Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 186 by Mr Nice Guy Mr Nice Guy

What's next?

Tea and Tension

Joey had tried not to squirm.

He sat at the Patels' kitchen table with his knees close together, Donna beside him, glitter twinkling under the fluorescent light. The tea was untouched. He didn't even like tea, but now didn't seem like the time to say so.

This was worse than anything he'd imagined. Donna had insisted they come, said it would be an important visit and that Indira needed their support. Joey still wasn't sure what she meant by that. But the minute the door opened and he saw the tightness in Neha Patel's mouth, he knew this would go badly.

The small talk never happened. There was tea, and silence, and then the conversation twisted itself into a knot of veiled insults, rising volume, and long-simmering suspicion.

Neha Patel didn't trust them.

At all.

"She is a child. My child. And I see exactly what this is. This isn't support. This is grooming. This is manipulation. You're all trying to make her like you—and for what? For boys like him to have their way with her?"

Joey flinched as if slapped.

His jaw tightened. His eyes dropped to the table, fists slowly clenching in his lap. He heard the scrape of Donna shifting beside him but didn’t look. His stomach churned.

Grooming. Manipulation.

Words that stabbed deep, not because they were true—because they weren't. And yet they were words that had power, because adults used them. Because mothers used them. Because women like Neha Patel said them with such absolute certainty.

He'd been called names before. Loser. Pervert. Creep. He could shrug those off. But this? This felt different.

He didn't want to be the villain in someone's story. Not hers. Not Indira's.

"She is not going to end up in some boy's bedroom," Neha snapped. "She will not become a dropout or a bimbo or a—thing for him to play with. I forbid it."

Joey swallowed. His nails dug into his palms. He heard the word "thing" like it echoed.

He wasn't even sure what he wanted from Indira. He liked her, sure. She was smart. She listened to him. She looked at him like he mattered.

But he hadn't touched her. He hadn't done anything.

"You should be ashamed. And you call yourself a mother. English is my second language, but at least I know what that word means. You are not good people."

That did it.

The air in the room shifted.

It didn't make a sound, but something subtle—psychic, maybe—reoriented itself. A current reversed. Joey's thoughts slowed. Clarified.

The pain was still there, but it wasn't hot anymore. It was cold now. Clean. Like ice water running through his limbs. It steadied him. His shoulders relaxed, just slightly. He looked up.

Donna went quiet beside him.

Neha stopped mid-breath.

Joey blinked once. Slow. His gaze locked on Neha Patel with that strange, detached intensity that felt more like instinct than will.

"Um," he said, softly.

"Actually…"

The room waited. His voice was calm. But it pressed.

"...my mother is an ideal mother. Anyone who thinks otherwise is an idiot."

Neha's face twitched. Her brows drew together like she was about to protest, but nothing came out.

Joey kept going.

"And Indira is an adult. She should get to make her own decisions about her future. Yes, she's a good girl. But if she wants to become a dropout, or a bimbo, or spend her nights in a boy's bedroom... that's up to her. Not you."

Silence.

For a few long moments, no one breathed.

Then: Neha sat back in her chair, spine straight but eyes glazed over slightly—conflicted, like she was trying to remember the thread of her argument but couldn't quite find it. Her lips parted once, then shut again.

Joey didn't speak. He didn't need to.

He could feel it—the idea sinking in. Not like a knife, but like dye in water. Irreversible. Absorbed.

Neha looked from Joey to Donna. Her voice, when it came, was quieter. Not submissive exactly, but... different.

"I... suppose I've been very controlling. I didn't mean to insult you," she said slowly, fingers tightening around her teacup. "I only want what's best for Indira. But I may not know what that is anymore."

Donna smiled softly. "None of us do. That's why we give them space to become who they're meant to be."

Neha nodded faintly, the motion stiff but real.

It was only then Joey heard the creak of the hallway floor.

He turned.

Indira.

Her bedroom door was open just a crack, enough for her to peek out. Her dark eyes were wide, watching. A soft expression sat on her face—uncertain, ****, curious.

Their eyes met.

Red blossomed in her cheeks as she stared at him. The corners of her mouth began to curl upwards, her eyes seeming to calculate something, an idea, or a formula she'd just forgotten.

Joey felt his heart twist, something warm and dangerous rising up from his gut, a surprising taste of affection for a girl he hardly knew, but now realized that their destinies were forever intertwined.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)