Yes let's see what they come up with

"Haha hey girls it seems you have planned this moment on your minds. So I do you want this to pan out? let's hear it." I tell them all.

"Oooh" both Sophie and Nat says in union and look at each other. Then they look at back at me and starts rambling. It's impossible to make out what any one of them are saying.

"Hey hey hey, hold your horses girls, I can't make out what either of you are saying. One at a time please." I reign them in, as they both starts giggling as they realize they may have gotten a little bit over exited there.

"Hihi sorry you first Sophie" says Natalie.

"Oh well thank you." Sophie says in a silly way before continuing "Well as I said I think you should take her from behind, like doggystyle here in the water. That way you can spank her whenever she whines to much like a little bitch. Putting her in her place and reminding her that she's supposed to take like a champ and if she doesn't whine from your cock then you can make her from your hand instead." She winks at me at the end.

Oh damn this girl's is a sadist for sure. Wanting to make her friends first time in the ass to be so rough. That's pretty hot I must admit and from what I can tell from the look on Maisie's face is that she is slightly embarrassed.

So my bet is she kinda likes this humiliating idea. Maybe she is a Sub or a masochist? Interesting to say the least. If not she would just look terrified that this idea.

Now it's Natalie's turn "Oh so typically you Sophie going rough and hard with a little bit of humiliation involed." She rolls her eyes.

Then she looks at me with a smirk. "well I think you should take a different more loving role. It is her first time after all and she is giving it to you so generously. It's not everyday someone gives you their anal virginity, right."

Maisie is blushing at this as Natalie's hand also touching her face gently. Omg Natalie is good at this guilt tripping me and charming her. Sophie just rolls her eyes at this, she can't believe her friends are using those cards.

Natalie continues "I think you should lay her on the back there and give her a good licking as you tease and slowly work on her little backdoor with your fingers. Only when she is satisfied with your services will she let you in her backdoor."

At this point her hand have wondered down under water and I'm sure she's rubbing Maisie's pussy.

"Then he will go up and kiss you as he slowly and only then will you let him gently get in your tight little asshole."

Sophie pushes Natalie's hand away from Maisie and looks at me. "So what will it be lover boy?" She say it in a derogatory way. "Want to be a good boy or a bad boy?"

I try to decipher what Maisie is thinking but she seems to be even more divided than I am. Should I ask her or even just go with my own thing?