Challenge

The whole group was staring at me, expecting me to either back down or start touching myself right there on the chair.

“No,” I said firmly, trying to stall. “This is ridiculous. I am not masturbating in front of all of you. Find another dare. I will do shots, answer anything, whatever, just not this.”

Jake laughed. “Come on, it is hot. Do not be shy.”

I shook my head harder. “I am not shy. I just do not want to put on a show. And honestly, Jake, you are always talking about how you only watch lesbian porn because you do not want to see some dude fucking. So here is my counter. I will masturbate to lesbian porn right here in front of everyone if you watch gay porn completely naked in front of us. Same rules. No hiding. Let us see how you handle it.”

The room went quiet for a second, then erupted in laughter and cheers. Mia’s eyes lit up. “Oh I love this. Deal. Jake, you heard her. Strip and take your punishment.”

Jake looked surprised but tried to play it cool. “Fine. Whatever. I can handle it.”

He stood up and stripped naked. His cock was already half-hard from the earlier tension. We queued up a gay porn video, a hot scene with two muscular guys kissing and touching each other. Jake sat back down, fully exposed, as the video started.

Meanwhile I got comfortable in the big chair. I slid my shorts and panties off, spreading my legs so everyone could see. The lesbian porn played on the other half of the split screen. Two beautiful women were already going at it, one eating the other out with loud moans.

I started touching myself slowly. My fingers circled my clit while I watched the girls. I was already wet from the tension of the night. “Mmm, look at them,” I said, loud enough for Jake to hear. “So hot.”

Jake tried to stay composed as the two guys on his screen started sucking each other. One took the other’s cock deep into his mouth. Jake’s own cock twitched and hardened fully despite his efforts. “This is nothing,” he muttered, but his voice was strained.

I pushed two fingers inside my pussy and started fucking myself openly. Wet sounds filled the room from my side. “Fuck, she is really taking that tongue deep,” I moaned, eyes locked on the lesbian scene. My hips rocked against my hand. I pulled my top up and pinched my nipples, putting on a full show.

The group loved the contrast. Sarah cheered me on while Mia filmed a little on her phone for the memory. Tyler watched both of us with a big grin.

On Jake’s screen the guys moved to fucking. One bent the other over and slid his thick cock inside him. Jake’s hand unconsciously moved to his own dick and started stroking slowly. His face was flushed.

“Look at Jake,” I teased, pumping my fingers faster. “He is getting hard watching guys fuck. I thought you only liked lesbian porn.”

“Shut up,” Jake groaned, but he did not stop stroking. His cock was leaking precum now.

I was getting close. The sight of Jake naked and turned on by gay porn was strangely exciting. I rubbed my clit faster, moaning loudly. “I am going to cum while you watch those guys fuck each other.”

My orgasm hit hard. I cried out, thighs shaking as my pussy clenched around my fingers. A small squirt splashed onto the chair. I kept rubbing through it, riding every wave while staring at Jake.

Jake could not hold back either. The guy on screen was pounding the other one hard, loud moans coming from the TV. Jake stroked faster and suddenly came with a grunt. Thick ropes of cum shot across his stomach and chest. He kept pumping until he was empty, breathing heavily.

The group exploded with teasing.

“Jake just came to gay porn,” Mia laughed. “So much for only liking lesbians.”

Sarah smirked. “Looks like someone is a little bicurious after all.”

I was still catching my breath, legs spread and pussy dripping. “My turn was hotter,” I said with a smile. “I came harder because of the girls. But watching you lose it to guys was a nice bonus.”

Jake wiped himself off, still naked. “Whatever. It was just the video.”

Mia was not done. “Since both of you came, the night is just getting started. Jake, you stay naked. And now both of you are going to keep playing. Put on another round of porn. This time mixed scenes.”

I stayed in the chair and started touching myself again while a new lesbian video played. Jake had to watch another gay scene, still fully exposed. This time I made it more intense. I used the toy Sarah handed me, a thick realistic dildo. I sucked on it first, showing everyone, then slid it deep into my pussy and rode it facing Jake.

“Watch me fuck this while you watch those guys,” I moaned.

Jake got hard again quickly. His hand returned to his cock. The mutual exhibitionism turned the whole room on. Sarah and Mia started touching each other. Tyler stroked himself openly.

I rode the dildo harder, tits bouncing, moaning loudly. Jake stroked in rhythm, eyes flicking between me and his screen. The competition became pure filthy fun. I came twice more on the toy, loud and messy. Jake came again watching the guys, shooting another load across himself.

By the end of the session everyone was involved. Jake ended up fucking Mia while watching more gay porn. I rode Tyler while making out with Sarah. The lines blurred in the best way possible.

Hours later we were all exhausted and satisfied. Jake was quiet but smiling. I felt bold and empowered.

“See?” I said softly. “Sometimes a different reaction is more fun.”