Try To Salvage The Evening

Five minutes passed before the girls followed me inside to the kitchen.

“How’d it go?” I asked.

“Better than I would have expected,” Sabrina said.

“Really?” Josie asked her. “That was the most awkward experience of my life!”

“Then why the hell did you call her the other night?” I asked.

“I have no idea! I’m never drinking again!”

“Are you all still going to be friends?”

“I don’t see how.”

“Of course we will,” Sabrina said. “We grew up together. She’ll get over herself.”

“Has she ever gone after one of your exes?” I asked.

“Oh, yeah,” Josie said. “A few times.”

“Well, there you go.”

“That’s the thing. I wasn’t expecting to get serious with you.”

“This is serious?” I asked.

“We just left our best friend out there crying to come inside to see you,” Sabrina said. “You’d better believe being here means something.”

“Even though the evening is no longer sexy,” Josie said.

“With the two of you in those dresses, I disagree.”

“I appreciate you trying to save the night, Mike, but Josie is right. We aren’t going to salvage it.”

“I understand, but hear me out,” I said as I pulled out a bottle of rum and set it on the counter.

“Noooo!” Josie whined. “Never again!”

“That was tequila,” I reminded her. “This is rum. Rum is our friend.”

“Hey, friend!” Sabrina said with a grin.

“Now,” I said as I pulled out a blender. “Do you want mojitos or daiquiris?”

---

It took three rounds with a heavy pour, but the night began to turn from a downer mood into one of excitement for having survived the confrontation with my ex. The adrenaline left us tired, but the sugar and booze brought back enough energy to end up in my room with the excuse of a movie which turned into cuddling which turned into kissing.

“Do you have any condoms?” Josie asked as she straddled me.

I reached to my nightstand for a new box. “Of course!”

“I can’t wait to take this thing inside me again.”

I turned to Sabrina to find her withdrawn to the corner of my bed. “Care to join us?”

“This is going to sound dumb, especially considering we were all insisting on doing this together, but I’m going to sit this one out.”

“What?” Josie asked. “You have to join us!”

“It’s fine,” Sabrina said. “I’m content to watch tonight.”

“That’s weird!”

“Why, are you here to taste my pussy or to take a pounding?"

“Both,” Josie said as she unzipped my pants.

“Sure, but which one really?”

Josie looked down as she pulled my dick out. “Well, first, I want Mike cock.”

“There you go.”

“But then I want you to lick his cum out of me.”

“That can’t happen if you use a condom, babe,” Sabrina said.

“Oh, right. Well, now we won’t need one because you can lick the cum out like a pudding cup!”

“I don’t think the human tongue is that long,” I said as Josie began stroking me.

“Show him, Babe!”

Sabrina grinned at me and stuck her tongue out past her lips, lengthening all the way down to touch the tip of her chin.

“Holy shit,” I said. “How can you speak with that thing?”

“Never underestimate my skills.”

“Sexy, right?” Josie asked as she mounted me.

“What the hell!” I said as I felt myself surrounded by warmth.

“What? We can still use a condom.”

“I know! But when did you take off your underwear?”

“Take it off? You have to put on underwear to take it off,” Josie said as she began riding me.

“You’re telling me you went through our entire date commando?”

“We both did.”

"Seriously?"

Sabrina grinned at me as she pulled up her dress to show her naked form underneath. “Yep!”

“Those are short dresses! There’s no way you went through dinner bottomless!”

“We were waiting for you to notice,” Sabrina said. “But every time one of us would flash you, you’d be looking at the other girl.”

“You didn’t think of synchronized flashing?”

“Flashing isn’t something you can randomly do in a busy restaurant. You need to time it, from multiple angles.”

“If you had gotten us kicked out, I can’t imagine it being for a better reason,” I said. “Now hide that leg before you make me cum prematurely.”

“Fuck, this feels so good!” Josie said as she bounced on me. “Now I don’t want a condom to ruin this!”

“Careful,” Sabrina said. “He’s already lasted longer than he did the other day.”

“I told you, I don’t usually have a short fuse.”

“So far you’re two for two. Is it really something you want to test?”

“Feels. So. Good!” Josie said with each bounce.

“Finishing inside her once doesn’t mean you should do it again, Mike.”

“I’m not planning on it.”

“Can you imagine?” Josie asked as she rolled her eyes back. “How mad would Jasmine be if I was carrying your baby?”

“That’s one way to make him soft,” Sabrina said.

“Actually, he just grew harder.”

“Really? Now you’re entering the danger zone!”

Josie moaned. “You’re telling me! I can’t believe how much better unprotected cock feels!”

“Last time, you made him flood my pussy with cum by holding me down. Now I can get my **** only using my words! Are you sure you want to give me this power?”

“Absolutely not,” I said. “Come on, Josie, give me a second so I can put on a rubber.”

“Nooo! Please?”

“Did he just get harder again?”

“Yep!”

Sabrina giggled. “This is fun!”

I lifted Josie to move us both closer to my nightstand and snatched up my box of condoms.

“Afraid you won’t last, cowboy?” Sabrina asked with a smirk.

“Maybe I would if your dress wasn’t halfway off.”

“My apologies. Let me fix that right here.”

“I’m leaving mine on to make you last longer,” Josie said.

“Yeah, that’s not helping,” I said as I tried to open the box without looking, distracted by the tits bouncing in my face.

“It’s hotter with the dress on?”

“Of course it is,” Sabrina said. “But really, he’s trying to distract us from what is really turning him on.”

“There are quite a few things, actually,” I said.

“Hey, toss me that box. You seem to be struggling with it.”

“Here,” I said as I handed it to Sabrina. “I’m a bit distracted.”

“Understandable,” she said as she lifted up the hem of her dress even higher. “Hey, now I feel like I’m participating! We’re turning this into a threesome after all!”

“Are you going to open that box, or are you talking about the two of us making a third person?”

Sabrina easily ripped open the box and handed me a condom. “Here.”

“Let me help you with that,” Josie said as she took it out of my hand and ripped the wrapper open.

“Just in time!” I said as I kissed her.

“Are you getting close?”

“Have you seen yourself?”

“Good,” she said with a grin before tossing back the condom over her shoulder and onto my floor.

“The fuck?”

“Oops.”

Sabrina fell over laughing. “Holy shit, girl! I can’t believe you just did that.”

“Sorry,” Josie said, still grinning.

“Oh, is that how it is?” I asked. “We’re playing chicken now?”

“Do it!” Sabrina said. “Destroy your lives!”

“Can I have another one?” Josie asked.

“You think you’re so funny?” I asked as I flipped the girl over and held her arms above her head. “How do you like it when I’m on top?”

Josie moaned. “Holy shit,” she whispered. “This is fucking hot.”

“Yeah?” I asked as I thrust into her. “You like the risk?”

“I guess so!”

“You both do,” Sabrina said. “You have a breeding fetish!”

“Fuck me,” Josie whispered. “Make me cum.”

“Are you close?” I asked.

“I’m right on the edge.”

“Me too.”

Her smile returned. “Give it to me!”

I felt myself harden again, filling the girl even more with each thrust as I pounded her into my bed. I could see Sabrina bouncing along with our rhythm in the corner of my eye, but I was focused on Josie. I waited for any sign of her cracking. I wanted to win this game.

“Are we still playing chicken?” I asked.

I was right on the edge, giving everything I could with long, deep strokes that pushed against her cervix.

Josie’s eyes closed and her face contorted as she was overcome with pleasure. “Yessss Mike! I’m cumming!”

“Holy shit! This is really happening!” Sabrina said. “ Now it's your turn, Mike! Cum inside her! Knock her up! Make those perky tits bigger! Give her a belly!”

“No,” I said. “I’m going to-”

Josie’s eyes opened and she looked right into mine. “Do it.”

I was caught off guard by her earnest request, but I still pulled back. However, I realized too late I was only pulling my head back, my body was still thrust forward and my dick was buried deep inside the girl as I unloaded.

I heard a jet engine taking off as wind blew around my head and all my muscles both tightened and loosened at once. There was no point in pulling out now, so I pumped a massive amount of my seed into the girl after collapsing on top of her.

“Bad news, guys,” Sabrina said. “It looks like you each lost this round.”

“No,” Josie said softly. “We both won.”

“Now,” I said, “get in there and lick your best friend's pretty little pussy clean!”