You make her yours

I guess this was inevitable from the first time you suggested to her your solution for how she could pay her rent. You didn't think it would be like this though.

“No! Take it out!” Her whole body bucks and twists under me, but with my arms firmly around her legs I am able to hold her enough to stay inside her. In fact, her wiggling makes it better. With each spasm and jerk her tight pussy milks my hard cock and if I were a younger man I'd be filling up by now. “Please Sir, it hurts ... I've never done this ... It's too big ... take it out ... Take it out!!” I'm not proud of this, but the combination of her struggles, the panicked protests and the fact she's pretending I've just deflowered her is turning me on. It is surprising easy to imagine that I am one of those ancient warriors plundering a captured virgin.

“You're mine now, Girl.” I growl coarsely after a particularly hard thrust and Alison's sudden gasp of excitement is all the encouragement I need. Almost immediately she reverts to the good Christian maiden being **** for the first time.

“No you beast! You can't ... I won't let you.” In spite of her protests, I have settled into a pretty good rhythm and while Alison is still protesting, I can feel her legs wrap around my back and she is meeting each thrust with surprising enthusiasm. “I'll never surrender, not to a pagan like you ... I won't ... Oh Dear God I couldn't ... oh please nooo!”

“I own you, Girl.” Gentler now, I'm no longer trying to **** her, instead I coax her into that surrender that she both fears and craves in equal parts. “Don't fight me, let it go...” I take her legs from behind me and fold them up against her tits, but she is no longer fighting at all.

“I can't ... it's a sin ... please...” By now it is clear that these feeble protests are just for show and when I get my hand down between our bodies and start stroking her clit there is not even a pretense that she is being ****. “It feels so good ... oh Lord forgive me ... why does it feel so good?”

The problem now is that I am getting close myself. It would suck to get my hot tenant this close to an orgasm on our first try and then fail to close the deal. Gritting my teeth, I continue to push in and out of her as she lays spread out on the table before me. The whole business of 'conquering' a maiden by forcing her and then fucking her until she cums is fantasy, but as fantasies go it is a pretty good one. So instead of taking the easy way out I keep rubbing her pussy as I fuck her and thankfully it doesn't take too much longer to make this happen.

“Ohh ... ohh nooo ... please, I can't ... noooOH FUCK!” The way Alison's tight pussy floods with juices and clenches down on my cock feels fucking amazing and with a grunt of deep satisfaction I start pumping my cum into her.