Tonya

Tonya loses to Terry.

Tonya felt numb as she resumed her position draped over the arm of the couch. She barely noticed and didn't care that Jen was lubing up Terry's cock for him. She barely noticed as he spread her ass and put the head of his cock against her virgin asshole. She had jinxed herself. Josh actually had prepped her ass for someone else. She had lost. The chance of claiming Josh was gone. There was still the chance that he would claim--

That thought fled her mind as she felt the head of Terry's cock penetrate her virgin ass. "Oh god!" she squeaked out.

"You need to relax!" Terry said quietly. "Relax and let it happen."

Her asshole had clamped down on his dick. All the relaxation Josh had given her ass had fled when she saw it wasn't Josh who was going to claim that hole. But then she looked up and saw Jen. Smirking. She and Jen had always has a fierce rivalry. And even though she had lasted longer than Jen, Jen had taken the ass pounding that signified her elimination. If she couldn't do the same, Jen would win. And it wasn't Terry's fault. He won her ass fair and square.

"OK, I'll try." She relaxed and Terry because to slowly work his cock deeper into her ass. After what felt like forever, his hands moved from her hips to her tits and she realized that he was balls deep in her ass. "Give me a minute to get used to...this."

Terry was having the time of his life. Earlier, the girl she was in lust with for years had rode his cock. Now, he was having anal sex with the other girl he was in lust with for years. Gen was right. Tonya's ass felt like heaven. He slid his cock in and out of her ass with long, slow strokes. "Are you okay?"

"It hurts, but it's starting to feel good, too. Keep going." Soon, she began to moan in pleasure and when Terry sped up, they became louder. Eventually, Terry was pounding her ass fast and hard. And she was loving it! She was taking a pounding in her ass just as well as Jen had. And each thrust **** out a loud yell.

"I'm gonna cum!"

"Cum in my ass!" They both yelled out as her whole body spasmed in a hard orgasm and he filled her ass with cum. She had just been sexually conquered by someone not her boyfriend. Again. But she was way too far gone to care at this point. She turned around and gave him a quick kiss. "If Juan dumps me, you're getting promoted to friend with benefits. And if he doesn't, I'll talk him into a threesome. I really want to try a DP!"

"Wow. Either way, I'm in!"