Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 10
by
TheTGBro
What does she choose?
The back
"My back!" Carrie yelled, her voice cracking with a mixture of panic and **** desire. It was the safest option: a way to avoid the total ownership of the incoming creampie or the humiliation of the on-a-whim mouth usage.
But as you watched from the crack in the door, you realized this safety was an illusion. Justin didn't hesitate. With a grunt of exertion that sounded like an animal claiming its territory, he withdrew his massive, glistening, raw, animalistic cock. He didn't even let her collapse. He kept one heavy hand planted firmly between her shoulder blades, pinning her flat against the mattress.
"Then wear it, bitch," Justin snarled.
He erupted. It wasn't a trickle; it was a deluge. You saw first-hand as thick ropes of semen shot out, splashing heavily against the smooth, pale skin of Carrie’s lower back. She shuddered with every pulse, her body going limp under the weight of his release. It was splattered all across her back, slowly dripping downward toward her ass. It was a visual testament to what she had just done, substantive and undeniable.
But the true horror wasn't the fluid splashing onto the bed. It was standing right beside her.
Paralyzed in the darkened hallway, your eyes darted from the wet sheen on your girlfriend's skin to David. He was standing just a few feet away from the lovers, bathed in the soft light of his own bedroom, but he wasn't looking at the climax. He was looking down at his own phone, his thumbs flying across the glass. You saw the blue light reflect in his eyes as he tapped away on his own device.
You realized as you swallowed your breath that he wasn't recording for his own personal private collection. He was uploading the footage onto the social media, onto his timeline and tagging Carrie in return. Your silence was last permission he needed to broadcast it to her entire network. Tagging her made sure every friend, family member, and yoga student she knows got the notification.
Panic didn't send you running back to your room; shame did. You couldn't bear to be standing there when they came out, to be seen as the impotent witness to your own destruction. You fled back to your bedroom, scrambling into your bed, naked and trembling.
You closed your eyes, but the image was burned behind your lids. You detached yourself from the reality completely. It felt like you were watching a movie, a dark tragedy where the protagonist is a helpless bystander as he loses the girl of his dreams to a stronger, more primal ****. The dissociation was dizzying. In that headspace, the pain transmuted into a sick, twisted arousal. You grabbed your cock, stroking furiously, needing to feel release as the emotions swelled into you and burned your dick with a hot pain.
You replayed the scenes: the "I love you," the submission, the semen coating her back, editing it in your mind until it was just simple pornography. You pumped faster, the friction building, chasing endorphins that would numb the pain. When you finally climaxed, spilling ropes of jizz onto your stomach, with greater volume than you had done with Carrie earlier today, the fantasy shattered.
You snapped back to reality the second the orgasm faded. The post-nut clarity hit you. This wasn't a movie. That was Carrie. That was Justin. And that video, the confession of love, was now circulating through her social circle via David's tag. The consequences weren't plot points; they were your life now.
You lay there in the dark, breathing heavy, staring at the ceiling, waiting for the inevitable.
It was fifteen minutes later when the door creaked open.
Carrie slipped inside. The smell of sex followed her instantly: musk, sweat, and the distinct scent of semen. She was flushed, her hair a chaotic mess, her chest heaving as she leaned against the doorframe for support. She looked destroyed, but in a chaotic way. Beautifully ruined.
She didn't know you had been in the hallway. She thought you had been here, waiting, obediently stroking your cock while she handled business.
"Oh my god," she breathed, pushing off the door and stumbling toward the bed. She crawled up next to you, her skin radiating heat. "Baby... you have no idea."
She was eager, her eyes wide and dilated, the adrenaline of the encounter still coursing through her. She began to recount the events, but the way she told it was jarring. To her, it was just a game.
"I was so totally surprised, babe," she said, her voice trembling slightly as she replayed the memory. "When David texted about 'Round Two,' I honestly thought it was just going to be him again. I walked in there ready for him, and then... he walked into the bedroom. Justin. My heart literally stopped. I almost turned around and ran right then and there."
You stared at her, trying to reconcile the woman in front of you with the story you knew. "But... you stayed. And Carrie, I thought you hated him. You've always said you despised him."
Carrie laughed. "I do!" she confirmed emphatically, nodding her head. "I absolutely hate him. He's a pig, he's rude, and he treats women like trash. I can't stand being in the same room as him usually."
She leaned in closer, her voice dropping to a whisper. "But that's what made it so hot, babe. The shock of him being there, and then... hate-fucking him. Being **** to submit to someone I genuinely detest? Having to look that asshole in the eye and scream 'I love you' just so he wouldn't leave me empty? It was such a mindfuck. It was degrading in the best way possible."
You looked at her, seeing the disconnect. She viewed the hatred as something to spice up your shared fetish. You had seen something different. The way she screamed it didn't sound like hate. It sounded like surrender.
"Carrie," you managed to **** out, your voice hoarse. "The video... David uploaded it."
She waved a hand dismissively, rolling onto her back and wincing slightly, likely from the soreness or the drying fluids on her skin. "I know, I know. My phone started blowing up with notifications before I even left the room. David tagged me in it."
"And you're okay with that?" You sat up, incredulous. "Carrie, everyone knows you hate him. Now everyone sees you screaming that you love him. Everyone you know."
She turned her head to you, her expression softening into something more patronizing. "It’s not such a big deal, babe. People post crazy shit all the time. It’s just sex. Besides..." She reached over to the nightstand where she had placed her phone. She tapped the screen and slid it across the sheets toward you.
"I'm too exhausted to deal with the comments. I'm going to pass out," she said, nestling into your pillow, pulling the covers up to her chin. "You handle it."
"Me?" You looked at the phone, then back at her.
"Yeah. Reply to the comments. Downplay it, exaggerate it, tell them I'm a slut, tell them it's just a game... whatever you want." She closed her eyes, a sleepy smile playing on her lips. Then, her eyes snapped open for a second, sharp and lucid.
"But just a warning, sweetie," she murmured. "Your comments are your commitment. Whatever you say on there... I'm going to hold you to it. You tell the world I'm Justin's property? Then I guess I am. You try to backpedal and say it was a joke? Then you better be ready to punish me for lying to you. I will reenact anything you write. Even if you try to take it back in the morning."
She closed her eyes again. "Goodnight, babe. Make me look good."
Within moments, her breathing evened out. She was asleep, exhausted by the thorough using she had just endured.
You were left alone in the dim light of the bedroom, the glow of her phone screen illuminating your face. You picked it up. The notification light was blinking furiously. You unlocked it and opened the app.
The video was there on her timeline, shared from David's profile. The thumbnail was a blur of motion, but the caption David had written was clear as day: Stuck-up bitch gf finally admits who she really belongs to. @Carrie_Yoga
You swallowed hard and scrolled down to the comments section. It had only been up for twenty minutes, but because he had tagged her, the engagement was pouring in. As your eyes scanned the handles, your stomach twisted. You recognized some of them.
Kyle_M: Damn, is that really Carrie? I always knew she was a freak. Look at the way she’s clawing the sheets. That ain't acting, bro.
YogaJen: Carrie?? Omg I can’t believe this is on my feed. Wait... is that Justin from the bar? I thought you guys had beef? You look pretty cozy here...
BigT44: LOL look at her eyes rolling back. She’s gone. That’s the look of a woman who just realized her boyfriend can’t satisfy her.
Chloe: This has to be a deepfake, right? There is no way Carrie would do this. Someone report this immediately.
Local_Lad: Where’s the boyfriend while this is happening? Does he know his girl is getting plowed by that guy? What a cuck.
Cousin_Mike: Uhh... Carrie? You know Grandma follows you on here, right? Might want to report this.
Justin_the_Beast: She knows her place. Just needed a real man to remind her.
Davidxx1488: Replying to @Justin_the_Beast: You broke her, man. She's been asleep since she crawled back to her room. Total savage.
FitGirlTrish: I don't know if this is real or fake, but if that's real... that is the sound of a woman who is NEVER going back to vanilla sex.
You stared at the screen. YogaJen was her colleague at the studio. Chloe was her best friend. Cousin Mike... god, her family was seeing this. And the skeptical comment, Chloe, offered you a lifeline, a way to pretend it wasn't real. But the comments from Justin and David, gloating right there in public view, were anchoring you to reality.
But it was FitGirlTrish that made your blood run cold. That was Trish from the upscale gym downtown, the fitness influencer Carrie obsessed over. Carrie was constantly checking Trish's feed, jealous of her following, her abs, and her "no-fucks-given" attitude. For Trish to not only see this but to validate it, to say that Carrie was "never going back", felt like a devastating seal of approval from the one woman Carrie wanted to impress.
Your thumb hovered over the "Reply" button. The weight of Carrie's ultimatum pressed down on you. Your comments are your commitment.
If you defended her or claimed it was fake, then Justin would be back. He would be wondering why Carrie isn't following the rules of the arrangement. If you leaned into it, if you validated the humiliation, you were sealing your fate. You were writing the script for the rest of your relationship. You looked at Carrie's sleeping form, the faint smell of Justin still clinging to her, and then back at the blinking cursor.
You began to type.
How do you respond to the comments?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
The “Anything” Promise
The girlfriend who’ll do ANYTHING
Your new girlfriend says she’ll do “anything” and she means it
Updated on Apr 28, 2026
by devlinc
Created on Oct 7, 2018
- 80,736 Likes
- 24,761,308 Views
- 7,700 Favorites
- 13,109 Bookmarks
- 1,762 Chapters
- 92 Chapters Deep
- All Comments
- Chapter Comments