You fuck her and cum in her

"Going in," you tease Shay as you line your dick up with her pussy, continuing to press your luck with her since she had yet to balk at you fucking her.

"UH...OHGOD..." she moans as you slide into her, caught off-guard by how bold you were actually being with her as you started to fuck her right off to the side of the dance floor, thrusting in and out of her and wondering how much more lucky you would be able to get with her.

"Fuck you're tight Shay," you whisper to her as you fuck her, your dick sliding deeper and deeper into her, her walls wrapping tighter and tighter around your dick the longer you fucked her.

"MMM...OHGOD...you feel so good in my slutty little pussy..." Shay softly purred, throwing her head back and closing her eyes as she started throwing her hips back into yours.

"So good you don't want me to stop?" you ask her as she cums on your dick, her juices rushing out onto it and running down the insides of your thighs as her cunt muscles clamp down on it and you started quickening your strokes into her.

"Keep...going..." she whispers, giving you implied permission to cum in her as you grab her hips and start hammering into her, grunting in her ear as you cum deep in her stretched-out pussy.

"OHGOD...your cum feels good inside me..." she moans out as you leave your cock buried inside of her and fill her pussy up with it, keeping yourself inside of her until every drop had entered her.

"I can't believe I just had sex with a goddess like you. And in public, too,"" you tease her as you make out with her, Shay's next request leaving you even more floored.