Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 17 by fantaghiro fantaghiro

What's next?

the trip

Tom had barely made it home and into bed when exhaustion claimed him. The next few days blurred together in a haze of anticipation and dread. Work was a distraction he couldn't maintain. Every time his phone buzzed, his heart jumped—expecting Charity or Ellie, expecting complications.

Wednesday evening, a group text arrived from Will: "Cabin's all set! 3 bedrooms, hot tub, hiking trails nearby. You're gonna love it, man. Leaving 8am Friday. Pack warm!"

Tom stared at the message. Three bedrooms. Will and Charity in one. Ellie in another. Him in the third. Walls between them, but Sarah's consciousness flowing through two of those rooms, aware of everything, capable of coordinating her two bodies with perfect precision.

Thursday night, another text, this time from an unknown number that he now recognized as Sarah's burner contact: "Ellie's been teasing Will all day about being excited for the trip. He has no idea she's excited to sneak into your room. —C"

Tom typed back: "This is insane. We're going to get caught."

The response came immediately: "Not if we're careful. And isn't that part of the thrill? —E"

Friday morning arrived too quickly. Tom packed his bag with shaking hands—clothes, toiletries, the coin tucked into a hidden pocket of his jacket. He couldn't leave it behind. Didn't dare.

Will's SUV pulled into his driveway at 8:03 AM. Tom grabbed his bag and headed out.

Will was driving, grinning like a kid going to summer camp. "Ready for this?"

"As I'll ever be," Tom said, tossing his bag in the back.

Charity sat in the passenger seat, turning to give him a warm smile. "It'll be good for you, Tom. Fresh air, good company."

Ellie was in the back seat, earbuds in, scrolling her phone. She glanced up as Tom climbed in beside her, and her lips curved into the barest hint of a smirk before she looked back down.

The drive was three hours north, into the mountains. Will dominated the conversation, talking about the trails, the cabin's amenities, his plans for grilling steaks. Charity chimed in periodically, playing the perfect wife, occasionally reaching over to squeeze Will's shoulder.

In the back seat, Ellie's leg pressed against Tom's. Just a subtle touch, easily dismissed as the cramped space, but he knew better. He glanced at her. She didn't look up from her phone, but her smirk deepened.

Tom shifted, trying to put distance between them. Her leg followed, maintaining contact.

An hour into the drive, Ellie stretched, arching her back in a way that made her chest press against her fitted t-shirt. "I'm bored," she announced, pulling out her earbuds.

"We're not even halfway there, sweetie," Charity said without turning around.

"Can we stop? I need to pee."

Will sighed but nodded. "There's a rest stop in about ten miles."

When they pulled in, Ellie hopped out immediately, heading toward the restrooms. Charity turned to Tom. "I could use a break too. Tom, you mind grabbing me a coffee from the vending machines? Black, two sugars."

"Sure," Tom said, climbing out.

Will stayed with the car, checking his phone. Tom headed toward the building, and Charity fell into step beside him. Once they were out of Will's line of sight, her hand brushed his.

"Ellie's going to come to your room tonight," she said quietly, voice low. "Around midnight. Will sleeps like the dead after a few beers, and I'll make sure he has a few."

"Charity—"

"Don't." She stopped, turning to face him. "I know this is complicated. I know it's wrong. But I need this, Tom. Both of me needs this." Her eyes searched his. "Please. Just... play along. Enjoy the trip. Enjoy us."

Before he could respond, she walked ahead toward the vending machines, all business again.

Tom stood frozen, then followed, grabbing her coffee and one for himself. By the time they returned to the SUV, Ellie was already back, looking refreshed and innocent.

The rest of the drive was ****. Every glance from Charity in the rearview mirror, every accidental brush of Ellie's hand against his, every laugh and casual comment—it was all foreplay, all loaded with meaning that only he and Sarah understood.

They arrived at the cabin just before noon. It was beautiful—rustic wood exterior, surrounded by tall pines, a deck with a view of the mountains. Inside, it was cozy and well-appointed. Three bedrooms on the upper floor, kitchen and living area downstairs, and the hot tub out back.

"Pick your room, Tom," Will said, hauling bags inside. "We're taking the master, Ellie usually likes the one with the window seat."

That left the smallest room for Tom, tucked at the end of the hall. Furthest from Will and Charity. Closest to Ellie.

Of course.

They spent the afternoon settling in, then went on a short hike. The mountain air was crisp, the scenery stunning. Tom tried to lose himself in the beauty of it, the normalcy of hiking with his best friend. But every time Ellie scrambled over a rock ahead of him, her ass perfectly framed by her leggings, or Charity laughed at one of Will's jokes, leaning into him affectionately, Tom was reminded of the surreal duality.

That evening, Will grilled steaks while Charity prepared sides in the kitchen. Ellie set the table, moving past Tom with deliberate slowness, her hip brushing his.

Dinner was excellent. Will opened a bottle of wine, then another. Charity kept his glass full, nursing her own. Ellie drank soda, complaining half-heartedly about not being old enough for wine.

After dinner, they played cards. Will grew louder, more boisterous as the **** hit. By ten, he was yawning, eyes heavy.

"I'm beat," he announced. "Long drive, good food, good company. I'm calling it."

Charity stood, stretching. "Me too. You guys okay cleaning up?"

"We got it, Mom," Ellie said, already gathering plates.

Tom helped Ellie load the dishwasher, hyperaware of her proximity, the scent of her shampoo, the curve of her neck. She didn't speak, just worked efficiently, occasionally glancing at him with those knowing eyes.

When they finished, Ellie yawned theatrically. "I'm gonna read for a bit, then crash. Night, Tom."

"Night."

He retreated to his room, heart pounding. He showered, changed into sleep pants and a t-shirt, then sat on the bed, staring at the door.

Minutes crawled by. Eleven o'clock. Eleven-thirty. Midnight.

A soft knock.

Tom opened the door. Ellie stood there in an oversized sleep shirt that barely covered her thighs, her hair loose around her shoulders.

"Can I come in?" she whispered.

He stepped aside. She slipped past him, and he closed the door, turning the lock as quietly as possible.

Ellie turned to face him, and the playful teenager mask dropped away, revealing raw hunger beneath. "I've been thinking about this all day," she breathed. "Feeling you next to me in the car, watching you during dinner, knowing that in a few hours I'd be here, alone with you."

"Will is right down the hall," Tom hissed.

"Charity made sure he drank enough. He's out cold. She's in bed next to him, wide awake, feeling everything I'm about to feel." Ellie stepped closer, hands sliding up his chest. "She's as turned on as I am, Tom. Lying there next to your best friend while I'm here about to fuck you."

Tom's resolve shattered. His hands gripped her hips, pulling her against him. She gasped, rising on her toes to kiss him, and he devoured her mouth, all pretense of restraint gone.

Ellie's hands tugged at his shirt. He pulled it over his head, then grabbed the hem of her sleep shirt, dragging it up and off. She wore nothing underneath. Her body was perfect—firm tits with dusky pink nipples, smooth skin, the barest strip of hair above her pussy.

"Bed," she whispered urgently. "And keep quiet. We can't let him hear."

Tom backed her toward the bed, and she fell onto it, spreading her legs in invitation. He shoved his sleep pants down, cock already hard and leaking.

"No foreplay," Ellie breathed. "Just fuck me. I need to feel you inside me."

Tom positioned himself, the head of his cock pressing against her entrance. She was soaking wet, ready. He thrust in, burying himself to the hilt in one smooth stroke.

Ellie's eyes went wide, mouth falling open in a silent cry. Tom clapped a hand over her mouth, leaning down to whisper in her ear. "Quiet."

She nodded frantically, and he began to move, slow deep thrusts that made her body arch beneath him. Her hands clawed at his back, her legs wrapping around his waist, pulling him deeper.

The bed creaked softly. Tom froze, listening. No sounds from down the hall. He resumed his rhythm, fucking Ellie with controlled intensity, swallowing her moans with his mouth.

His phone, discarded on the nightstand, lit up with a text. Tom glanced at it mid-thrust.

"She feels so good around you. I can feel how wet she is, how full. Don't stop. Make her come. Make ME come. —C"

The knowledge that Charity was lying in bed next to Will, feeling every sensation of Ellie's body being fucked, sent Tom over the edge. He pounded into Ellie harder, chasing his orgasm.

Ellie bit down on his shoulder to muffle her scream as she came, pussy clamping around him. Tom followed seconds later, spilling inside her, hips jerking as he emptied himself.

They collapsed together, panting, sweat-slicked. Ellie's phone buzzed on the floor. She reached for it, read the message, and laughed breathlessly.

"What?" Tom whispered.

She showed him the screen. A message from Charity to both of them: "That was incredible. Same time tomorrow night. But next time, I'm coming too. Literally. —C&E"

Tom stared at the message, then at Ellie's flushed, satisfied face, and realized the vacation had barely begun.

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)