her first time?

The gasps and moans paused and Tom was afraid they had heard him, so he pulled back. But then Jay spoke. "Are you sure you're ready for this Sarah? You've taken everything pretty slow so far..."

Sarah shushed him "Jay, I wanted to since that first photo shoot, but I was scared. Tonight I'm happier than I've ever been before. I want to celebrate - with you. I'm ready."

'She's told him she's a virgin?' Tom said to himself. That idea kicked his own arousal up by an order of magnitude. He considered another wishing with the justification it could improve the fantasy for Sarah. Silently he wished 'I wish Sarah, without losing any of her sexual experience or memories, would feel like this is her very first time.' The idea of something else taking Sarah's virginity while he watched was almost too much, and he quickly found himself with his pants open and dick in his hand.

He heard shuffling. Carefully, slowing easing the door open just a bit more, he tried once more to get a peek. He could see Sarah lying naked on the bed, reaching out her arms to Jay. Jay seemed entranced; finally he said "I've fantasized about this...."

She giggled. "No need for fantasies anymore. I'm right here."

Tom watched Jay climb onto Sarah who welcomed him with legs spread wide. Tom was frustrated her couldn't really see Jay enter her, having a limited view from the door. "Ohh..." Sarah gasped softly, "aahh!"

Jay gently pulled out of her. "Are you okay?" he asked softly, gazing into her eyes.

"I'm fine," she told him. "Just a little surprised. It's...it's my first time, and it'll be uncomfortable for me at first." Her voice registered a hint of surprise as she said that, but she quickly recovered. "But I want it! I want to feel you. I'll tell you if you need to stop."

Jay took a breath and slowly pushed in and out. Sarah gasped and moaned, becoming more vocal. That encouraged Jay. He increased his rhythm, moaning as he thrust harder and harder into her.

Sarah shifted, turning her head slightly. Her gaze caught Tom's and she smiled. "Harder, harder!" she whispered to Jay. She continued to stare at Tom as she let out soft moans, growing in intensity. Tom feverishly stroked himself, almost in time to their rhythm. Suddenly she wrapped her legs around Jay, pulling him into her. He pounded and released, muttering "oh god!" Sarah screamed in pleasure, arched her back, then fell limp after several seconds. That was too much for Tom and he released, managing only at the last second to twist so that he came all over himself and his trousers rather than Sarah's doorway.

Jay rolled off to the side, blocking Tom's view of Sarah. "Didn't think you'd be such screamer," he teased. "Bet they heard you..." he paused. "Oh God, your Dad! What will he do?" he asked in a panicked voice.

Tom couldn't see Sarah's face but her voice was calm. "Don't worry about Daddy. I'm SURE he's in bed either asleep or with his headphones on. He's oblivious."

Realizing that was a signal, Tom stepped back from the door. He heard the bed squeak as someone got up, so hurried quietly down the hall to his room to clean himself up.