Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 8 by Wyvvernn Wyvvernn

What to do with Carrie?

Break the News

You walk down, hand in hand with your new girlfriend to your old one who hasn't even realized she has been replaced yet. Sitting there dutifully on the couch is Carrie. You sit down across from her, and make it so Carrie can't move. Then you jump behind the driver seat of Cassidy to taunt her.

"Hey Carrie, so Dave and I were thinking that it was time for an upgrade," you say, walking over to her, still naked. "And you've been replaced."

"Replaced?" Carrie asks, a bit confused.

"Yes. I will be Dave's new girlfriend and you're just going to be our plaything," you say with a smirk.

"What? You're leaving me for my sister?" Carrie asked, looking over at your body, but still unable to move.

"Yeah, she's way sexier than you," you respond with Cassidy, walking a circle around Carrie. "But that's okay. From now on, I think we will keep you as our little pet, hows that sound?"

"Well if that's what you want," she says, a bit flustered. "Anything for Dave."

"It's Cassidy. I'm also your boss now, big sis," you taunt, stepping in front of her. "You may call me mistress, and him master from now on."

Carrie looks up into you eyes and nods. "Yes Mistress."

"Good. Now, I'm going to have some fun with both puppets I own now, see what kind of changes I can make, so you just sit there dutifully and I'll see if you get anything from this," you say, walking over to Carrie's clothes she brought over. "Oh yeah, I'm going to need to borrow a few things just until I can order new clothes. I have a new job idea and it'll require a totally new wardrobe."

You search through Carrie's stuff till you find a tight black dress that seems perfect. You also find some bright red lingerie and put it on. With that, you sit down next to your own body. Jumping back into your own body, you stand up, with both Carrie's and Cassidy's eyes on you. You are ecstatic about your new girlfriend and what you plan to do with her, but for now you had some more things to do. What to do first though?

What do you do with the two of them?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)