Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 12 by sopagettingslippyuh sopagettingslippyuh

What's next?

18th Birthday part 11

"Noo, let's go outside. The others are probably waiting already." Sophie nodded and head out. Anni followed her and I looked at my collection of new sex toys for a second. Then I put the boxes down on my bed and left my room too.

Leni, Liz and Eric were already in the hot tub. One of them seemed to have found the control for the jets as the water was now bubbling and the lights of the pool, brightened the close surroundings. Sophie was standing near the pool in my shirt and her panties. Anni was still completely dressed. "I'm... Not comfortable right now...", she said as Sophie began pulling my shirt off. "Oh, come on Anni nobody would judge you. Oh, there you are.", Sophie waved me over. "Come on Ava, tell her to come in too.", she said as she began climbing into the pool. "You can keep your underwear on like me."
"You're not even wearing a bra.", Anni replied. Sophie stopped in her movements and looked down. "Oh, well. You're right, but you can keep yours on if you like.", Sophie said. Her nipples began to stiffen as goosebumps formed on her skin. The air was really cool. "Ava, what about you? Are you not coming in?", she asked me, and I remembered I was part of the action. "I am. Wait.", I replied and walked over to Anni. "I can tell them to keep their eyes shut until you're in. Or you could just follow me around the corner and undress there.", I whispered. Anni looked into my eyes. "Can you come with me? I don't want to undress here in front of everyone.", I nodded and we hushed into the shadow of my dad's tool shed.

I got rid of my hoodie and shirt and piled them up neatly. "Could you help me with my bra?", I asked and turned around. She quickly unclasped it, so I pulled it off and put it on the pile of my clothes. Behind me, I could hear Anni removing her sweater. I turned around and saw my best friend's back. I, too, unclasped her bra and carefully stripped it off her arms. Anni didn't turn around. In fact, she didn't move at all. Thinking it was a hint, I unzipped her skirt and it fell to the ground. Anni shrieked, jumped and turned around. "I'm sorry, I thought-" "I was just taking time. Fuck, Ava...", she slowly began to relax. "Well, I guess it doesn't matter any more then.", she removed her hand from her crotch and only then I realized she hasn't put her panty back on. "I think it's still behind your couch somewhere.", she said and looked down. I chuckled a bit. "Look", I said, and pulled my skirt down myself. "I don't have one on either, but psst. Don't tell that around." She smirked and took my hand. We walked back to the others and climbed in the water as well.

"Now you are the one that's overdressed.", Anni jokingly said to Sophie. "But I'm not the only one.", Sophie retorted, "Eric still has his boxer shorts on as well." Turns out he pulled his pants back up when I left. I frowned at him, but he just shrugged. He was sitting next to Liz and Leni. Liz was closest to the pool's ladder. I sat down between Leni and Sophie, and Anni sat down next to Sophie on the other side of the ladder. Yes, it was cramped. Yes, the tub was designed for about four people max. We all had a laugh and drank some more.

It was almost beginning to dawn when the conversations got a little stale and Sophie suggest we played truth or dare. "Nah, the interesting questions have been asked already, and we're naked already, what else is there to do?", Anni complained. Sophie, who had raised her hand as if she was in school, looked a bit disappointed and put her hand back down. But not on her lap, no, it was now on mine. I glanced over to her. She didn't even seem to realize. Or she was just good at hiding it. I didn't say anything. Somehow this felt exciting, having a girl's hand so close to my... But then there was Eric. "How about we just skip the truths and just do the dares?", Leni proposed, "and if an interesting question comes up, we just dare us to say the truth." Everyone except Anni liked the idea, so we started. Rock, paper, scissors decided who starts. Leni won. "It's not a game of luck.", she said, "I dare you, Eric, to take your boxer shorts off." Eric sighed. "I should've expected this to happen." "Yes you should've.", Leni, Liz and Sophie said in a choir. Eric stood up and pulled his boxer shorts down in a quick movement. He then stepped out of them, trying not to break his own ankles without stepping on some of ours, and held them up. "You happy?", he asked as he turned to Leni. "Yeah", she said, and flicked her finger against his dick. "Softie-" I knew what she wanted to say, but Eric wet underwear landed over her face before she could say anything. We laughed and Leni threw the underwear over her shoulders. "Your turn big boy.", She said and laid back. "OK, Sophie, do as I did then we're all equal.", he said. "But what about-", Anni started but was interrupted by Sophie stretching her legs up and pulling her French cut panty down to her knees. "Can somebody help? I can't reach further down.", she said, acting all innocent while waving her underwear in front of Eric. He reached forward and pulled it over her feet. He made a move as if he wanted to throw it over his shoulder as well, but Sophie stopped him. "No, keep it. I don't want it to get dirty." With that, she pushed her hand further between my thighs and began caressing my legs a little. The bubbles may have hidden what she was doing, but I may be wrong as well and everybody might have seen what was going on.

"I dareee, Liz, you stand up and turn around and let us all spank you." I looked at Sophie. She was acting kind of weird, and somehow sex driven all of a sudden. Maybe she was just drunk too and I overthought thinks like I usually do. Either way, Liz quietly stood up and turned around. Leni didn't let a second pass and gave Liz a hard spank on the ass. Eric leaned forward and did the same. He jumped a little in his seat just as he leaned back. Leni was smiling mischievously at him, but I couldn't make out what was happening under the water's bubbling surface. Then, Sophie broke my strain of thoughts when she leaned forward, supported her weight on my thigh and slipped off, resulting in her hand smacking against my pussy. I winced and jumped slightly. She excused herself and spanked Liz' ass. "I'm sorry", she repeated as her hands caressed my, now very sensitive, crotch. I whimpered a little but enjoyed her touches. Eric made a similar face to mine and Leni but her lower lip, while Anni finished the turn by smacking Liz' ass. It has turned red by now, and Liz was very careful when sitting down.

Now there was silence. Well, the bubbles bursting on the water's surface still were quite audible, but everyone was waiting for Liz' turn. "I can't think of a dare...", Liz said, so Leni again whispered something in her ear. They both smiled mischievously and looked at Anni.

"Anni I dare you to tell us if Eric's... Cock... is bigger than your boyfriends." Anni rolled her eyes. "OK Eric, stand up, so I can see your prick.", she said as she got closer to him. "With closed eyes.", Liz added. Anni turned to her and Leni. "How am I- Ooh, fuck you two.", she said. "Alright Eric. Sit back, relax, let me handle this." Eric looked a bit overwhelmed as one of the most popular girls was now between his legs, naked, while he was also naked. Anni put her hands out, closed her eyes and wrapped her hand around Eric dick. She moved them along his shaft a little until she said, "No." Eric looked disappointed, and Leni saw. "Are you sure?", she asked. Anni removed her hands completely from his crotch and got back to her seat. "Yes."

"Leni, it's your turn. Tell us if Eric is bigger than your boyfriend.", Anni said with a smirk. "I don't have a boyfriend.", Leni retorted. "Well, then tell us if he is bigger than your exes.", Anni said. Leni reached down to Eric's crotch, but before she could answer, Anni stopped her. "Nonono. You are not allowed to use hands or eyes.", she smirked, "Since you don't seem to trust your hands that much."

"Oh, I see where this is going... Eric, you OK with this?", Leni said, knowing how he feels about consent.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)