You want Karen and Karen alone.

“Yeah I wanted to talk to you about this.” You take her hands and look into her eyes. “Babe, I really enjoyed the fun we had with Sarah and Jakob. I never experienced sex this amazing in my life and I’m so happy to see you get properly fucked as well.” Karen gives a saucy smile in reply. You take a breath and continue, ”But I don’t want to do this again. I’ve been thinking about it since they left and we don’t need anybody else to have fun. I feel weird about fucking Sarah, even though I had a lot of fun with her. Can you be satisfied with just my body?”

Karen embraces you gently. “I told you before that I care more about you than anything else. My feelings haven’t changed since then. I could sense something was off when Sarah arrived. Why didn’t you tell me then? We could have called it off.”

“And deny you Jakob’s cock?” you ask her teasingly. Karen blushes and looks away embarrassed. “Don’t feel guilty baby,” you placate her. “I’m honestly glad you got to sleep with them one more time. I didn’t stop it then because I wanted to see if my feelings would change. They haven’t. And be truthful, aren’t you happy I held my tongue till now?”

“Yes,” she replies quietly. She looks back at you and continues, “Jakob’s cock was fucking amazing and I loved playing with Sarah. But all that is nothing compared to you. I know I’ll be happy with your cock, especially now that my ass can actually enjoy it.”

You laugh and tickle her in reply. The two of you spend most of the day airing out your feelings and emotions to each other, ultimately deciding to remain monogamous.