Turns out it *was* more of a threesome...

Sean stood back as the two sexy women started sucking Magnus's phallus together. Magnus look over at Sean and magnanimously gestured toward Chloe's ass, clearly offering him his own wife to fuck, but Sean just looked down at his limp dick and shrugged wryly, mouthing, "whiskey dick" back. Magnus made a silent chuckle and 'what are you gonna do' shrug. Now that Sean thought about it, Chloe had been pretty focused on making him cum the last two days, more than her libido would normally demand. She said she was excited about tonight, but she wouldn't have tried to wear him out intentionally...

"Would you girls like to take this to the bed where we can get more comfortable?" Magnus asked, and Sean felt a pang of jealousy that his friend was offering them Sean's own bed. Magnus gestured toward Sean to come join, making sure to include him, but Sean held back. He went to the kitchen and drank some water. He tried to calm down a little, then attempted some tentative strokes to get hard again. He struggled for a second, then pictured Chloe riding up and down on Magnus and thought he felt the first signs of life. After a few minutes he grabbed a bottle of champagne they'd bought for tonight and headed to the bedroom where he could hear giggling mixed with moans.

He walked into the bedroom and popped the cork, hoping to make an entrance, but everybody was too distracted as the creamy white foam sloshed over Sean's hand. Allie was on all fours atop Chloe on the bed, the two making out, breasts and bodies rubbing together as Magnus stood behind them on the floor. Chloe had her Magnus -sized dildo pressed halfway into her pussy while Magnus thrust deeply into Allie. Magnus gripped the fake cock and his real cock together at the base, so every time he pushed forward he was effectively fucking both girls at once. He then spit on one of his fingers of his free hand and started rubbing around Allie's asshole. She squealed when he pressed it inside, then he continued thrusting to a chorus of grunts, moans, and wet sounds.

After a minute Magnus glanced over, looking almost surprised to find Sean in his own bedroom. He smiled at him and asked, "Do you want a turn?"

Sean grinned back and nodded. Now this was what he had signed up for. Magnus pulled out, followed by a sigh of disappointment from Allie. Magnus whispered to Sean as he passed by, "Ask Allie if you can fuck her ass." and patted him on the shoulder. He moved around the bed and pushed his massive rod between their faces, getting a response of 'oohs' and 'aahs' as they began giving him a double blowjob. Sean moved to the other side, greeted by the lovely sight of two beautiful pussies on two beautiful women. He'd been sporting a semi up to that point, but now he thought he'd get fully hard.

The massive dildo was still sticking obscenely from Chloe's pussy, but above it was Allie's, ripe and open from it's recent fucking. There was also Allie's little rosebud, which did look pretty alluring. The thing was, he thought it might be hard to get into that tight hole without being 100% rock hard, and Chloe had made it pretty clear she wasn't happy about him crossing the line to fuck Allie's pussy. She already thought he had once, so better not to chance it. He decided to place it safe and go for his wife's pussy, stroking himself a few times. He slid the dildo out of her and pushed it into Allie, eliciting a sigh and a moan, respectively, and leaving his wife's gaping wet snatch exposed.

Sean thought it would be hot to try Magnus's technique to fuck both girls at once, so he gripped the dildo on top of his own shaft, then started pressing forward. He'd just gotten the tip of his dick wet when he felt Allie's hand on his leg and she made a pained grunt. Sean realized he had about half of the dildo in her. He rocked back and forth, desperately trying to get his dick into his wife before his fledgling erection faded, but he just didn't have enough length

He finally gave up on Allie and removed the dildo, though her exasperated sigh made it clear how she felt about that. He finally pressed forward with his semi-erect shaft and slipped right into he wife. Only, he hadn't counted on how wet and stretched out she would be. He felt almost nothing aside from a vague warmth and wetness. Apparently Chloe didn't feel anything either as she asked, "are you all the way in?" then after a second, and with a hint of disappointment, "Are you all the way hard?" He felt his fear and self consciousness start to dominate, and his erection started to fade. He tried fucking her loose pussy hard and fast, but he just slipped completely out of her. "Ah, shit." He muttered to himself. A perfect opportunity and he'd lost it.

He had an idea though. He picked up the dildo again and started pushing it into his wife, eliciting an, "mmmm" of pleasure from her. He bent down and started trying to lick Allie, but it was too much of a stretch to get to her pussy, so he could only reach her back entrance. He shrugged and start rimming her, slowly sliding the massive toy into his own wife as both girls sucked and licked Magnus. Everyone seemed to enjoy it at first, but after awhile Allie said in a small voice, looking up at Magnus, "Can I have the real thing again?" Magnus looked at Sean and said, "ready to tag out bro?" Sean nodded and stepped away, deciding he'd take his spot at their mouths as Magnus came back around.

Magnus lined up with Allie's pussy and pushed into her. While she cried out with her mouth in a perfect 'O' Sean tried to get his dick in it, but either he missed or she dodged him, then she put her face into the mattress where she couldn't see him. Chloe did dutifully start licking his balls though, which was nice. Sean started stroking himself, enjoying the sensation of Chloe moaning deeply from the Magnus-dildo pushing inside her. Except then he noticed that Magnus wasn't inside Allie anymore. He switched and was fucking his wife. Raw. Again.

Did she know? Did Magnus think it was okay? He hadn't stopped them earlier, so he probably didn't realize that wasn't supposed to be happening tonight. But Chloe had said to be cool. All these thoughts were racing through his head as his dick suddenly sprang to full hardness again. Chloe smiled up at him and took her mouth off for a second to to say, "Good boy."
as she stroked him. Then she tilted her head all the back and opened her mouth, making it clear she wanted to Sean to fuck her throat. Her obliged, sliding all the way in without trouble. Magnus smiled at him and held out his hand. Are we really high-fiving, Sean thought, but reached out and hit his hand. "Yeah man! Get some!" Magnus shouted. Sean was thrusting away as Chloe made juicy gagging sounds every time Magnus's thrusting pushed her deeper than she intended. Just a couple times of this and Sean was pushed over his limit, grunting and shooting his load straight down his wife's throat. She just smiled up at him and licked her lips.

Sean sat in the only chair in the room, feeling a little self-conscious again, and thinking it would be weird to sit with everyone on the bed. He had a good view of the action though, as Magnus switched back a forth between the girls as they made out roughly. Magnus was starting to huff and puff like a steam engine climbing a mountain, and Chloe was panting right along with him. He looked at Sean and asked silently, "Inside?" Sean quickly shook his head, and saw Magnus pull out and try to switch back to Allie, whose pussy hovered just centimeters above Chloe's. He didn't quite make it as the first torrent of cum erupted from him. Sean was shocked with the volume of the stream. It looked more like someone taking a piss that shooting a load, starting with a trickle, swelling to a stream that lasted a full second, then tapering. Magnus groaned throughout the first jet as it splattered against Allie's pussy and ran down, dripping onto Chloe. Then got just the tip inside Allie and groaned again. Chloe had been right on the edge of orgasm, and was now rubbing her clit vigorously to try and get over the edge. Magnus went on pumping and groaning for a solid 20 seconds into Allie as Sean stared in disbelief. The fuck? Is he part horse, Sean thought.

When Magnus finally pulled out of Allie a torrent of cum flowed from her, some sticking in her bush, the rest running thickly over Chloe's hand that was still working feverishly on her clit and dipping two fingers into her pussy. Those finger were now dripping with Magnus's sticky load. She finally started moaning and bucking her hips onto her plunging, cum-soaked fingers as she came, still kissing Allie deeply.

Allie rolled off of Chloe as the two broke off their long kiss. Everyone laughed together and let out little cheers, then set off toward the kitchen for refreshments. After a minute Allie left to use the restroom and Sean decided to do the same. He walked into the bedroom, but realized he'd left his phone in the kitchen. He started to walk back, but paused just inside the door as he heard Chloe speak.

"Well it's late and we've all been drinking, if you guys want to take the guest room...?"

Magnus smiled, "That sounds great, unless you wanted to go another round?"

Sean made a noise in his throat, but then Chloe said, "That's tempting but Sean's got work in the morning."

Magnus decided to try one more time, "Well if you wanted to chill with me and Allie for a minute..."

Chloe smiled and looked up at him coyly, "Well if we want to do this again I think it's best if I just catch up with Sean." She paused, then went on with a smile, "but maybe after he's asleep and we wont disturb him I'll come surprise you."

Chloe got linens and things for the guest room and helped them get settled. She climbed into bed with Sean a minute later and said,

"So babe. How was your first foursome?"

"Good I guess."

"You guess?"

"Well I feel like there were some lines crossed, but overall it was fun. I wish I could've, uh, performed a little better."

"That's okay baby, it happens to a lot of guys. Especially after a couple drinks." She said, glossing over the lines that may or may not have been crossed.

"So I thought when we talked earlier you weren't going to fuck Magnus again, but then at the end he was back inside you." He was trying not to sound petulant, but not doing a great job.

"What?" She replied, with feigned shock, "i thought that was just the dildo. I really can't tell them apart. I'm so sorry that upset you."

"Oh. Okay. Sorry for getting upset. Um, well, did you enjoy yourself?"

Chloe smiled a big grin, "Very much." Was she blushing just a little, or was that a trick of the light? She leaned over and kissed him goodnight, then turned out the light.