You confront Shay...but she's not alone.

The next day, you make plans to deal with Shay personally.
Lola will be busy with Class and some work, so you have plenty of time.

You arrive and find a note on the door...

'I've been expecting you. Come in.'

You go inside- with the door unlocked- and look around for Shay.
She finds you and she's not alone!

"This is Eva. She's my friend."
"Hi there. I saw all of the pictures of you and just had to meet you."
"Pictures of me? You know what- I'm not even going to ask."
"Don't be upset, stud," Eva says, "We just want to have some fun with you. Let's let him see the goods before he decides."
Shay nods.

The Step-MILF rips open her top to expose her bra-less tits and Eva pulls her big tits out of her dress.

Holy shitballs!

They look amazing!
Eva's tits are even bigger than Shay's.

They smile at your stunned state and keep going.

Shay shimmies out of her skirt and Eva slides her skin-tight dress off sensually.
They only have panties on now.

Damn!

"He's not saying 'no,'" Shay says.
"And he's not leaving," Eva adds.
"Who can blame him?"
"Nobody would. Panties now?"
"Panties now."

Eva gets on her knees behind Shay and pulls her panties down, exposing her pussy.
You've seen it before, but you aren't exactly used to it.

Shay makes Eva turn around and yanks her panties down slowly.
As she turns around, the Step-MILF makes sure to cover her friend's pussy with her hands.

"If you want to see her pussy, you need to strip for us," Shay says.
"And if you strip for us, you have to fuck us," Eva adds.
"Strip now or forever hold your, well, piece, I guess."