Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4 by ManRayMansker ManRayMansker

What's next?

An Average Bull Fantasy

You lie back in the afterglow of your hands-free orgasm, the AI’s clinical verdict still glowing on your screen: perfectly average in every measurable category. Average length, average girth, average shape, average balls.

Ordinary.

And yet that single word unlocks something filthy inside you.

At first, the fantasy is almost tender. You picture Erin in the guest bedroom she sometimes shares with Nick when they visit. She’s frustrated again Nick’s micropenis slipping out for the third time, too small to stay inside her during even gentle missionary.

In your mind you knock softly, step inside as the supportive stepfather, and offer to help. Erin’s eyes light up with relief and hunger when she sees the ordinary but functional cock tenting your pants. She sends Nick to the corner chair with a single command: “Watch how a real man does it.”You slide into her slowly, feeling her slick walls actually stretch and grip you. Erin moans a real, throaty sound Nick has never earned and wraps her legs around your waist. “Finally,” she breathes against your ear. “Something I can actually feel.”

You rock into her with steady, average strokes, hitting depths Nick can never reach. The fantasy stays almost romantic for the first few minutes: deep kissing, eye contact, her hands caressing your back while Nick strokes his 1.5-inch soft nub in humiliated silence.

You imagine flipping Erin onto all fours right in front of Nick. Her heavy tits swing as you mount her from behind, your average cock sliding home with a wet slap. This time you’re not gentle. You grip her hips and fuck her properly long, firm strokes that make her ass ripple and her pussy cream down your shaft.

Erin’s moans turn pornographic. “Yes—fuck—right there! Nick never hits that spot!” You look over at your stepson and smirk while you rail his fiancée, your balls slapping her clit on every thrust. Nick’s tiny prick is rock-hard at its pathetic maximum, leaking clear fluid as he watches you stretch the woman he can’t satisfy.You talk to him while you fuck her. “This is what she needs, buddy. A cock that actually fills her up.”

Erin pushes back onto you eagerly, cunt squelching obscenely around your average thickness. She cums hard, gushing down your balls, and you don’t stop pounding her through it until she’s babbling.

You have Erin riding you reverse cowgirl on the bed while Nick kneels beside it, face inches from the action. Your average cock disappears into her soaked pussy over and over, coated in her creamy juices. Every time you bottom out she grinds her clit against you and moans your name. You reach around to rub her swollen nub while ordering Nick, “Hold her ass open wider so I can watch how a proper dick stretches her.”

Erin squirts for the second time, spraying Nick’s face and chest while she screams. You pull out and slap your wet cock against her gaping hole, then shove back in balls-deep. “Tell him whose pussy this is now,” you growl. Erin looks straight at Nick, eyes glazed with lust: “It’s his. My stepdad’s average cock owns this cunt now.” You flood her with thick ropes of cum, pumping load after load deep inside while Nick whimpers and leaks onto the floor without permission to touch himself.Six hundred words and the depravity escalates. In the expanded fantasy you film it. Erin sets up her phone while you fuck her in every position Nick has failed in. You make her describe the difference out loud for the camera: “Nick’s micropenis feels like a finger. This cock… fuck… it actually fills me. I can feel his balls slapping my clit. I’m going to cum again—watch me cum on a real dick, baby!” She squirts a third time while you **** her lightly and rail her prone-bone style, your hips smacking loudly against her ass.You pull out and paint her face with the last of your load while Nick is **** to watch every spurt land on his fiancée’s tongue. Then you make him clean her up licking your cum from Erin’s well-fucked pussy while you stroke your spent but still-thick cock beside them. Erin reaches back and spreads herself obscenely, moaning, “Thank your stepdad for finally satisfying me.”

You imagine a full weekend of it. Erin sneaks into your room every night while Tawny sleeps, dropping to her knees to worship your average cock—the first cock she’s been able to deepthroat in years. She gags happily, tears running down her cheeks as she forces more of you down her throat than Nick’s entire erection could ever provide. You fuck her face until she’s a drooling mess, then bend her over the bathroom counter and pound her while Nick listens through the wall, jerking his tiny prick.The climax of the fantasy has Erin riding you in the marital bed, Tawny somehow approving and watching from the chair. Erin bounces frantically, tits flopping, screaming about how your perfectly average dick is ruining her for micropenis forever. You fill her womb again and again, then make her sit on Nick’s face so he can taste exactly how thoroughly you’ve claimed her.

Now, you’re hard again, stroking slowly to the vivid mental images. Perfectly average. Perfectly capable of turning the woman your stepson can’t satisfy into a cum-drunk slut who begs for more. The ordinary cock your wife has always praised is now, in your mind, a weapon of delicious cuckold **** and raw sexual satisfaction.You cum a second time just picturing Erin’s face when she finally experiences a proper orgasm mouth open, eyes rolling back, pussy pulsing around the one thing Nick will never be: enough.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)