John’s breathing was slow and deep. After a short break, Erin had counted up to ten, spanking Taylor each time and each time Taylor would massage John’s dick while pressing herself harder against the wall and pushing him slightly deeper.

The wall shook and Taylor yelped as John was pushed as deep as possible with the wall between them. Then Taylor’s legs closed around him again, making her ever tighter as Erin stage whispered, “You know, now that I’ve calmed down a little, and since you seem to be a little masochistic slut, I think I might just continue taking some of my frustrations out on you. How’s that sound?”

Without waiting for an answer, Taylor was pulled away from the wall, freeing John’s cock to the cool washroom air. It was only a moment before a hand grabbed him and lined him up before he was inside of someone again.

“Now, I want you to know something. Mr mystery man behind the wall might have his dick inside of you, but you’d better remember that it’s me that’s fucking you, do you hear me?” Erin growled.

Taylor whimpered. The wall shook again as her ass hit it. Both John and Taylor’s moans increased in volume as Erin continued her rough treatment. “This is what you deserve, being used as a toy. I could tell everyone all of your dirty secrets and fantasies. You all judge me because I don’t hide what I do or think, at least I haven’t fucked anyone for money or good grades.”

“W-what? O-oh! I’ve n-never done that,” Taylor defended herself between moans.

“No, no, you haven’t, but you know someone who has. Not that I’d tell you who,” Erin divulged. “But you know what, I know you’ve got yourself off in the bathroom before, and not just this one in the privacy of our room but in the public bathrooms too.”

Taylor and John’s moans grew increasingly. John could only just follow the conversation despite how hard it had become to concentrate. He could vaguely hear them talking but he was too focused on how he was feeling and how Taylor’s pussy began to milk him for all he was worth. John began knocking on the wall and Taylor was pulled from him once more.

His dick twitched and bobbed in the cool air and John felt disappointed as each throb drew him further back from the orgasm he was approaching.

“Oh, look at it go, I think you were seconds away from getting a nice thick creampie. I’d say it’s a shame, but you don’t deserve it. Don’t worry, big guy, I won’t leave you disappointed. You’re gonna fill me up nicely,” Erin cooed.

John throbbed again as he felt a heavy breath against his dick. He panted, still feeling disappointed that he wasn’t able to cum. John had tuned everything out, just barely hearing mumbling from the other side of the wall, but eventually his focus came back.

“I’m getting pretty tired of you all slut shaming me. I don’t have anything to hide, I can tell you the names of both the other guys I slept with, and list the names of the girls I’ve fooled around with. I have no hang-ups when it comes to my sex life,” Erin argued, obviously annoyed again.

There was mumbling from the other side of the wall, but John only caught the word, “Sorry,” a couple of times.

“I don’t really hold grudges, but I’d expect you to respect me enough to take my word on things, and if you can’t even do that, I’m not sure we should call each other friends anymore,” Erin said, her tone sad. John wasn’t sure what he’d missed, but he felt a little bad.

Erin cleared her throat and her voice picked back up, “Doesn’t matter… get down here, we’re both gonna get a taste of his dick covered in your sweet, sweet nectar.”

“I didn’t mean… Uhm, let me just have a second,” Taylor huffed. The sound of heavy measured breathing cut through the quiet of the washroom and once it was steady, John heard movement. “You know, that was really hot. I’ve never had sex with someone's boyfriend in front of them before, and I hadn’t even imagined being encouraged to do it. I’m not sure if this is the right word but doesn’t that make you like a cuck or something?”

Erin growled. “Are you intentionally trying to push my buttons? First off, he’s not cheating because we. Are. Not. Together. Not only that but like I said before I was the one fucking and using you. Know what, I don’t care, just shut the fuck up and listen to me.”

The sound of the toilet flush from the stall next door almost entirely drowned out the whispering. As the sound of rushing water faded, John caught the end of the instruction, “Just kiss me.”

John breathed in deeply, his cheek pressed against the wall as he tried to focus on listening, expecting to hear the sound of the two girls making out. John let out a yelp from surprise and pleasure when two sets of lips kissed the tip of his dick.

A groan rumbled in John’s chest as the two girls opened their mouths, allowing their lips to make contact around his dick. Their tongues explored his dick as they searched for each other, making him moan again.

The girls moved downwards, their moans sending vibrations through his shaft. As they moved, their tongues lashed out at each other while simultaneously licking him clean.

They continued moving until they reached the base of his cock then they began to slowly move back and forth in unison. A thought occurred to him, making him wonder if it was just amazing or if being unable to see enhanced the experience that much.

John was enjoying the feeling of both girls and let out a grunt of annoyance as they pulled away from him. “Okay, I’m super wet now, and I need this inside of me,” Erin said, hunger in her voice.

Taylor whined and kissed the tip of his dick one last time before reluctantly pulling away. Erin laughed and spoke again, “Finally being truthful to what you want? Unfortunately, he’s all mine now.”

A soft hand gripped his dick and the tip slipped inside of Erin, accompanied by her moaning in approval as she pushed herself further and further back. Both girls felt amazing but in very different ways.

Due to what Erin had been doing, Taylor’s pussy would twitch and massage his dick the entire time, she was wet enough to allow him to move but there was enough resistance to stimulate him perfectly.

Erin on the other hand was tighter, providing a constant and pleasurable pressure all around him. Erin was wetter which allowed him to slide in and out of her with ease and there was a noticeable increase in temperature inside Erin.

Moving at a moderate pace, John found himself letting out a long moan. She took advantage of his entire length, pulling almost all the way off him before sinking back until her ass pressed against the wall and then grinded herself back, sending a shiver through John’s body from the additional stimulation.

“Hey, get here and kiss me, and maybe play with my nipples a little too,” Erin ordered, pausing to moan. “I won’t leave you out, though, don’t-”

Erin was cut off and the sound of the two girls moaning into each other as they made out made John’s dick throb. All the excitement John had been through and with how close he’d gotten when he was fucking Taylor brought his orgasm quickly and John began knocking on the wall.

Erin moaned then the sound of kissing stopped. “Fuck, that was a little quicker than I expected. Don’t pull out, I wanna enjoy this as long as I can. Maybe feeling you cum inside me will get me over the edge too.”

The kissing continued, and Erin began to fuck him a little faster. His fingers tightened on the wall and he let out a drawn-out moan as he began cumming, at which point Erin slammed herself backwards pressing herself against the wall.

“Fuck, that feels amazing. You always cum so much, it feels like you just gave me a year's worth,” Erin purred. “Quick, Taylor, get on the floor. Don’t let any of this go to waste, plus you owe me for getting you off earlier so you’re going to eat me out until I cum.”

“I-” Taylor started then cut herself off. “Okay.”

There was a shuffling sound, then John felt a tongue brush against his dick, cleaning him off as Erin pulled away from the wall. The sensation made John shiver and sigh.

Both Erin and Taylor’s moans were accompanied by the wet sound of Taylor pleasuring Erin. “Fuck, wait, what’s that!? No! N-never mind, don’t stop,” Erin’s voice sounded a little panicked.

“I need to sit down, follow me,” Erin stuttered. “Hey, b-big guy, you can take off now, I’ll text you. Make sure to put the cover back on the hole.”

John did as Erin asked, covering the glory hole again, and huffed to steady his breathing. He put his clothing back on, and unlatched the door, slipping out.

As he came to the threshold between the washroom and main space of the club room, John stopped. He noticed a pile of clothing which seemed to have been shuffled under the toilet stall door.

He knelt down and shuffled through the cloth before finding a pair of pink Calvin Klein bikini briefs and a pair of lavender hipsters with lace hems and a little bow on the front. Both pairs of underwear had an expected damp patch on the front, the hipsters being slightly dryer.

’Should I really do this? They’re gonna know who took them… Eh, if they want them back, Erin can ask. It’s not like they have to spend the entire day pantieless, schools almost over,’_ John reasoned internally, stashing the panties in his inventory.

He stood and was about to exit the washroom when he received a text message.

< E: Is this what I think it is? What do I do? >

Attached was a picture, the back of a girl's head, her red hair intertwined in Erin’s fingers, but one thing stood out, a glowing ring marking on her finger. Quickly John looked at his hand, the ring he had now adorned with two brighter spots which simulated the gems in a ring, the original was white, but now next to it was a purple spot.

Erin had already made it clear that she wasn’t in an actual relationship with him. ’Calm down, nothing has to change, only people that know about magic would even know, right?’ he thought. Taking another breath to calm himself down, he sent a message back.

< J: Don’t panic, just imagine the ring vanishing. I’m sorry, I didn’t mean for this to happen, I don’t even know what causes it. I know it’s a lot, but we can talk about it later, just enjoy yourself for now I guess? >

A laugh came from the stall, which caused John to continue out of the room, entering the hallway he got another message.

< E: Thank you and HUSBAND I'm sure everything will work out so I guess we shouldn’t worry too much >

’Why does everyone seem to take these things much better than I do? This should be something to be concerned about at least, shouldn’t it?’ he thought. Shaking his head he closed the club room door behind him and stressed a little as he began to power walk towards the exit of the school.

I hope you all enjoyed the chapter and I'd love to hear your thoughts. Engagement means a lot to me and my comment section, discord channels and DMs are all open to hear what you have to say.

If you enjoyed the latest chapter, a quick LIKE would be super appreciated. Thanks a bunch!

For those who really enjoy my work, please consider supporting me monetarily. Your contributions go towards commissioned artwork and keeping my creative juices flowing. You can make a one-time tip or become a Member on Buy Me A Coffee. Members get access to early chapters and updates on commissioned art.

I'd like to express a heartfelt thanks to all who support me. Your backing is invaluable, and I'm deeply grateful for it. You are all extremely appreciated.

Atreides
Mekkosadx
Demoncet
And the other members that prefer not to be named