To the victors go the spoils.

After Annabelle cums, Tibby sits up and grins at you. "Am I back in your good graces, captain?"

"You sure are," you tell her. "Come give your captain a hug, kitty."

She rushes at you before you're done talking, knocking you onto your back and sitting on your thighs. Your cock is rock hard at this point, and your pet is quick to free it from your pants. The hand she wraps around it is not quite a hug, but who are you to complain?

Annabelle raises her head to watch the reformed mutineer start jerking you off before turning to Ashley. "Well, they're busy. I guess that makes me your captive."

"And what am I to do with you?" Ashley asks with a coy smile.

"You've taken down my ship, looted my treasure chest... I think all that's left is claiming me as spoils of war. You could order me to service you and I'd have **** but to obey."

"That does sound nice. They say the captain always goes down with the ship, so... your ship's gone down. Now it's your turn," Ashley says. Her hands go under her skirt and she takes her panties off, stretching the elastic waistband to shoot them at Annabelle.

"Right away," Annabelle tells her after catching the flung underwear. "I'm all yours, just lie down and I can get started."

While those two get into position, Tibby moves up as well. When she's hovering above your hips, you put your hands on her sides and guide her down onto your shaft. However, she's still wearing her underwear so all it does is rub against the cotton. Tibby giggles. "Forgetting something?"

Reaching down, she hikes her dress up and tugs her panties to the side. This time when she lets you pull her down your cock slips inside easily, Tibby's cunt welcoming it in with a warm, wet embrace. For a moment you just hold her down against you, but Tibby is already impatient. You can tell she wants to move, so you let go of her and she does!

At first only grinding in small circles, then adding some back-and-forth motions that build until Tibby is bouncing on your cock. You wish she'd taken her dress off first so you could run your hands up her body, but you're fully dressed as well. The only person out of her clothes is Annabelle, who discarded her blouse before going down on Ashley.

But clothed or not, your dick is out of your pants and in Tibby, who is squeaking with excitement as she rides you. Her dress is up around her waist too, which means you can grab her bare ass with both hands and help her bounce away. Since you just sucked on Annabelle's nipples with Ashley, you're too aroused to last very long. But Tibby is at least as excited having spent that time between Annabelle's legs, so you cum within seconds of each other.

Ashley takes a while longer to orgasm, Annabelle taking her time to get a good taste of the bunny. She's lying on her back, legs spread wide, whimpering and begging for more.

You and Tibby decide to give it to her. Crawling up her sides, you help her sit up so Tibby can get her out of her shirt without interrupting Annabelle's work. Then you lie her down again, and moments later both of you have one of her nipples in your mouth. Ashley's hands come around to hold you both to her chest, and you suck eagerly.

Her head flops against the mattress, eyes closed but breathing rapidly. Now Annabelle gives it her all too, and soon Ashley is moaning loudly. None of you let up, pushing the bunny to further heights until she explodes. Her hand clenching in your hair, Ashley groans as she's taken over the peak.

When your head is released you move up to kiss her, but Tibby beats you there. You pinch Ashley's nipple while you wait your turn, producing a yip of protest that's muffled by Tibby's mouth. After the cat lets up you kiss Ashley, and then so does Annabelle.

Eventually they disconnect as well, and Annabelle pulls her leggings up. "Wow. You three take your pirate roleplay seriously. I wish we could do more, but I have to run. After I take a shower and change my clothes, that is. You can help yourself to something to drink from the kitchen in the meantime, ok?"

That's a little disappointing, but you understand. While Ashley goes looking for her panties, you and Tibby fix your clothes. After refreshing yourself in the kitchen, you call out your goodbyes and exit Annabelle's apartment.