You cum in her again. Then she tells you the truth.

"FUCK....OHGOD...fuck me John..." she hisses as you pound away on her pussy with every intention of filling it up with your baby seed again whether she was being honest with you or not.

"FUCK...yeah...cum on that dick Brooke...let me cum in you again baby..." you softly tell her as you feel her cunt muscles squeezing down on your dick, her back arching as she throws her head back and cums for you, screaming your name louder and louder as her eyes roll back in her head.

"UH...FUCK...FUCK...FUCK...fuck me...cum in me..." she shouts as her legs wrap around your waist, her body going stiff as a board as you start to cum deep inside her, your dick bumping into her cervix as you spurt your baby-making fluid into her.

"OHGOD...so deep..." she moans as you finish up inside of her and start to pull out of her, pinning her to the bed and making out with her.

"Daddy's little girl ain't so innocent, is she Brooke?" you tease her as you hold her in your arms, wanting to go one more round with her, but not having the strength for it.

"More than you know," she whispers, squeezing your hand in a way that convinces you she's about to give you some life-altering news, "you see, my daddy did make me get on the pill when I turned 18. But I've been off of it for a long, long time now. And you're the first guy I've let cum inside me since then."

"And I also happen to me at my most fertile time of the month," she tells you as she squeezes your dick and places her head on your chest, "and I decided somewhere along the way tonight that I wanted to make a baby with you."

"Let's talk about this some more in the morning Brooke," you tell her, assuring her that you weren't going to go anywhere as she fell asleep in your arms while you considered your own options before falling asleep yourself.