Chapter 19: I'm Begging You, Brielle..."

Continued from chapter 18:

Amy takes a shuddering breath, gathering every ounce of courage she possesses.

When she speaks again, her voice is thick with emotion, each word a struggle to get out.

“B-Brielle, I... I need to tell you something. Something terrible I’ve done.”

She pauses, composing herself before continuing, her tone heavy with self-loathing and regret.

“I... I cheated on Ero. While he was out of town. At W-Wild Willy's. Girl's night. I betrayed Ero in the worst possible way, and I can never forgive myself for the pain I’ve caused him.”

Amy’s voice breaks, tears flowing freely as she lays bare her soul.

“I’m so sorry, Brielle. I know how much you love Ero, how much you care about our family.”

There’s a stunned silence on the other end of the line, broken only by the sound of Amy’s muffled sobs.

When Brielle finally speaks, her voice is low, trembling with barely contained emotion.

“Amy... How could you? After everything Mom put Dad through, how could you do this to Ero, to yourself?”

Chapter 19:

Her tone shifts, anger and disgust coloring her words.

“Wild Willy's? Really? You sank so low as to cheat in a place like that? With those floozy friends of yours?”

“Y-yes,” Amy replies, breaking down into full, ugly sobs as she hands me the phone, her face buried in her hands.

“Ero?” Brielle’s voice is uncertain. “Ero, are you there?”

“I’m here, Brielle.”

“Ero, I am so sorry for Amy’s actions. She’s always been like this—so headstrong, so careless. I’m only a sophomore in college, and I can’t believe how immature she can be sometimes.”

Brielle turns her wrath back on Amy.

“Amy, what on earth? Ero is so perfect. He’s given you everything, and he’d give you the world if you asked him. How could you do this? To him? To me? To your marriage?”

Amy sobs uncontrollably into the phone. Brielle ignores her, focusing on me.

“Ero, are you okay?”

“No, Brielle, I’m not.”

I **** Amy to take the phone back.

“Tell her, Amy. Tell her what you need her to do…”

Amy takes the phone with a trembling hand, her voice shaking with sobs, as she addresses her sister.

“Brielle, I know I’ve hurt everyone who cares about me. I’ve betrayed the man I love and shamed our family name. Nothing I say can undo what I’ve done.”

She takes a deep, shuddering breath before continuing, her words tumbling out in a **** rush.

“But I’m begging you, Brielle. Please, I need your help to fix this. To make things right. I want... I need you to come stay with us during your fall break. Act as our marriage counselor, guide us through this crisis.”

Her voice drops to a mortified whisper, her cheeks burning with shame.

“I need you to punish me, Brielle.”

Brielle is silent for about ten seconds before she responds, her voice icy cold.

“Punish you, Amy? Punish you? Punish you how?”

Amy flinches at the incredulity in Brielle's voice, knowing she must elaborate on her shocking request.

“I mean in whatever way you think is necessary to help me atone for my sins. To make me feel the full weight of the pain I’ve caused Ero.”

Her voice trembles as she continues, each word a struggle.

“I have been incredibly immature and reckless. I guess I’m asking you, my younger sister by six years, to please... please punish me in a way that fits what I've done.”

“I need you to balance the scales between Ero and me, so he can forgive me. I need to be hurt, like I’ve hurt Ero. I need to be humiliated, like I’ve humiliated him. I am giving myself to you, Brielle, to punish me the way you wish you could have punished Mom when she cheated on Dad.”

Amy swallows, shuddering with humiliation and fear.

“ You can strip me. You can spank me. You will have complete access to my body to do with me as you will... so Ero can witness the depths of what I will go to in order to earn his forgiveness. Brielle, please. The guilt and shame are killing me.”

“Please do what needs to be done so I can be free of it.”

Amy's breath comes in short, panicked gasps as she lays herself bare.

“And please, if you're willing, include Jenna and Rose in the punishment as well. They enabled my behavior, and they should share in the repercussions.”

Brielle doesn’t respond right away while Amy’s racked sobs fill the silence.

“Ero, am I hearing my big sister right? Do you want me to do this? I mean, she definitely deserves it. Wild Willy's? Sexy Six? Ew!”

Brielle begins to scold Amy.

“Amy, you’re a grown-up, and you’re behaving like an irresponsible college freshman. If you were in my sorority... a paddling would be the least of your worries.”

Amy tries to protest, but Brielle interrupts her.

“Amy, I don’t care what you want. Ero? Ero, do you want me to do this? To punish Amy?”

I smile sympathetically at Amy.

“Yes, Brielle, I think it’s what needs to happen for us to even have a chance. We are so out of balance right now; this is the only way I think we can fix it. I want Amy to hurt like I’m hurting. I want her to be humiliated like I’ve been humiliated.”

I take a deep breath and continue.

“I don’t trust myself to punish Amy because I’m so mad, and I don’t want to cheat if I can help it. I don’t think that fixes things. Our sex life is so out of whack right now…”

“I think her punishment should be sexual in nature, painful in nature, and utterly humiliating in nature. I want you to take her apart piece by piece, breaking her down to nothing. I am willing to help, under your supervision, so that I do not take it too far.”

“If Jenna and Rose are willing, they need everything Amy gets because they encouraged her infidelity. The rest of them will be dealt with, but Jenna and Rose were Amy’s friends before The Sexy Six, and she wants to keep them, so this is how they get to stay. What do you suggest? Are you willing to help us with this?”

Amy listens in horror and morbid fascination as I outline my desires for her punishment. Each word sends a fresh wave of dread and shame coursing through her body.

She knows she has no right to object, no grounds to refuse whatever humiliations and torments Brielle and I deem fit to inflict upon her. This is the price of her betrayal, the penance she must pay to even begin to make amends.

Controlling her shaking voice, Amy speaks up.

“Brielle, I understand your ****, your disbelief. But I swear to you, I am ready to endure any degradation, any pain, to prove my love and loyalty to Ero. My body, my pride, my very sanity—I place them all in your capable hands.”

Her voice quavers with a mixture of fear and perverse anticipation as she continues.

“If…”

“If what, Amelia?” Brielle's voice is like ice.

To be continued in chapter 20...