pulled out,

the look of Haley's ass too tempting to resist. He pushed the head of his cock against her sphincter, rubbing it up and down to spread their combined juices around her asshole. "Daddy, what are you doing?" Haley asked, looking over her shoulder.

"I just have to try this," Phil said, using one hand to guide his cock, the fingers pressing the head against her asshole. "Your mom has never let me do this."

Haley bit her lip nervously. She had never even thought about someone wanting to put something in there, but her dad seemed determined.

He kept pressing, and Haley's eyes opened in pain as her ass was stretched for the first time. Phil took it slow, not wanting to cum too soon, and not wanting to hurt Haley, but he desperately needed to get inside her.

Then the head popped in, and with a little persistence, the shaft followed soon after. Haley gasped as her father steadily pushed his cock into her, pushed until his pubic hair pressed against the smooth skin of her ass.

"Oh, god, this is tight," he moaned, his hand going back to her hips before moving her again, watching his cock as it sank into Haley's stretched ass.

Phil didn't last long. He had been close to cumming when his cock was in her pussy, and her ass was tighter. He managed three thrusts before driving his entire length into her, his cock spasming, painting the walls of her colon with sperm.

He collapsed onto Haley's back, his hands sliding from her hips to cup her small breasts, kneading her nipples between his fingertips.

"That hurt a bit daddy," Haley pouted.

"Don't worry, baby," Phil responded. "It won't hurt that bad next time."

Haley thrilled at the thought of her dad having sex with her again, even if he wanted to put it back in her butt.