Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 15 by fantaghiro fantaghiro

What's next?

packing

The next thing he know, Tom stood in the middle of his bedroom, still gripping the coin in his pocket. His eyes flicked between Charity and Ellie, both of whom were busy tossing a few items into a weekend bag, laughing in that effortless, familiar way that should have felt normal—but didn’t. Not at all.

Charity, her blonde hair brushing her shoulders, glanced over her shoulder at him. “You’re just standing there, Tom. Come on, help us pack! You’re hopelessly slow otherwise.” Her tone was warm and teasing, but beneath it, he could feel Sarah—the ghost of her awareness—threaded into the words, in the tilt of her head, the light in her eyes. Every subtle gesture felt intimate, charged, as if she were whispering in a language only he could understand.

Ellie leaned against the bed, her curly hair spilling over her shoulder. She caught Tom’s eye and winked slowly, licking her lips in a motion so deliberate it made his stomach tighten. He blinked, heart hammering. She was her own person—he could see it—but the faint, unmistakable echo of Sarah’s mischievous awareness made the action impossible to categorize as innocent.

Tom shook his head, trying to ground himself. “Okay… uh, what exactly should I pack?” he asked, forcing casualness into his voice.

Charity-Sarah smirked, leaning close just enough that her shoulder brushed his. He felt a faint pulse of electricity run up his arm. “Hmm… I’d say… clothes you actually want to wear. And don’t forget your swim trunks. You might regret it if you don’t,” she murmured, voice lower than normal, soft, intimate, layered with something that wasn’t just Charity. Sarah was in every syllable, every nuanced inflection.

Ellie-Sarah chimed in from the sofa, bouncing slightly. “And don’t forget your sunscreen! You know you always forget it, Tom. Mom and I… we’re not letting you burn like last time,” she said, giggling. But the way her eyes held him, the subtle quirk of her smile—it was Sarah’s humor, Sarah’s teasing, threaded with Ellie’s youthful energy.

Tom exhaled slowly, aware that every look, every motion, every teasing word carried two consciousnesses at once. He realized that his old feelings of desire for Sarah were now spread across two fully embodied, fully autonomous presences: Charity-Sarah and Ellie-Sarah. It was intoxicating, disorienting… and impossible to ignore.

Charity stepped closer again, placing a hand lightly on his forearm. “We’re going to have fun this weekend, you’ll see. I promise it’ll help you relax.” Her body pressed slightly against his chest, the warmth and softness undeniable. Tom felt a flush creep across his neck and shoulders. He wanted to pull back, wanted to resist… but the memory-merged Sarah in her—the familiarity and intimacy—was impossible to ignore.

Ellie jumped up from the sofa, sauntering toward him. “Don’t worry, Mr. Branson—uh, Tom. You’ll have us both to keep an eye on you,” she teased, brushing past him deliberately, letting the faintest of brushes linger a heartbeat too long. Her giggle carried a hint of Sarah’s private laughter, the one that had always made him ache with desire, threaded through her youthful, playful identity.

Tom ran a hand through his hair, heart racing. “I… I can’t believe this is happening,” he muttered to himself. The coin in his pocket felt impossibly heavy, pulsing with potential, like it was aware of every tiny thrill, every conflict, every illicit thought.

Charity-Sarah gave him a sly smile, stepping back to give him a better view of Ellie, who was perched on the arm of the sofa, legs swinging lazily. “Just relax,” Charity murmured. “We’re still us, you know. Just… split. And still entirely aware of you.”

Ellie’s voice chimed in, playful and intimate at the same time. “Yeah… we know you, Tom. You’re still our Sarah’s husband, no matter what form we’re in.” Her wink was slow, deliberate, a teasing promise that made his chest tighten in ways he hadn’t felt in years.

Tom exhaled, torn between amazement, lust, and the absurdity of the situation. He glanced at Will, now sitting in an armchair, oblivious to the surreal tension radiating from the two women in front of him, chatting casually like nothing had changed. The juxtaposition made everything feel unreal—normal social reality stacked against the impossible, erotic, psychological reality created by the coin.

“What have I got myself into?” he murmured silently, already knowing the answer was something much more intense, complicated, and thrilling than he could have imagined.

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)