Breakage of a Rule Results in Punishment

"We won, right?" Aayra said. "I mean, this round. We won this round. Right? Sarah's pillow touched Sam's head." she said.

"Yeah, you did." Jenna sulked.

"Ha-ha-ha!" All heads turned to Cassy. "Look what we have here," she looked at Sam and Sarah. Both were currently hiding their crotches. "Breakage of a rule. You can not hide yourself," she put her hands on her waist, "and both of them are currently doing so."

Everyone noticed.

"That means... the breakage of a rule has to result in..." she smiled deviously, "a punishment."

Aayra and Jenna chuckled. "Mmm hmmm!" Jenna said. "Me too." said Aayra.

"Hey!" Sam exclaimed. "No, see. I-- we weren't hiding ourselves. It was just a heavy fall. It hurt us. So, I was just..." he tried acting it out, he massaged his balls a bit and suddenly realized how utterly ridiculous the situation of being naked in front of five naked girls was, "...massaging it a bit. That's all. No breakage of rules, see." He lifted his hands. And all girls stared at his body.

He bit his lip. His willy wagged. He tried his level best to not drip in that moment. He failed. A thin stream of precum came out of his dick. Jenna pointed it out! "He's dripping!"

Cassy bit her lip, folding her hands. "Over so soon, eh Sam?" she asked, tapping her feet. "I thought you could resist more." She said with mischief in her eyes. "Does this turn you on? Being naked with five other naked girls? Does it turn you on seeing your batchmates like his, hm? Do you like this?" she said slowly, seductively.

His breathing started ragging again. "Look, it's just a biological..." he breathed, "...a biological response." Cassy looked at him like a little girl. Nodding at him with puppy eyes. Aayra and Jenna grinned mischievously. Anna was excited. He looked at Sarah. She still had her hands on her crotch.

"So, you're saying..." Cassy lifted her hands, untying her hairs, and tying them again, slowly. Deliberately. Her eyes looking at Sam's eyes, fixed. "You're saying... that... this... we... don't arouse you? Hm? Is that what you're saying, Sam?"

Sam's breaths ragged again. "No-- I mean--" he stuttered, the girls are enjoying this. "Stop it."

"Stop what, hm?" she put her hands behind her back. Sam looked at her breasts and licked his lips as they were dry as fuck. Then back into her eyes.

"Stop. Just stop."

Cassy looked into his eyes. Giving him the I know what you're going through and I'm fucking enjoying it look. Then, after a few seconds. She turned. "Alright. Since Sarah is the only one still hiding herself. She's the one who's gonna face the punishment."

"Hey!" Sam intervenes. "No. I meant-- for-- both of us."

"No." Cassy pointed at Sarah. "Look at her. Still her hands on her crotch. That doesn't look like her massaging her groin, at all."

"But--"

"No buts. Either you two face the punishment together, or just her. Since you provided us with a believable explanation... we shall let it pass." she said. "But not her." She pointed at Cassy.

"But what will the punishment be?" asked Jenna.

"A dare! A dare!" Anna replied and everyone looked to her as if it was an obvious response.