You fuck Sarah’s ass instead.

You look at Sarah’s sexy peach-shaped ass and remember how much you enjoyed pleasuring it. You run a finger along her crack, watching her shiver delectably from your touch. “I want to fuck Sarah’s ass first, baby. Do you mind?”

Karen looks at you in surprise. You see no anger or disappointment on her face. She then gives you a naughty grin. “You like fucking her more than me, don’t you?”

“Absolutely,” you reply. “You need to wait till I’ve had my fill of her.”

She gives a sigh of contentment. “Anything you want, baby.” Then to Sarah, “Want to take his cock?”

“Badly,” Sarah replies. “It took all my willpower not to fuck him in the bedroom.”

Karen scrambles below Sarah until her face is underneath Sarah’s pussy. She looks up at you. “Enter slowly. I want to enjoy the view.” She laps Sarah’s clit and you see Sarah bend lower to return the favor.

You push your tip into Sarah’s warm asshole. She immediately contracts tightly and the pressure almost makes you cum. It’s tighter than anything you have ever felt and you can feel her ass thrum with tension. You hear Karen whisper dirtily to Sarah, encouraging her to open up and let you in.

Sarah relaxes and you slowly slide in deeper. Her ass feels rougher than any pussy you’ve fucked and every time her ass contracts you’re gripped by an indescribable spasm of pleasure. Surprisingly there is little resistance to your cock thrusting in, your mouth having evidently done its job. A minute or so later, you’re fully inside her and you hear her breath ease. You feel Karen’s tongue roam over your throbbing balls as you enjoy Sarah’s grip on your ass.

You thrust gently into her and hear her give a deep moan of satisfaction. “Fuck yeah! That hit the spot,” she exclaims as she moves to meet your cock. You see Jakob, his cock ring still on, rub his tip on Karen’s pussy as Sarah teases them both with her tongue. You start feeling Sarah’s ass relax and moving becomes much easier. You start lengthening your thrusts and are rewarded with answering moans of pleasure from her. Your cock starts enjoying the feel of her ass and you let it take over completely. You are now thrusting the full length of your cock in and out of her, each motion making her scream for pleasure as she begs for more.

“Doesn’t her ass feel good, baby?” Karen whispers below you, her lips and breath tickling your swinging balls.

“So good, baby,” you pant back, barely able to reply through the pleasure.

“Does her pussy feel better than mine?”

“Much. Much. Better,” you pant back, thrusting hard with each word.

“Oh that’s so fucking hot.” Karen is panting hard as well. “Tell me more. What else?”

“Her feet,” you almost scream, so close to the edge. “I want to worship them, baby. Kiss them, lick them, fuck them...”

Suddenly, Sarah’s ass grips your cock hard, hard enough to scare you, and then she moans and bucks loudly as she orgasms. Her ass ripples all over your shaft and you feel a dam break within you as you flood her ass with your cum. The two of moan in unison for minutes as you struggle to stay upright on your shaking knees. Finally it’s over and you collapse backwards, your cock still weakly twitching and streaming a small dribble of cum. You see a thick dollop of cum leak out of her asshole and drip right into Karen’s waiting, open mouth. Karen ravenously swallows your cum as she scoops out more with her finger. Your view is blocked by Jakob’s ass as he gets behind Sarah, his cock ring removed. He thrusts all the way into her ass without ceremony and fucks her roughly. Sarah screams in happiness and you watch in amazement as she enthusiastically rocks back, exhorting him to fuck harder.

Karen leaves the loud couple behind and crawls over to you. She pushes you down unceremoniously and then rides your face hard. She grinds roughly without a word until she cums all over your face. Then she embraces you tight and whispers, her words full of affection and satiated lust, “I love being second-best, especially compared to Sarah. Thank you, love.” She kisses your wet mouth before breaking off giggling, “I guess I need to wait for my ass to get fucked. No matter, I think this was way better.”