They Both Win

As Josh watched Terry fucking Kim in the ass, his cock did get hard again. And right as Terry and Kim came, he suddenly felt a mouth around his cock. Looking under the table he found Maria. "Maria, what are you doing? We haven't dealt yet."

"There's no need," the redhead Latina said as she took his cock out of her mouth. "If I win, I'm picking you. If you win, you know you're picking me. And either way, you're going to fuck me in the ass right now!" Maria got in the middle of the floor on her hands and knees and shook her ass at Josh.

"When you put it that way..." Josh got behind her and lined the head of his cock with her ass.

"Wait a sec. Jen, how about you grab your double dildo and join us."

"Now, that's a great idea!" Jen said as she jumped up and ran to her room.

Josh slid his cock into Maria's already lubed ass. "Oh my god, you fill me up so good!" Josh had immediately lost any reservations about anal sex the moment he felt Maria's tight ass around his cock. He kept his cock balls deep relishing the feeling. Then, Jen came back. She inserted the dildo in her pussy and laid down. Maria, while keeping Josh inside her, crawled on top of Jen and sank the other end of the dildo in her pussy. Her fantasy was coming true with her being sandwiched between the two twins.

"The game's over, right?" Geo asked. However, Jen was too busy moaning in pleasure to answer. "Fuck it, I take that as a yes. Tonya, I'm so pent up right now! I need you!"

Tonya blinked in surprise at Geo's boldness. Then, she remembered how pissed she was at Juan. "You know what? I need to get fucked right now, too." She got on her hands and knees in the floor and Geo wasted no time getting behind her. However, she didn't expect him to ram his cock up her ass!

Juan was likewise pissed at Tonya but he really needed to get off, so he weighed his options. It was very unlikely that he'd be able to join the threesome going on right now. Also, Kim was basically unconscious. However, when Geo rammed his cock up Tonya's ass, she gasped and Juan saw an opportunity that he wasn't about to waste. And that's how Tonya found herself in a very unlikely split roast between Geo and Juan.

While Geo wasn't as big as Terry, he was still only the second person to fuck Tonya in the ass. And he wasn't being gentle at all. Likewise, Juan was fucking her mouth just as roughly. Still, everything was starting to feel really good!

"Hey Geo," Juan said as he pulled his cock out of her mouth. "Flip her over." Not taking his cock out of her ass, Geo repositioned them so that Tonya was on top of him reverse cowgirl with his cock balls deep in her ass. Before Tonya realized what was happening Juan spread his legs and rammed his hard cock into her cunt for the first time.

"Juan?" Tonya asked in confusion.

"Shut up." Then, he started to fuck her hard while Geo thrust up from under her. This isn't how she imagined her first time with Juan would be. Sandwiched between him and another guy with him getting sloppy seconds from yet another guy. But soon, Juan and Geo found a rhythm and fucked her too senseless to care.

Terry and Kim woke up to quite the scene. Tonya being double penetrated by Juan and Geo and Maria by Josh and Jen! "Holy shit," Terry said in amazement.

"Half of them are going to need some therapy after this," Kim said as she snuggled against Terry. Terry caught the hint and cuddled them as they watched the others.

Maria came loudly first. Then, she had a wicked idea. "Let's switch it up a bit."

Jen immediately knew what she meant. "You want Josh to fuck me in the ass, don't you?"

"And I'll eat you out while he does!" Jen and Josh had already committed incest and Josh now enjoyed anal sex so this is something that was bound to happen anyway.

Josh pulled out unsure about this situation but both girls started sucking his cock. "Jen?" Josh asked as his sister bobbed up and down and his cock.

Jen passed his cock to Maria. "It's okay. I want this!"

Maria and Jen got into 69 position with Jen on top and started to eat each other out. Then, Josh got behind Jen and slowly slid his cock up her ass. Jen's head raised up and she moaned loudly. Josh was the biggest she'd had in her ass so she couldn't concentrate on eating out Maria. Maria didn't care as she happily ate out Jen and watched from beneath as Josh fucked Jen's ass. Between the assfucking Josh was giving her, the expert pussy eating Maria was giving her, and her being so very turned on by her own brother fucking her, Jen ended up having a mindblowing orgasm.

Tonya came loudly but Geo and Juan kept fucking her. But Geo didn't last much longer and filled her ass with his cum. With Geo still buried in her ass, Juan kept plowing Tonya's cunt. "Juan! Juan!" Tonya was surprised to find herself yelling out his name. But as he squeezed her tits and looked her in the eye as he fucked her, she found herself about to cum again.

"Tonya!" Juan yelled out as he came deep inside her causing her to cum on his cock, again.

Finally, Josh came inside of Jen's ass. He pulled out and collapsed next to her on his back. Maria managed to disengage from Jen leaving Jen laying on her stomach. "I can't believe...we did that..." Josh said out of breath.

"Me either..." Jen said just as exhausted. Just then, Josh felt Maria's mouth around his softening cock, making him moan.

"You know Jen," Maria said as she smiled at the twins, "Josh was supposed to cum in MY ass. But since he came in yours, I'll just have to reclaim his cum from you." Maria spread Jen's ass and started to lick and suck on her asshole trying to eat Josh's cum out of her. This felt amazing so Jen moaned in pleasure. Josh looked in amazement at the two nymphos and wondered just what he had gotten himself into.