Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 14 by EmmaPhelan EmmaPhelan

I have a bad feeling about this...

When three is not enough...

I make eye contact with Perkins and then glance at the door. With my arms pulled behind me and my mouth full my communication options are pretty limited.

He gets the message somehow and walks toward the door. He shakes his head and as he reaches to lock it, the doorknob turns. Everyone freezes. It feels like an eternity, and there is something weird about having a cock lodged motionless in your pussy and your mouth.

The door opens fully and in walk Eric and Lewis. To say they looked surprised would be a serious understatement. The door closes behind them. Perkins locks the door. Damn it man, why didn't you do that in the first place? I'm at a loss for words.

They are not necessarily the words I would have chosen, but Garrett yells out, "Hey guys, are you here for the science lab too?"

Perkins face palms. This situation has escalated completely out of control, and I would face palm too if I could move my arms. Actually I would rewind the clock to this morning and skipped school to begin with.

Neither of my friends can find words. I can only imagine the surprise at seeing one of your best friends, a girl, naked for the first time, and when you do, not only is she naked, she is wrapped around multiple cocks owned by people that are the butt of more than a few school jokes. Eric looks me straight in the eyes, a mixture of "What the fuck, Riley?" and "Holy fuck, my best friend is totally naked having sex!" I nod ever so slightly.

He gets the message. He drops his drawers in a heartbeat, like he's been waiting for this opportunity. "Absolutely! But let's mix it up. Have her lay on the desk." Lucas and Seth disengage. The awkwardness has softened them. Garrett on the other hand, having been off to himself, never stopped stroking.

By the time I'm stretched out on the desk, Lucas has made the necessary wardrobe adjustments and Eric is ready to go. He leans down on top of me, kisses me deeply on the lips and whispers in my ear "This is highly unlike you, Riley, but I've dreamed about this moment for far too long. Lucas and I will try to keep them under control, but I'm sorry if it gets too rough." I can feel his elongated member pressing against me. He stands back up, pushes my thighs apart and slides his cock in. I am in a daze, as not once had I ever thought of Eric or Lewis in that way. How sweet that they want to somehow protect me while fucking my brains out, but I'm in too deep now. Or I should say, Eric is.

His strokes are long and powerful and I think the fact it's one of my best friends has amplified the intensity. He pushes me to orgasm in minutes. He slows and pulls out. Lewis leans down and kisses me. He whispers in my ear "My dreams have come true. I hope this is as good as Eric." The heat of his breath lingers in my ear, and I willingly spread my legs. He slides in. He is a little thicker than Eric, and maybe a little longer. It's hard to tell. I'm staring into his eyes, oblivious to everything except the rocking motion as he thrusts, and my breasts heaving back and forth. He fondles them and I wrap my legs around his waist, pulling him in tight. I'm pushed over the edge for the second time in a few minutes.

The other three, watching the mastery and seeing the ease with which I climaxed, want turns too. Garrett leads off and tries, and it's better than what he was doing before but he needs practice. Lucas is much improved as far as tempo, but he drives it in hard every thrust.

Seth doesn't really care about any of it. He grabs my ankles and pushes them back towards my head so my body is **** to arch. My pussy ends up at a more upward angle. I grab my ankles and hold on. He climbs up on the desk and drives his cock straight down into my waiting pussy. The angle is a little different, and it is intense. The way my body is arched inward I get a better view of things and that enhances my excitement. He fucks hard and fast but the change of pace and angle do bring me to a satisfactory orgasm.

Lucas says, "Okay, I think we are all ready to finish. Do we want to come inside her?"

Eric looks genuinely distressed. He says, "No. Think of how awesome a five man facial would be!"

Smart boy. Appeal to the gang bang porn fetish crowd. It'll be messy as hell, but I'd probably be oozing for the next day with that much cum lodged in my pussy.

I nod in agreement, slip off the desk and get down on my knees. Seth walks over first. I close my eyes. I hear his grunts and feel the hot, sticky stuff land on my eyelids. I'll have to wipe my face off before I open them or it's gonna be hell. I don't know who went next, but it sounds like Lucas. He just decorates my forehead and it drips down from there. Garrett is next, and I only know it because I hear him yell "painted lady" right before he blows. It lands all over - forehead, nose, lips and chin. I feel some of it drip down onto my breasts.

I hear Lucas say "Open your mouth." I open it. I don't know how long it was, it felt like maybe twenty seconds, but the weird salty taste that is cum floods my tongue and he is finished. I can't bring myself to swallow it and I basically drool it out of my mouth. Exclamations of excitement from the three who are not my friends. This must be their wet dream every night.

That leaves Eric. Someone wipes my face off. I open my eyes slowly, anticipating any residual cum will find its way into my eyes. A little does and it irritates me but it isn't anything like what Seth's wads would have done to me.

Eric leans down and whispers in my ear "You can take care of the rest." He rests his hands on my shoulders. His erect member looms in front of my face. I take it in my mouth and go down on him. Even in this short time of intimacy with Eric, it is already a hundred times better than my night with Nathan after prom. I know, I keep comparing everything with prom night, but it was my first time, what am I supposed to do?"

I bob and suck, using the pressure of his hands on my shoulders as my cues. Finally I can tell he is ready to go. I look at him and he nods. He is leaving me in control. I encircle his cock with my hand and stroke back and forth, faster and faster. As neat and clean as it would be, I just don't want anymore cum in my mouth. I close my eyes the moment I feel that first subtle shift in his cock and the first pulse splatters against my face. There must have been another dozen pulses until finally he is spent. I wipe around my eyes and open them. The look on Eric's face is utter serenity.

I look at Perkins. "Congratulations gentlemen, you have successfully completed your lab. You will finally be done with high school." The original three high five each other, zip up and leave. I'm still on my knees, in a partial state of shock from the whole experience.

"Miss Gailliard, I know this was a little unorthodox, but thank you. On behalf of me, Principal Jackson, and a lot of other teachers here, we truly thank you."

Eric and Lewis both give me a sideways glance. I say, "I'll explain later."

Unorthodox is not the word I would have chosen. Fucking insane is more like it. And I actually did it. I stand up and retrieve my thong and bra from the floor and put them on. Perkins hands me some paper towels to wipe my face off.

I pull on my jeans, slip into my sandals and then grab my shirt off the floor, pulling it on. Everything from the waist down is sore.

I grab my bag and walk to the door. Eric is already there, holding it open. Lewis takes my bag. Perkins thanks me again and says "Enjoy the rest of your day, Miss Gailliard."

We head for the front of the building and exit the front doors. For the last time. Though I almost entertain the idea of becoming a teacher so I can come back and "encourage" my students to participate in unorthodox activities for grades. I laugh to myself.

Eric's car is parked half on the sidewalk, half on the lawn in front of the school. I comment "Outstanding parking job there, Eric."

Eric laughs. He walks around to the driver's side and hops in. I look at Lewis. He kisses me on the cheek and says "Shotgun is yours. From now to the end of time."

I climb in next to Eric on the passenger side. He kisses me on the cheek as well. "You had quite the adventure there. I knew when you texted me that something unusual was going on. Traffic sucked or else we would have been there sooner."

I ask, "So boys, how was the historic site?"

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)