when she swims out.

Seeing she's the last one standing Cynthia shouts, "Woohoo!" and promptly launches herself into the pool as well.

With all the girls out of the pool, still varying degrees of soaked, Kat gather them all up. "Congratulations, Cynthia, you've earned yourself immunity for the first set of eliminations."

"Yes!" The redhead pumps her fist.

"It was quite the victory, too. The way you recovered after Andrea nearly knocked you off was incredible." She continues.

Andrea shoots daggers at the host for brining up what she'd done, but Cynthia smiles, completely obliviously responding. "Yeah, I thought I was done for there for a second."

"Well, unfortunately for the rest of you, that means you're on the chopping block." Kat continues. "Tomorrow we'll hold the discarding ceremony where two of you, will be discarded."

"Two?" Simone squeaks.

"Yes, two." Kat confirms. "The harem master Gary, will select one of you to discard. Then, the audience at home will choose a second. Does that worry you, Simone?"

She nods. "I don't want to go home." She whimpers.

"What about you, Andrea?" Kat asks, "How are you feeling about this elimination?"

The Hispanic woman swallows but gives her best attempt at a confident smile. "I'm a little nervous." She admits. "But I have faith the audience will want to see Gary and I's love endure."

"And finally, how are you feeling Ava?" Kat asks.

"Please vote me out." Ava pleads, her voice cracking. She turns to Gary, who's shocked to see tears in her eyes, as she repeats herself. "Please."

"Well Garry, you have a big choice in front of you." Kat says, ignoring the woman obviously on the verge of a breakdown next to her. "And a little more than 24 hours to make your final decision. I'll leave you to think it over and spend some time with the girls to help you decide."