The Second Evening - Game Time

It started to rain and turn cold that night after dinner, so the friends all hang out in the spacious living room of the beach house, each couple on a couch, drinking, laughing, and having a good time, a fire roaring in the fireplace. They are all dressed comfortably, mainly in sweat clothes or pajamas. Stephanie wears her shoulder length light blonde hair down, while Lisa has hers in a ponytail.

Kayla is cuddled up with Cal on one of the couches, looking at Stephanie laying in Jackson’s arms, staring at her anklet. Cal leans over and whispers in Kayla’s ear, “Hey I meant to tell you real quick, it’s true about Brian and Lisa.” She looks at him and quietly asks, “What are you saying, Cal?” “What I’m saying is, you know, I’m down if you are.” Kayla looks over at Brian and Lisa and says, “I know you want to fuck her Cal, and I love you baby. AND I’m willing to let you have your fun and fuck your first white girl, but I dunno. You know my last boyfriend was white, and he didn’t exactly . . . measure up to my size standards.” Cal laughs and says, “Oh yeah? Well not this dude.” Kayla looks at him and he quickly tells her, “I talked to him. He says the reason they swing is because he has a big dick, and his girl can’t always handle it.” Kayla looks at him, shocked, and Cal just shrugs, leaving her wondering.

After a few hours drinking, Lisa says, “Hey, let’s play a game you guys.” Stephanie responds “Sure! That’s a great idea! What do you want to play?” After a brief discussion, Cal says “How about spin the bottle?” Kayla smacks him lightly on the arm, saying “Oh my god Cal, what are we, eleven years old?”and everyone laughs. Lisa suggests Would You Rather, and everyone agrees. She says “Good! But let’s make it a little spicy! I’ll go first . . . OK Steph, would you rather have kinky sex or romantic sex?” Everyone laughs and right away Stephanie answers “Oh, kinky sex, all day!” Everyone bursts out laughing, and she asks Brian, “So, would you rather make out with your boss or watch your boss make out with Lisa?” He quickly says “Oh that’s easy, my boss is a guy so in that case I would DEFINITELY rather see Lisa kissing her boss.” Lisa says, “Ew, that’s gross, Frank is like, 70 years old!” Everyone laughs at this, and after a minute Brian says, “OK, Kayla - would you rather have sex with someone who is really skilled or someone with an attractive body?” Kayla thinks for a bit and responds “I guess I’d rather have someone with good skills.” Cal says “Lucky for you I have both!” Everyone roars with laughter as Kayla replies, “Huh, says you!”

Everyone is pretty drunk now, and Cal whispers in Kayla’s ear, “Hey, I’m still down, you down?” Kayla tipsily responds “Not sure, but I AM curious . . .” Cal smiles at her and says “Let’s go for it. I mean, what the hell, no one is gonna know, and Stephanie’s already fucking around.” Kayla looks at him and replies, “Yeah, OK. But if he was bullshitting you about the size of his dick, you are NEVER going to hear the end of it!” Cal sits back and laughs, saying “I love you, baby.” Kayla smiles at him, replying “I love you too, baby.”

Kayla then asks Jackson, “OK, Jackson, would you rather have bad sex with a woman or get the best blowjob of your life from a guy?” Jackson says, “Aww HELL NO, I ‘aint fucking no dude, man, I don’t roll like that.” He then asks Lisa, “Hmm, OK Lisa, would you rather get caught having sex in public or catch someone else having sex?” Lisa thinks for a bit and then says “Getting caught.” Everyone whoops at this, and then she says “Cal - would you rather have sex with one person watching or with 50 people watching?” Cal immediately says, “50 people. The more the merrier!” and everyone laughs. Cal then looks at Kayla and says, “Hey Kayla, would you rather have sex with an older guy with a big dick or a drunk sex with your best friend?” “Damn,” she responds, thinking. Finally she says “I guess I’d fuck the guy with the big dick,” before adding “Like the song says, ‘Don’t want no short dicked man.’” Everyone bursts out laughing at this.

Lisa looks at Kayla and says, “Your in luck, girl, ‘cuz THIS guy’s gotchya covered!” and points to her boyfriend. Everyone roars at this and Kayla says, “Oh yeah? Well, I’ll be the judge of that!” This causes everyone to explode in laughter. Finally things calm down and, as Jackson wraps his arms around Stephanie, Lisa says “Well, go on dear, let her be the judge of it.” Brian smiles at her, stands up and drops his pajama pants.