Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 16
by
Mr Nice Guy
What's next?
The Ringer
Craig spent far longer than he wanted standing in front of the closet.
The afternoon light spilling through the bedroom window did nothing to improve his mood. It only made the situation clearer. Every option hanging on the rack was some variation of fitted, cropped, sleeveless, lacy, or otherwise impractical for athletics. Apparently the ancient god currently redesigning his life had not considered the possibility that Craig might one day need to play recreational basketball.
Eventually he pieced together the closest thing he could find to something athletic... well... at least something that wouldn't rip apart while he was on the court.
The skirt came first. Blue, pleated, and short enough that the fabric fanned out when he turned even slightly. It reminded him of a tennis skirt, which at least felt vaguely sports-adjacent. That was something.
Next came a pink cropped tank top, snug around his torso and short enough that his entire midriff showed whenever he lifted his arms. Not ideal. But it allowed his shoulders to move freely, which felt like the more important priority if he was going to pretend to play basketball.
Blue and white sports socks followed, pulled up halfway to his calves. The last vestige of his male clothes.
Then the shoes. Craig stared at them for a long moment before sighing. Pink and white wedge sneakers sat where his old athletic shoes should have been. At least they were designed like running shoes, even if the soles rose into a ridiculous wedge heel. Compared to the stilettos he'd worn the night before, they almost looked reasonable.
Almost.
Once the shoes were laced and tightened, he stood and tested his balance.
Effortless.
The strange grace his body now carried made the movement feel completely natural. Walking across the room in them felt no different than wearing ordinary sneakers once had. No, that wasn't entirely true. He felt more agile than before, as if the heels had somehow unlocked a secret athlete hidden inside of him, held back by flat-soled shoes.
Still.
A glance in the mirror did nothing to soothe his nerves. The skirt was short. Too short. Every step threatened to lift the pleats just enough to show the pink lace panties underneath. A careful turn confirmed the suspicion. One wrong movement and the lace flashed clearly beneath the hem.
Fantastic.
Craig grabbed the keys to Frank's car. If the basketball guys reacted the way Frank had this morning, maybe it wouldn't matter.
Hopefully.
The drive over turned out to be the least stressful part of the afternoon. Frank's car started with a familiar rumble, and once Craig slid into the driver's seat he realized something surprising: driving in heels was easy. The wedge sneakers rested comfortably on the pedals, the angle of his feet fitting the shape naturally. A few experimental presses of the accelerator confirmed it. Smooth. Controlled. No awkward ankle bending required.
He merged into traffic feeling cautiously optimistic. Maybe the whole afternoon would go smoothly.
A red light stopped him a few blocks from the gym. Craig leaned back slightly in the seat and waited, fingers drumming on the steering wheel. Sunlight warmed the side of his face through the window. Then a shadow rolled up beside him.
A black Dodge Ram idled in the next lane, tall enough that the driver looked down into Craig's car like he was peering into a fish tank. The man behind the wheel was thick-necked and broad-shouldered, the type who looked like he could bench press a refrigerator for fun. Several bumper stickers decorated the truck's rear window: loud declarations about politics, freedom, and various opinions that didn't exactly scream open-mindedness.
Craig kept his eyes forward. No reason to invite interaction.
Still, curiosity tugged at him. His gaze drifted sideways. The driver was looking directly at him.
For a split second Craig braced for confusion, laughter, or worse. Instead, the man gave a short nod of approval. The kind men sometimes exchanged silently at stoplights. A simple gesture of respect.
Craig blinked.
Then the light turned green and the truck roared away.
The moment left him sitting there for half a second longer than necessary before he pressed the gas.
Weird.
The gym buzzed with the echo of bouncing basketballs and squeaking sneakers. Craig stepped through the entrance trying not to look as self-conscious as he felt. The wedge sneakers clicked softly against the polished floor as he crossed toward the court Frank had described.
Several guys in gym shorts and jerseys were already warming up. One of them spotted him and waved.
"Hey! Frank's sub!"
Craig slowed. So they were expecting him. Good. That meant this might go smoothly.
"Yeah," Craig said as he approached. "Frank's pretty wrecked today."
A few sympathetic groans went around the group.
"Yeah, that tracks," one of them laughed.
Another player gave Craig an appraising look.
Across the court, someone on the opposing team leaned over to look more closely.
"Oh come on," that guy called out. "You guys seriously bringing in a ringer today?"
Craig nearly choked.
"Oh, no, no," he said, raising both hands to show he was no threat. "Definitely not. I don't really play much."
The group exchanged amused looks.
"You'll do great," one of them said casually.
Another tossed him a ball.
"Just move around. Have fun."
The confidence made Craig feel even more out of place. Still, when the game started and the ball began flying across the court, something unexpected happened. Moving felt... good.
Really good.
Those wedge sneakers that had seemed ridiculous earlier gripped the court perfectly. His balance shifted easily from step to step. The skirt fluttered around his thighs as he ran, but the motion never slowed him down. If anything, it made him feel lighter. Quicker. Each stride sent the pleats lifting slightly, cool air brushing against his legs. He tried very hard not to think about what that meant for the pink lace underneath.
Craig had intended to stay near the edge of the court and mostly exist as a legal body. Instead, he found himself running. Pivoting. Keeping up.
At one point a teammate passed the ball in his direction. Pure reflex made Craig catch it.

Panic followed immediately. Everyone was watching. The basket stood ten feet away. His heart hammered.
Just shoot.
Craig jumped. The motion felt effortless. Legs extended, arms lifted, wrists flicked. The ball arced cleanly through the air.
Swish.
The net snapped softly.
Craig stared.
His teammates erupted.
"Nice!"
"See?!"
"Told you!"
Heat rushed to his face as he jogged back across the court, trying to pretend that hadn't surprised him as much as it had.
The game continued. Momentum built. By the final minute the score sat nearly tied, both teams pushing hard. Craig barely noticed how naturally he moved now.
The ball came loose near midcourt. One of his teammates scooped it up and passed.
Straight to Craig.
Instinct took over. He ran. Two defenders closed in, sneakers squealing across the floor. The basket loomed ahead. The skirt flared as he pivoted, the pleats lifting dangerously high. Craig planted his foot and jumped.
For a brief moment the entire gym seemed to hold its breath.
Arms extended.
Release.
The ball dropped cleanly through the hoop.
Cheers exploded around the court. Craig landed lightly on his wedge heels without stumbling.
Only then did he realize something else had happened.
The jump had flipped his skirt straight up. Cool air brushed against his thighs. Pink lace flashed brightly beneath the hem for anyone facing him. Meaning, of course, the entire gym.
Craig yanked the skirt down immediately, face burning.
But no one reacted. No laughter. No confusion. Just celebration. Teammates rushed toward him, clapping his shoulders and cheering.
"Game winner!"
"Hell yeah!"
"Frank's gonna owe you big time!"
Craig stood there catching his breath, still flushed from the sprint and the embarrassment, while the team celebrated around him. Somehow, despite everything, they'd won.
And apparently, panties and all, Craig had just been the hero of the game.
What's next?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Soulmates
Eros is here to help
A young man find himself catching the attention of the god Eros while carrying a fresh rejection from a woman he liked, only to discover that he already has a soulmate! Only it's a little complicated...
Updated on Jun 10, 2026
by Mr Nice Guy
Created on Feb 15, 2026
by Mr Nice Guy
- All Comments
- Chapter Comments