More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 17 by Funtimes Funtimes

What's next?

The beginning turns into the weekend

The purse swings wildly as they stumble through the house, their breathing still heavy from their outdoor escapade. I can only catch glimpses—a hallway, a lamp, the edge of a coffee table—as Sarah carries her purse into what must be Wiley's living room.

"Let me just..." Sarah's voice trails off as the purse settles. The camera angle shifts, and suddenly I have a clear view between Sarah's spread legs as she sits on what appears to be a leather sofa. She's completely naked, her inner thighs glistening with their combined fluids. A thick rivulet of white slowly trickles down her leg.

My breath catches as Sarah looks directly at the purse and gives a subtle wink. She knows exactly what she's showing me.

Beside her, Wiley collapses onto the couch, his chest still heaving. His glasses are askew, his hair a disheveled mess. He looks completely overwhelmed.

"Wow, Sara-be—" he starts, then stops abruptly. I can see him wince at his mistake. "Oh, I mean Sarah. What was that?"

The camera captures Sarah's face as her lips curl into a seductive smile. She shifts slightly, causing another drop of his seed to escape, clearly visible through the purse opening.

"What do you mean?" she asks innocently. "I thought you wanted to fuck me."

Wiley runs a trembling hand through his hair. "I did... But..."

"But what?" Sarah presses, leaning toward him. The movement causes her legs to spread wider, giving me an even more explicit view. "Wasn't it everything you fantasized about?"

"More," he admits, his voice hoarse. "But I never thought... on my front porch? Anyone could have seen us."

Sarah laughs, the sound sultry and confident. "That's what made it exciting." She trails her fingers along his arm. "Did you like showing the neighborhood who you were fucking tonight?"

Wiley's face contorts with a mix of desire and confusion. He shifts on the couch, his eyes searching Sarah's face.

"Sarah, I don't understand what's happening between us," he says, his voice dropping to a near whisper. "This isn't like you. The Sarah I grew up with wouldn't—"

"The Sarah you grew up with has grown up," she cuts in, her fingers trailing down his chest. "People change, Wiley."

He captures her hand, stopping its descent. "That's just it. This feels like... like you're playing some kind of game." His eyes soften, vulnerability seeping through. "Sarah... I love you. I've always loved you. And I more than love having sex with you... but..."

Sarah pulls her hand free from his grasp, her expression hardening slightly. "But nothing," she says firmly. "I came here to have fun... and get fucked... even if someone..." Her eyes flick deliberately toward her purse on the coffee table, and she gives a slow, deliberate wink, "is watching. So, you in or out?"

Wiley follows her gaze to the purse, his brow furrowing. For a moment, understanding seems to dawn on his face, quickly replaced by hurt. He swallows hard, looking back at Sarah with eyes that have lost some of their shine.

"This isn't right," he says quietly. "This isn't you."

But when Sarah slides onto his lap, her naked body pressing against his, his resolve visibly crumbles. His hands move to her hips, his expression torn between desire and disappointment.

"I'm in," he whispers, defeat and desire mingling in his voice.

Sarah smiles triumphantly, grinding against him. "Good choice."

Sarah leans forward, capturing Wiley's mouth in a deep, hungry kiss. Her hand slides between them, fingers wrapping around his hardening cock, guiding him back to her entrance. The camera angle in the purse gives me a perfect view of Wiley's face over her shoulder, his expression a battlefield of emotions.

His eyes roll back as she sinks down on him, but there's something tortured in his features—pleasure fighting against confusion, desire warring with hurt. He looks like a man getting everything he's ever wanted but sensing it's all wrong somehow.

"Oh fuck, Sara-bear," he moans against her lips, the childhood nickname slipping out as his resistance crumbles. "I love you so much."

Sarah breaks the kiss, arching her back as she takes him deeper. "Then show me," she commands, her voice husky with desire. "Use that cock of yours to show me exactly how you feel."

His hands grip her hips tighter, guiding her movements as he thrusts upward. "Oh Sara-bear," he groans, his face contorting with pleasure and something like desperation. "I love you so much... Please... stop this and just be mine..."

The plea in his voice is raw, genuine. For a second, I feel a stab of something like pity for him.

Sarah moans, her head falling back, hair cascading down her spine. "I'll be your something," she purrs, grinding her hips in slow circles. "Your whore for this weekend..."

Wiley's rhythm falters. "What?!"

Sarah stops moving, her body still joined with his but suddenly still. Through the purse camera, I can see her looking down at him, a predatory smile playing on her lips.

"Didn't you notice I didn't bring any bags in?" She trails a finger down his chest. "I plan on being naked all weekend. And as long as you can keep it up, I plan on having your dick inside me the entire time."

Wiley's face is a study in conflict—desire fighting with something deeper, more painful. For a moment, he looks like he might push her off, might demand answers. But then Sarah rolls her hips once, experimentally, and his resolve visibly crumbles.

Wiley’s lips found their way to her nipple, tentative at first, then more insistent—Sarah’s sharp intake of breath and softly murmured “Good, now you’re getting it,” only fueling his hunger. Never mind the tremor in his hands, the low animal whimper vibrating in his throat as he latched on, as if suckling out of need not just for sensation but for some deeper, wordless reassurance. He was pathetic in the way all men are in the throes of worship; Sarah seemed to sense this and pressed his face harder to her breast, her nails digging gentle but possessive half-moons into the back of his neck.

His mouth still locked over her hardening nipple, Wiley tried to speak, the words muffled by flesh and desperation. “I’m not done trying to make you mine,” he whimpered, the sound so pained and needy I almost felt sorry for him—almost. Sarah afforded him no quarter, only a slow, rolling laugh that vibrated through her ribcage and into his open mouth.

“As long as you keep fucking me, however I want to be fucked,” she purred, “you can try all you want.” There was zero mercy in her voice.

If I didn’t hate that gross, perverted, fat pig, I would have actually pitied him. Over the course of that all-consuming weekend, he poured his heart out at every possible opportunity, between the endless marathon of sex and the rare, oxygen-starved pauses for food or water. He clung to her, implored her, pleaded with her—sometimes during, sometimes after orgasm—but try as he might, my girlfriend gave him no sign that any of it was working, no hint that he’d found a secret passage into her heart. The only hole she let him use was the one that milked his cock for every drop of cum he could produce.

Saturday night blurred into Sunday morning. The last time I checked the feed, she was riding him on the living room rug, her hands digging into his chest hard enough to make him yelp. She taunted him, over and over, pushing him to the edge then backing off, the same way a cat plays with a doomed mouse. When he finally broke, crying out her name and grasping at her hips like he was scared she’d vanish if he let go, Sarah just threw her head back and howled. Even through the shitty camera audio, you could hear the triumph in her voice.

By the time sunlight crept through the living room blinds, Wiley was a shell of a man—sweaty, glassy-eyed, barely able to sit up as Sarah straddled his lap, her thighs gleaming with a sticky mixture of their excesses. She made no effort to conceal her nudity, nor to clean herself up. Instead, she grabbed his phone and opened the front-facing camera, snapping a selfie of the two of them: Wiley slack-jawed and dazed, Sarah radiant and smug, a bead of white trailing down her inner thigh. She sent it to me with the caption “ur move, babe ;)”

At checkout time, she didn’t bother putting on pants. The only difference between now and Friday was Wiley’s seed drying on her skin, and a new, mean glint in her eye. She gathered her purse and her shoes and padded toward the door, not even glancing back at the man sprawled and ruined on his own sofa.

Wiley, for his part, looked at her with a helpless, pleading expression I’d seen before on sick puppies and abandoned children. “Do you have to leave?” he whispered, the words nearly lost in the cavern of his empty townhouse.

Sarah turned at the threshold, silhouetted by the morning light. She laughed, loud and musical. “Yes, I do.”

He tried again. “But don’t you feel anything between us?” His voice cracked on the last word.

Sarah crossed the living room in three quick strides and crouched in front of him, face inches from his. “Of course I do, Wile E. Coyote,” she said, and kissed him once on the cheek—chaste, almost sisterly. “I love you like a brother.” Before he could protest, she stood, slinging her bag over her naked shoulder.

Wiley blinked dumbly, pain flickering across his features. “But I love you more than that,” he said, so quietly you could barely hear him. “Can’t you see that?”

Sarah ruffled his sweat-soaked hair. “Trust me, I see it,” she said, eyes flicking briefly to the purse camera on the coffee table.

Wiley voice was full of desperation as he said, “I’ll never stop trying to make you feel the same way I do.”

She gave me a sly, conspiratorial wink, then turned back to Wiley. “If I come back, as long as you fuck me you can keep trying to change my mind, but you should know…” She leaned forward again, her lips brushing the shell of his ear, “it won’t work.” She made sure the words landed, then waltzed out the front door, still naked, not the slightest bit self-conscious.

I watched, slack-jawed, as she let herself out onto the porch, stretched luxuriously in the pale sunshine, and walked to her car in nothing but a smile and yesterday’s makeup. Wiley, meanwhile, remained frozen on the couch, hands limp, jaw trembling, eyes fixed on the spot where she’d just been. It was almost sad. Almost.

An hour later she texts me “You better be ready, because I can’t wait for you to reclaim me.”

I text her back “oh trust me, after that show I am more than ready.”

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)