You prefer to do it yourself

You do.

She shivers slightly as you slowly raise the shirt, your hands brushing lightly against her side. Getting the bunched up fabric past her breasts takes a bit of effort, but the sight of the soft flesh dropping down again is a glorious sight indeed. Even better, getting the t-shirt over her head and arms means she has to lean forward far enough for her soft breasts come to brush gently against your chest. It feels impossibly soft and warm. And apparently you are not the only one enjoying the feeling, you can feel Tobys hips buck slightly against your own as her nipples graze your chest.

“Dang, I never really noticed my nipples before this morning..” She confesses slightly puzzled, as you toss away the shirt “ but now feeling them rub against my shirt was driving me craa-aa-a-…. ” feeling mischievous you have lightly grabbed one of her breasts and lightly flicked her nipple with a thumb. “…crazy. S-stop that!” Her startled expression is everything you hoped for.

“Do you really want me to?” you ask, running your thumb in a feathery circles around her nipple. Uncharacteristically bold of you, but at this point you are just running with the adrenalin high from getting to second base for the first time.

It takes Toby a few moments to answer that. Which is probably related to the renewed bucking of her hips. “No.” she murmures after a moment “It feels really strange but…” she runs a hand lightly across your own chest giving you as small smile “.. but it’s not bad. Nippleplay never did much for me, but now….” she takes your hand and guides it deeper towards her crotch “Can you feel it, babe? ” she whispers as your fingers encounter a large wet spot on her boxers “Can you feel how much I want you?”

You nod, wondering idly what must be going on in Tobys head right now. Was this usually the part where he let the girl feel his hardon? You have to see how far you can push this.

Even with his pants unzipped, it is a tight fit but you manage to push your fingers in deeper. A Tobys gasp tells you when your searching fingers reach your destination. So that’s where the clitoris was. At least you hope the protrusion you feel beneath the boxers is it.

You run your fingers over it experimentally a few times and,,, nope. That were just the lips . but when you push a bit harder your finger parts them and ….. Toby eyes suddenly widen. Bingo!

You give your finger an experimental wiggle, trying to imitate what you have in porn and… Toby screws his eyes shut, her entire body going ridgid

“Aahhhhhaaaaaahh!”

Your first thought it must have hurt, and you freeze immediately. An apology is already on your lips when Tobys eyes snap back open “Don’t stop!” she hisses.

“It didn’t ..hurt?” you ask after a moment.

“No.” on of her hands bends your head slightly to the side as she dives in for a short passionate kiss, “Hell no. It felt great.” She adds giving you another kiss for emphasis. “It just surprised me. It never felt li.ii.i.i.i.i.i” you rub your finger along her damp boxers again, enjoying Tobys expression as she is forced to stop midsentence to recover her bearings “It feels di-i-i-i-i-i- ” this time she fights through the distraction “It nev-ahhh felt like this w-with others. Ev- Everything feels different. Bu-u-u-ut I can’t figure out what. ”

“Oh?” you smile and continue gently massaging her through her underwear “Different how?”

“Like… hahhhh like… when I saw you.”

“Yes? what about me.”

“I ohhhh I just knew I had to take you home with me. But I never thought about taking men home for sex before. Never.”

“Then why did you do it?”

“I don’t know! I just knew I had to. You were just so sexy and…and sweet…. and perfect! And the more we talked the more I… “ Toby seems to have gotten over the initial surprise by now. She is still letting out little gasps of pleasure but she is talking more clearly now ” The more we talked the more I wanted you to want me. It was the only thing that mattered. I’d never thought I’d do something like this, but everything felt wrong since I woke up, aside from this. Aside from you. It feels totally crazy, but… ”

You chuckle “Well if anyone would have told me a gorgeous girl would be begging me to have sex with her before noon, I’d have laughed in their face. ” you prod.

“What? But I’m not….” You feel your dick strain against your own boxers as Toby tries to rationalize the last statement. “ A gorgeous girl?”

“But you are. You are one of the most stunning girls I have ever seen. ” You smirk, bringing up your free hand to lightly massage her breast. “Not to sound shallow but there can’t be a girl on campus who isn’t jealous of your boobs, for one.”

“My….” She looks down at your hand cupping a truly spectacular rack, “I - ohhhhh- I really am stacked. I never even noticed…. .”

Seeing Toby trying to figure out what has happened to him, was fricking amazing. How far could you push this, you wonder. One of your fingers had worked it’s way into the fly of Tobys boxers during all this and you decide to see how far you can push this. You slide your fingers deeper, until they find an opening that your index finger can slip into.

Her reaction as you slip your index finger slides into the tight opening up to the first knuckle is even better than you hoped.

Her eyes flick down to her crotch before her head snaps up to look at you with a look of utter confusion as she tries to understand what is happening.

“Wh—uuhhhh!”

Whatever she was about to say, is completely wiped from her mind as you wriggle your finger to slide it in deeper. “Don’t… ” She pants as you position a second finger at her entrance “Stop….”.

“Don’t worry.” You assure her “I won’t.”

Adding a second finger causes her to raise her hips to escape the strange sensation, before collapsing against you in the process. You have to hastily jerk your head aside to avoid her horn colliding with your forehead.

It is a shame you can’t see her face like that, but seeing her lie across your chest with her boobs pressing into your torso and her hips raised high into the air is …also nice.

You listen to her short gasps as your second finger slides into her, and you start to slowly move them back and forth trying to find the motion that gets the best response.

“I… ” Toby stammers out between gasps after a while “ Your…. It….. Why …….. Why can I feel you inside me? ”

What? Oh. Oh! You were thinking about your dick when you said Toby wouldn’t notice his changes until he felt you inside him, but yes you are very much inside him now too. So how to deal with this?

“Because I want to make you feel good? ” you murmur, and you can’t help but smirk a bit as you add “I know a lady has needs too.”

“But… I am a girl!”

“Yes. “ you agree ” You are. A very beautiful one.”

“I mean, I am Liz. Liz! “ she tries again ” Elizabeth Paige! I am ahahaaaaa “ as she tries to get back up her hips come down , driving your fingers deeper than you dared to go before.

The sound of her voice, the sight of her face, the feeling of her wet walls massaging your fingers and most of all the knowledge of what must be going on in Elizabeths head right now is too much. You can’t hold it any longer. With a small grunt and a drawn out sigh you cum.

A moment later you feel Toby roll off of you. While you are still a bit dazed from the best orgasm you had so far, she takes the hand buried in her crotch and gently pushes your hand away. You can't really stop her from dowing that without seeming suspisioucs so you just lie there and watch her shudder slightly -whether with disgust or pleasure you are not sure – as your fingers are dragged out of her with a small wet sound. “This—this is some kind of mistake.” She stammers as she hastily scrambles off the bed.

“What are you talking about?” you pant, trying to play innocent. Luckily you don’t have to feign disappointment at this abrupt end to the make-out session, even if you are disappointed for very different reasons. “What is a mistake?”

“This…” she nods vaguely in the direction of your groin.

“But … didn’t you …. I mean…. ” Dang, you really didn’t take into account how hard it would be to think straight immediately after (almost) having sex. You just thought it would be funny if Tobys awareness returned mid-penetration. You take a deep breath. “You initiated it, right? You wanted to sleep with me. ”

“I…. ” Toby licks her lips I confusion “Yes, I … ” her eyes flick down to your crotch before snapping back to your face “I still do. But …. I’m not .. We met before. I’m Kates friend. I am Lizzie. ” she screws her eyes shut and shakes her head in confusion “No this isn’t right!” before visibly forcing herself to take a calming breath.

“Is everything alright? Did I do something wrong?” You have a hard time keeping a smirk of your face, as you ask that.

“No.” she decides after looking at you for a long moment “No. I … I just need to be alone for a bit. Please?”

She keeps staring at you, with pleading eyes as you try to decide what to do.