Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by whatsawhizzer whatsawhizzer

What do you do next?

him instead.

You barge into the room with the knife out. You come up behind him and then put the knife up to his neck. The man let’s out a squeal in surprise, immediately putting his hands up and away from their iron grip on the girl’s head. The girl, finally noticing that he isn’t slamming his dick down her throat any more, looks up in surprise.

The girl wipes away her tears, and the look she gives you is more annoyed than thankful, shedding any doubt that this was anything more than role play. You had already figured that, really, and you had your own plans.

“Wh-what’s going on?” the man asks, his voice sounding genuinely scared.

“You think its okay to **** a woman?” you demand with just a tinge of anger in your voice.

He lets out a little squeak before responding, “No… no, I wasn’t, we were just…”

You look down at the annoyed girl and wink. “Well, too fucking bad, because now you’re my little fuck puppet. Hey, girl, do me a favor and keep him nice and hard for me? I wouldn’t want our toy to grow soft before I’ve had my way.”

This part was a bit of a gamble, but when her eyes showed understanding, a big grin broke out on her tear ruined face.

“Fuck’n A,” she laughed, “Why not?”

Her mouth was wrapped around his dick in a heartbeat. He tried to let out a sigh of relief, but when he tried to drop his head his neck ended up pressing against the knife you had at his throat, and he snapped right back to attention. Of course, he hadn’t seen your face yet, but you pretty certain the prospect of a threesome would melt any guy. You hadn’t seen his face either though, so with your free hand you remove his mask and toss it to the side, nibbling on his ear as you go.

Luckily the guy is pretty attractive. He cautiously turns his head to you, already breathing hard from the machinations of the girl below. You kiss him on the lips, and the two of you are tongue wrestling as the other girl slides her lips up and down his shaft to the sounds of sucking.

You reach down and grip the base of his cock in your hand, supporting the cock for her. She takes the message and removes her own hands, grabbing either side of his hip instead to help her move her head forward and back on his dick. With each thrust of her mouth, her lips cover the entire shaft and her wet lips press against your hand.

You finger his balls slightly as she continues to go to town with reckless abandon. Meanwhile, you start kissing his neck and face, running your tongue all over his body. Your body responds to the actions, and so does his. He starts letting out gasps that grow into deep moans, and you realize he’s getting close to cumming.

“Hey, sweetie.” You say.

She pulls his dick out of her mouth and looks up with innocent looking eyes. “What’s up?”

“I’m horny as hell. I said keep him up, not get him off.”

She lets out a laugh and stands up, “Well, shit. The little twat probably doesn’t even have enough in him for two girls at once.”

You nod and the two of your pass a look of understanding. Only one of you was getting fucked today. You had the knife, but in order to fuck him you’d probably need to give up the knife. However, you were horny too and weren’t quite sure.

The girl whips out a condom and puts it on him with skill. The two of you lie him down on the bed. But which one of you is going to get on top?

What will you do next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)