All three girls?

You look at the three nerdy girls, your brain short-circuiting under pressure. After a second of awkward silence you just blurt it out:

“Uh… all of you?”

The room goes dead quiet for a beat.

The tiny girl in the Harry Potter shirt drops her dice. The big-chested girl behind the stack of books blushes furiously. The wiry girl with braces and freckles just stares at you with wide eyes before a slow, excited grin spreads across her face.

“...All three of us?” the tiny girl squeaks.

You nod, deciding to lean into the chaos. “Look, I know this sounds insane, but I’m in a stupid bet and I desperately need worn panties. And… well, you’re all really cute. So yeah. All of you. If you’re down.”

The three girls exchange glances, blushing hard. In a school with almost no boys, the idea that a guy wants to fuck three nerdy girls is way to enticing, and being called cute was not helping them resist.

The big-chested girl fidgets with her hands, her massive tits jiggling slightly as she shifts. “I… I’ve never done anything like this before, but… okay. Also I'm Abgail”

The girl with braces laughs nervously but looks thrilled. “I'm Grace, and please tell me this is for real!” She squeals.

The tiny one fidgets with her hair, she trys to look tough but is blushing hard. “F-fine, I'll go along with everyone. Just don’t be weird about it! And call me Hannah.”

Grace claps her hands together. “LARPing room is empty right now. It’s literally two doors down and has a lock.”