"How about a third girlfriend?”

“We could work with this, actually.” Taylor says.

“How so?” Megan asks.

“Well, for one, she’s technically our coach. She’s also the girl’s P.E. teacher.”

“So…?”

“So having her on our side would be very beneficial to us.” Taylor grins.

“Isn’t she already on our side, though?” Megan asks.

“Only as cheerleaders. She wants to be one of us, which is honestly quite pathetic, so she let’s us get away with anything. However, if she’s in love with John, she might object to things that involve him.” Taylor explains.

“Such as…” Megan trails off, not following.

“Such as skipping P.E. for a little private time, covering for us, and other things.”

“Oh! I get it!” Megan says. You mentally agree, keeping quiet to see how things unfold.

“So Babe,” Taylor looks at you. “I bet you’d love a third girlfriend, wouldn’t you?”

Before you can vocalize your thoughts, your dick answers for you by getting rock hard again.

“It seems he would!” Megan says with a happy giggle, eyes locked to your cock.

“I mean… I… I don’t know.” You answer. You thought it would be possible, but you didn’t think Taylor would just outright suggest it. “Would you be okay with it?” You ask tentatively.

“Yeah, I would!” Megan says. “I told you I didn’t mind sharing you. Actually, I think I actually like it! So as long as you still pay attention to me, I’m all for it!”

Megan’s answer surprises you. Even more shockingly, Taylor nods.

“Since you started fucking Megan as well, you’ve gotten even better and it’s only been like a day and a half. You last a lot more and make us cum consistently.” She tells you analytically. “If we look at it as putting more weight on dumbbells, another girl can only be a plus. Besides…” She trails off, biting her lip and giving you a smoldering look. “Watching you fuck Megan made me so hot. And… thinking of you fucking Heather too…” She doesn’t finish her sentence.

You see the face of lust on both of your girlfriends. You realize that your changes might have been more than you intended, but if they lead to this, all the better.

“Do you think she’ll agree?” She will, you can make that happen. Still, you ask their opinion.

Taylor looks to Megan. “What do you think?”

“Hard to say,” Megan admits. “But if she loves you as much as we do, she’ll agree. Especially after you use this.” She trails a finger from the base of your dick to the tip.

“So? Are you in?” Taylor asks you.