More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 9 by paperclip12321 paperclip12321

What's next?

Coffee Date

Emilia sat in the corner of the coffee shop, a steamy cup of chai latte in her hands, the golden cinnamon and milk foam creating a delicate, comforting aroma that wafted through the air. The soft hum of conversation and the faint jazzy melody playing from the old jukebox filled the small, cozy space, each patron content in their own world, lost in their thoughts or engaged in quiet chatter.

It was just past 10:15am and Emilia was beginning to wonder where her sister might be. Usually punctual, Lily was never late for any of their scheduled dates. But today, she was nowhere to be seen. Emilia had already been waiting for fifteen minutes, her fingers tapping anxiously against the warm mug in her hands. Just as she was about to check her watch again, the bell above the coffee shop door chimed.

Lily walked in, looking slightly disheveled, her hair a mess of tangles, and her face bare of any makeup. Emilia's eyebrows furrowed in concern as she watched Lily weave her way through the crowded coffee shop, her eyes scanning the room before finally settling on Emilia. The usual vibrant spark in Lily's eyes seemed to be dimmed, replaced by a uncertain, almost nervous look. Her sister wore a uncharacteristic hoodie, her usual stylish attire replaced by something more casual and comforting.

"Lil, hey is everything okay?" Emilia said, her voice laced with concern as she got up from the table to greet her sister.

"Hey El, yeah sorry I'm late. Everything is fine. Just a rough morning," Lily said, giving a small smile to her sister as they hugged and sat down.

"Well I ordered you you're favorite latte," Emilia said as she scooted chai latte with almond milk. "Extra sugar, just for you."

"Oh, ummm thanks, Sis. You know me too well," Lily replied, taking the cup and bringing it up to her lips.

Emilia watched as her sister took a small sip and almost grimace at the taste. "What's wrong? Taste okay?" she asked noting her sister's less than enthusiastic reaction to the drink.

"Oh yeah, it's perfect. It's just that I haven't really been drinking coffee lately," Lily said, her voice softer than usual.

"Really? Well suggesting we get coffee is a bit peculiar, don't you think?" Emilia said raising an eyebrow at her sister. She always enjoyed giving her little sister a bit of a hard time whenever she did something silly.

"Ha, yeah I guess it was. I don't know, I just know that you like this spot and I wanted to see you," Lily said as she gave a half hearted smile.

"Well I'm really happy to see you either way, Lil. You seemed like you really needed to talk about something on the phone. What's up?" Emilia asked, her voice softening as she continued to note Lily's uncharacteristic demeanor. She reached across the table and placed her hand over Lily's.

Zach looked down at their joined hands nervously, Emilia's thumb tracing small circles on the back of his hand. "Honestly, El, I just... I just wanted to talk to you," he said, his voice quiet and sincere.

Zach knew he had to tread carefully, to make his words sound like something Lily would say, while also not giving too much away. "You know, I just... I've been feeling a bit off lately. I thought maybe talking to you would help," he said, hoping that the vagueness of the statement would be reassuring rather than suspicious. He looked into Emilia's eyes, trying to mirror the concern he saw in them. "I just feel like we've been drifting apart. I guess that's why I've been acting a little off."

Emilia's grip on Zach's hand tightened slightly, her brow furrowing in worry. "What do you mean? We talk all the time, Lil. You know I'm always here for you," Emilia said. "Are you feeling this way because of Ethan? I know you two don't get along but that doesn't affect our relationship."

"What? No, Ethan is fine. In fact, I feel like he and I have been getting a lot.....closer lately," Zach said shaking his borrowed head. He smiled internally knowing just how much the real Lily would be seething with anger right now if she knew he was sitting here saying that. Too bad she didn't have a choice, Zach thought as he took another sip of Lily's favorite flavor latte, grimacing at the overly sweet taste.

"Really?" Emilia asked, her eyebrows raised in surprise. "I was pretty sure you two hated each other. I mean, don't get me wrong, I'm happy to hear that you guys are getting along but it just surprises me."

"Yeah actually I really feel like we have been. That's the main reason I wanted to meet. To let you know that I'm starting to see why you like him so much," Zach said as he gave a casual shrug. He saw a potential out and he was going to take it. If he could make Emilia think that the tension between Lily and Ethan was gone, then that would help explain why Lily was so adamant about meeting. It may even help him in getting Emilia to overlook his current appearance. There was no way he was going to go through Lily's morning routine. All that work to just look pretty? No way, a hoodie and sweat pants would work just fine on a body that already looked this good. Zach smiled inwardly knowing he wasn't wearing anything else underneath the hoodie. He could feel his borrowed nipples harden slightly each time the fabric of the hoodie brushed against them. The feeling making his borrowed pussy clench reflexively causing a bit of Ethan's cum to ooze out.

"Wow, Lily that's so great!" Emilia said, her face lighting up with a wide grin. She leaned back in her chair, excitement replacing the concern she'd felt only moments ago. "I mean, I've always thought you two had so much in common. I'm really glad to hear that you're getting along better."

"Yeah, I don't know why I was so harsh to him before. I guess it was a bad first impression. You know how I can be sometimes," Zach said, gaining conficence as he realized his acting was working. Maybe he'd get away with this little lie afer all. Sure he and Ethan still had to figure out how to keep the real Lily from spilling the beans, but this was a good start. The two sister's continued their conversation for another hour, enjoying every moment of their time together. Neither fully understanding the web of deceit they were both wrapped in. One completely unware that her sister had been sleeping with her husband, and the other **** into a nether world as she served as a mount to an extremely horny bodyhopper.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)