A horror movie

The next movie they watched was a cheesy horror movie, one that broke the usual tropes of virgins being safe from the killer while the non-virgins got killed. Instead, in this movie, the virgins were doomed.

The story was about a bunch of college age girls who got together and talked about the legend of a killer called Madman Jack. Supposedly, if a group of girls got together and said his name three times, he would appear and kill all the virgins. They didn't believe the legend, so they all said his name three times. And then, there was a pounding at the door. The girls screamed and ran off in different directions. Madman Jack killed one pretty quickly and then another. Some of the girls went home and thought they were safe. But the next night, even at their homes, Madman Jack would appear. He killed three more girls, leaving only one left. "Come here, little virgin," called out Madman Jack, but the last remaining girl drove off and found her boyfriend. She explained the situation, but he didn't believe her. She begged him to fuck her as Madman Jack became visible in the distance. He eventually agreed, and they started fucking. Madman Jack raced up to them, knife drawn, just as they reached climax at the same time. Madman Jack then screamed and faded away to nothing.

"So, Blake, what if Madman Jack was chasing you?" asked Liz. "Would you go running to Steve and beg him to fuck you?"

You reply, "Well, I mean, if I had to, to save my life, I guess I would."

The other girls all laugh.