Amber

What do you have to fear? You've already done more with Amber than anyone else. You make a bee line straight for her. As you approach her she turns and sees you coming. She gives a wry smile and high pitched and gleeful yell and jumps into you as you get close enough. Instinctively you catch her around her waist and she wraps her legs around you anchoring herself to you and kisses you deeply. You respond likewise quickly tasting that she has done some pre-gaming before your arrival.

After what feels like a blissful eternity she stops kissing you and slides her legs back down to the ground. "Hi! I'm so happy you're here! Let me introduce you to my new friends! They're twins! Ohh...I think I forgot which is which"

You break your gaze from Amber to look at the pair and actually recognize them from high school. They are Josie and Jackie Schmidtz. They were in your grade in theory but missed a lot of school for various hockey camps and competitions. The youngest of four from a line of hockey stars. Josie is the nice twin and Jackie is pure evil. Both were equally your crush in high school, along with probably every other boy in your grade. One was in pink and the other in blue but you couldn't tell them apart at the moment.

"That's Josie and that's Jackie" you say confidently but honestly guessing "we played hockey together at the local ring."

Josie smiles while Jackie retorts "lucky guess."

"Oh you know each other! That's sweet!" Amber adds, seemingly oddly enthused about it. "That'll make tonight more fun! Go grab us some drinks." Before you can object twin in pink comments "Don't worry about being a square. They're non-alcoholic. One of the softball players is a chemistry major and came up with it. She calls it Truth Serum."

"So we're going to play truth or dare!" Amber cheers. "Are you in?"