There is another way

Matthew reached for the drawer and took out a cold, small glass container. "Don't worry I've never touched your pussy before. Just lay down on your stomach and relax." She did as she was told while Matthew opened the bottle. She drew a sharp breath as she felt the cold lube hitting her butt. "Don't tell me... you are going to do THIS?" Matthew rubbed his hoc against her lubed ass, gently pushing the tip against her butthole. "Of course we're going to do it anal. don't tell me you forgot about all the times you let me take you from behind. Yo you want me to fuck your pussy instead? You could get pregnant from that." Mayas eyes widened. "No! Please anything but that! I'll do what you say, but not that!" She clenched her fists into the sheets. Matthew slowly and gently put more pressure on her backdoor, while Maya buried her face in a pillow. After a few moments he felt the tip of his cock sliding into her ass, and Maya let out a muffled squeal into her pillow. Taking his stepdaughters anal virginity was pure bliss. The feeling of her tight hole clenched around his cock, accompanied by little squeals with every thrust he made, felt like heaven. He slowly picked up pace, careful not to tear anything by too sudden movements. After a few minutes, he managed to get the full length of his cock buried inside her ass. Maya had tears in her eyes. The unexpected penetration and the alien feeling of cock in her ass was too much for her to handle. Matthew loved the view of the beautiful redhead below him, struggling not to cry out loud, little beads of sweat running off her forehead as she threw him a pleading look, asking him to stop. Matthew was no longer able to hold back and blew his load inside her ass. He moaned out loud as he shot multiple spurts of hot cum shot deep inside his stepdaughters bowels. Maya let out a Lon, painful moan and clenched her hands even harder.

When he was finished, Matthew slowly pulled out his dick, covered in cum and a little blood. His semen oozing out other abused hole.

"You were very brave Maya. Im proud of you. You did your chores to my full satisfaction. Now get up and take a shower, you've earned it"

Maya slowly came to her feet, trying to cover her butt with the little bit of fabric her slutty skirt hat do offer. She left a small trail of cum and blood as she went to the bathroom, trying to walk normal.

Matthew wiped her body fluids off his dick and wondered how he's going to have fun next.