Chapter 37
by
Mr Nice Guy
What's next?
Taking the Wheel
Evan drove past the bus stop without slowing down.
The sight of it barely registered at first, just a familiar part of the morning, a place he'd stood at more times than he could count. It wasn't until he was halfway down the block that the realization actually settled in.

Right.
He didn't need to take the bus anymore.
Hands shifted slightly on the steering wheel as the thought caught up to him. The difference wasn't dramatic on the surface. He was still heading to the same place, still dealing with the same classes, but something about it felt significant in a way he couldn't quite ignore. This wasn't a one-time event. This was his life now.
His life.
His car.
It had been sitting in the driveway that morning, exactly where it belonged. Clean, polished, expensive in a way that still felt slightly unreal. His dad hadn't been home, having apparently stayed out for the night, giving them space. Normally he would have asked permission before taking the car out. Permission and a request for gas money. But not that morning. Nor any morning going forward.
It was like a switch had flipped somewhere, allowing his brain to fully make the connection. The car was his, and would be his from now on. What had been taken from his dad and given to him would never go back.
Stacy's car, a small red hatchback, had been parked next to the sedan when he left that morning. Evan still remembered his father buying it for her after they'd been married less than a month. A gift that must have seemed extravagant to the new bride at the time, before she became used to the opulence that came with being married to Evan's dad.
Only it wasn't Evan's dad who had bought the car. Not anymore. Now it would have been a gift from her new husband, Evan himself. How had history been rewritten when this new world's Evan handed her the keys. Had she been ecstatic? Had she thanked him? Had it gotten physical?
A shot of heat spread out from his groin. A new phenomenon that morning, not entirely welcome. Each time Stacy entered his mind, each time he thought of her, a small rush of arousal hit him. Not a distracting, uncomfortable level of arousal like he'd felt the night they'd slept apart, but a quick flush of heat, a reminder of how the potion's magic wanted him to see her.
Things were shifting. Not gradually, not subtly, but quickly. Intensely. Completely.
It was more than just being married to his father's wife. Now he had control of so much more. Their home, their finances, all of it was under his name. One day he was just beginning his adult life, going to school, figuring out who he was and what he wanted. The next day he was already established, with all the responsibilities that came with it. Pieces of a life that used to belong to someone else now sitting squarely in his hands.
The light ahead turned green, and the car rolled forward smoothly as his thoughts drifted back to the conversation that morning.
"I need you to take the lead."
Stacy's voice had been steady when she said it, but everything else about her hadn't been. There had been something underneath the words: something tight, strained, barely held together. Not just frustration or anger, but something closer to fear.
And trust, something he'd never had from her before. Something he wasn't sure he deserved.
She hadn't been deflecting. Hadn't been arguing. For once, there hadn't been any edge to it at all. Just a quiet, uncomfortable honesty that he hadn't expected from her.
And she'd meant it.
For whatever reason, she was right. He could, at least so far, push back a little more than she could. Not by much, and definitely not consistently, but there was a gap there. Just enough space to think before reacting. Enough to recognize what was happening and make a choice.
Enough to stop her.
A memory came forward to his conscious mind, vivid enough to make his grip tighten on the steering wheel. The warmth of her body against his. The slow, deliberate movement of her hand on his penis. Again a shot of arousal hit him, not just because of the content of the memory, but because it featured Stacy.
Evan shifted slightly in his seat, jaw tightening, dropping his hand to adjust himself in his jeans.
That gap mattered.
Whether it was him that was doing it or the magic allowing it, it didn't really change anything. Maybe him being able to resist was part of the magic's plan. Maybe it was an accident. Maybe it was just temporary and would disappear the longer this went on.
That possibility lingered longer than he liked. Because if it did disappear, if whatever resistance he had now just faded, then what? Would he end up like her? Acting without thinking. Wanting without choosing. Losing track of where instinct ended and influence began.
He shook it off, knowing that he would make himself crazy worrying about what might or might not happen. Right now, what was happening was that Stacy needed him, and he'd already agreed. He was in it.
Which meant paying attention. Staying aware. Not letting things slide just because it was easier. Because the magic wasn't leaving him alone either, as another shot of arousal hit him the moment he started thinking of her. Quick and sharp, low in his stomach. Not overwhelming, not consuming, just a brief pulse of heat that faded almost as quickly as it appeared. Subtle, but persistent. Predictable.
Evan exhaled slowly through his nose.
Annoying. Unavoidable. Trying to pretend it wasn't happening felt about as useful as ignoring the weather. It didn't change anything. So he'd deal with it, be aware of it, fight the feelings when they came.
Because this whole situation was on him. His fault. His responsibility. He would take care of Stacy because it was the least he could do.
Not because he liked her. Far from it. Stacy was still Stacy. Pushy. Mean. Judgemental. The woman who'd made his life harder, colder. The woman who had driven a wedge between him and his dad.
What Evan was committing to had nothing to do with Stacy. It had everything to do with him. What he'd done. How he'd failed. Nothing in him wanted to let anyone suffer because of his mistakes. Not even Stacy.
This wasn't about what he wanted anymore. Not really. It was about doing the right thing. Even if that meant being the one to say no. Even if it meant stepping back when everything in his body was pushing the other direction. Even if it meant dealing with whatever fallout came after.
She'd asked him to take the lead. So he would. Even if he had no idea what that actually looked like yet.
Campus came into view ahead, buildings rising into a skyline that suddenly felt disconnected from everything else going on in his life. Classes still existed. Assignments still mattered. People were still moving through their day like nothing had changed.
Which, in a way, made it all feel even stranger. Life hadn't paused for this. It had just folded it in.
The study group pressed back into his thoughts, bringing a new layer of tension with it. Tonight. A house full of classmates. Professor Caldwell. And Stacy.
She'd said she would do it. Commit to it. Play the role. He still didn't know what that meant, what she was planning on doing.
A knot formed low in his stomach as he turned onto campus, easing into the flow of traffic. Would she lean into it? Would the magic push her further in front of other people? Would she even realize if it did?
The memory of Caldwell's words surfaced, unhelpfully clear.
Your wife was... remarkably persuasive.
Evan grimaced.
For a moment, his thoughts drifted back to Madame Ruth. The shop. The finality in her voice when she'd explained the rules. Permanent. But maybe...
Maybe there was something else. Some kind of adjustment. Or something to add on. A way to make this easier. Manageable.
No.
That was how this all started. Reaching for control where he didn't have any. Messing with something he didn't understand. He wasn't making that mistake again.
The car turned into a parking lot, tires crunching softly against the pavement as he scanned for an open space. One problem at a time. That was all he could manage.
Classes first. Then tonight. Everything else could wait.
The thought of Stacy surfaced again, uninvited. Another quick pulse of heat followed. Evan let out a sharp breath, pulling into an empty spot.
"Damnit."
What's next?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Love Potion Number Ten
Madame Ruth's Finest Work
Love Potion Number Nine worked a little too well, so Madame Ruth's decided to go a different route for her newest creation.
Updated on Jun 11, 2026
by Mr Nice Guy
Created on Dec 28, 2025
by Mr Nice Guy
- All Comments
- Chapter Comments
