More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 16 by BigSash

What's next?

Surreal

It was a surreal, almost dreamlike situation. Lilith, my goth crush of three years, someone I’d never dared to speak to beyond fleeting glances, was under my control. Her pale, youthful body—thin but not skinny, with modest breasts that rose and fell with each shuddering breath—was bare before me, glistening faintly in the firelight. She was pleasuring herself, her fingers moving frantically, driven by the hypnotic suggestions I’d pulled from that strange, almost magical book. My cock, impossibly enhanced to nearly a foot long by some trigger in those pages, stood as the focal point of her fixation. Orphelia, her friend, watched with wide, unblinking eyes, her face a stark white mask of makeup that hid any blush. The air was thick with the musky scent of Lilith’s arousal, mingling with the smoky warmth of the crackling fireplace. My heart thundered, a wild rhythm in my chest. Was this real? Could I really wield this power over her—over them?

I swallowed hard, my throat dry despite the heat. The thrill of control surged through me, intoxicating, but a flicker of fear gnawed at the edges of my mind. What if I’d gone too far? What if Lilith woke from this trance and saw me for what I was—a guy pushing boundaries he barely understood? No. I shoved the doubt down. This was my fantasy, my moment, and I was going to ride it to the end.

“Lilith,” I said, my voice low and deliberate, though my pulse raced like a runaway train, “I want you to masturbate. But just before you climax, you’ll realize you can’t come. The pleasure will build, hotter and more intense than anything you’ve ever felt, but release will stay just out of reach. Do you understand?”

“Yes,” she moaned, her voice raw, trembling with need. Her fingers moved faster, slick sounds filling the room, her pale thighs trembling as she worked herself into a frenzy. Her body arched slightly, modest breasts quivering, nipples hard and flushed against her alabaster skin. Sweat beaded on her brow, catching the orange glow of the fire, carving dark streaks through her smudged makeup.

Fuck, she’s gorgeous like this—so raw, so ****. My own arousal pulsed painfully, my cock straining as I watched her unravel. I wanted to push her further, to see how much she could take, but Orphelia’s reaction—her silent, shocked stare—made me wonder. Was she horrified? Aroused? I needed to know.

“Orphelia,” I turned to her, forcing my voice to stay steady despite the chaos in my head, “do you think I’ve proven my point? That hypnosis is real? Don’t answer yet. I want you to think about what it means to you—whether you believe it, whether you’d let yourself be hypnotized. Got it?”

Orphelia’s eyes, rimmed with dark liner, widened beneath her ghostly makeup. Her lips parted, but no words came. She nodded slowly, her long black hair swaying like a veil in the flickering light, her breath shallow and uneven. The fire’s heat pressed against us, making the room feel like a pressure cooker, amplifying every sound—Lilith’s soft whimpers, the creak of the floor, the pop of burning logs.

“Okay, you can go to your room now,” I said, my mind already racing ahead. “Or do you not live here?”

“N-no, my room’s right upstairs,” she stammered, her voice barely audible, trembling like a leaf caught in a storm.

“Good. Go to your room and get into bed. I’ll stay with Lilith a bit longer, and she’ll join you later.”

“Okay,” Orphelia whispered, rising unsteadily. Her ruffled skirt brushed against her legs, the soft rustle swallowed by Lilith’s ragged breaths. She moved toward the door, the wooden floor groaning faintly under her weight.

“Wait, Orphelia,” I called, my heart pounding with anticipation. This was it—the moment to weave them both deeper into this spell. My cock throbbed, urging me to push further, to test the limits. “Wish Lilith goodnight first.”

Orphelia froze mid-step, her body stiffening. She turned back, her movements hesitant, almost ****. “Goodnight, Lilith,” she murmured, her voice soft and tinged with unease, barely cutting through the thick air.

Lilith didn’t respond. Her eyes were locked on my cock, her fingers moving with **** urgency, her moans rising in pitch, each one a plea for release. Her pale body glistened with sweat, her slender frame trembling, her modest breasts heaving with each labored breath. Her face was a portrait of torment—eyebrows furrowed, lips bitten raw, eyes glistening with unshed tears of frustration. She was unraveling, and I was the one pulling the strings.

“Orphelia, give her a goodnight kiss,” I said, my voice dropping to a husky whisper. My blood roared in my ears, a mix of triumph and nervous energy. This could break everything—or bind them to me forever.

Orphelia stood rooted to the spot, her painted face a mask of shock, her eyes wide like a deer caught in headlights. The room seemed to pause, the only sounds Lilith’s **** whimpers and the fire’s relentless crackle. Orphelia’s hands clenched at her sides, her painted nails digging into her palms, her chest rising and falling with shallow breaths. Was she resisting? Or was she drawn in, just like me?

“Just on the forehead,” I added, softening my tone to coax her forward. “No big deal. Come here.”

Orphelia swallowed hard, her throat bobbing visibly. She took a single, faltering step toward Lilith, her skirt whispering against the floor. The delay was agonizing, each movement stretching the tension like a tightly wound spring. Another step, slower, her long black hair swaying, catching the firelight like liquid obsidian. The scent of her perfume—sharp and floral—cut through the heavy musk of Lilith’s arousal, creating a dizzying contrast. Lilith’s moans grew louder, more frantic, her body arching off the chair, her fingers digging into her own thighs as if to anchor herself against the unbearable need.

“Lilith, stop for a moment,” I commanded, my voice sharp to cut through her haze.

Lilith’s hand froze, but her body didn’t relax. She sat rigid, quivering like a taut wire, her breaths coming in short, ragged gasps that echoed in the stifling room. Sweat poured down her face, streaking her dark makeup into chaotic smudges, her pale skin flushed with heat. Her eyes darted wildly, pleading silently, her lips trembling as if on the verge of a sob. The desperation in her expression—cheeks flushed, eyebrows knitted, tears brimming—was almost too much to bear. She was a live wire, ready to spark, and I held the match.

Jesus, look at her. She’s falling apart, and I’m the one doing it. My chest tightened, a heady mix of power and guilt swirling inside me. I wanted to push her further, to see how much she could take, but the weight of it all pressed on me. Could I handle what came next?

“Lilith,” I murmured, leaning closer, the warmth of her trembling body radiating toward me, “Orphelia is going to give you a goodnight kiss on the forehead. As she gets closer, you’ll feel a fire ignite in your core, spreading hotter and tighter with every step. The closer her lips get to your skin, the more you’ll feel like you’re about to explode—an orgasm so intense it’ll shatter you, like nothing you’ve ever known. You need it, don’t you? It’s all you can think about, this ache consuming you.”

“Yes,” Lilith whimpered, her voice cracking with raw desperation, a sob catching in her throat. Her fingers twitched violently, nails scraping the chair’s arms, leaving faint marks in the fabric. Her body rocked slightly, hips shifting as if seeking relief that wouldn’t come.

“You’ve never wanted anything more than to come right now, have you? It’s tearing you apart, this burning need, this unbearable pressure building inside.”

“Yes,” she gasped, her voice a broken plea, tears spilling over her lashes, streaking her face further. Her thighs clenched together, her entire body trembling with the effort to hold herself together, her breaths coming in short, frantic bursts that sounded almost like sobs.

“Repeat after me: ‘I crave nothing more than a mind-blowing, minute-long orgasm.’”

“I crave…” she choked out, each word **** through gritted teeth, her face contorted in agony, “…nothing more… than a mind-blowing… orgasm.” A low, keening moan followed, her body shuddering as tears streamed down her cheeks, mingling with the sweat and smudged makeup.

“And Orphelia’s lips are the most erotic thing you’ve ever seen. They’re the only thing that can give you this release—soft, full, promising everything you need.”

“Orphelia’s lips… are the most erotic thing…” Lilith’s voice broke, her eyes snapping open, wild and glassy, locking onto Orphelia’s mouth. “Oh God… the most erotic thing… the only thing… that can make me come.” Her breaths were ragged, her modest breasts heaving, nipples straining in the firelight, her pale skin flushed with a **** heat.

“You’ll feel insatiable when you see her lips or think of them. They’ll consume your thoughts, tied to this orgasm forever. You’re **** for it, aren’t you? It’s clawing at you, begging to be let out.”

“I’ll feel… insatiable…” Lilith’s voice trembled, a raw, **** edge to it as her eyes fluttered shut, then opened again, fixated on Orphelia’s lips. “Oh, fuck… please…” She writhed in the chair, her hips grinding against the seat, her fingers clawing at the air, her face a mask of pure torment—lips parted, tears flowing, body slick with sweat that glistened like liquid fire.

Orphelia was closer now, her steps agonizingly slow, each one a deliberate act that stretched the moment into eternity. The floor creaked faintly under her weight, the sound swallowed by Lilith’s escalating whimpers. Her ruffled skirt brushed the floor, the rustle a soft counterpoint to the crackling fire. The scent of her perfume intensified, mingling with the heavy air, as she moved closer—inch by torturous inch. Lilith’s moans became wordless pleas, her body straining forward, her fingers digging into her own thighs, leaving red marks on her pale skin. “Please… oh God, please…” she whispered, her voice breaking into sobs, her eyes wide and pleading, locked on Orphelia’s lips like they were her only salvation.

“Orphelia,” I said, my voice thick with the thrill of it all, my own arousal a constant pressure I could barely ignore, “go to her slowly. Would it be okay to kiss her on the lips instead? Just a small kiss—it’ll push her over the edge. Nothing more.”

Orphelia nodded faintly, her eyes glazed, her breath shallow and uneven. She continued her approach, each step a heartbeat in the charged silence. The room pulsed with anticipation—the heat from the fire licking at my skin, Lilith’s **** cries growing louder, my own breath syncing with theirs in a ragged rhythm. Orphelia’s long hair swayed, catching the light, her pale face glowing like a specter in the flickering shadows.

She stopped just short of Lilith, her lips hovering inches away. The air between them seemed to crackle, thick with the scent of sweat, perfume, and raw desire. Lilith’s body arched toward her, a low, guttural moan escaping her throat, her eyes wide and unblinking, tears streaming down her face as she teetered on the edge of collapse. Her hands gripped the chair so tightly her knuckles turned white, her entire being radiating unbearable need.

Orphelia leaned down, her movements achingly slow, her painted face closing the distance. Her breath ghosted across Lilith’s lips, and Lilith let out a broken sob, her body trembling violently, hips bucking as if drawn to the promise of release. The moment stretched, taut and electric, the world narrowing to the space between their lips.

Finally, Orphelia’s lips brushed Lilith’s—soft, closed, lingering just a heartbeat longer than necessary. The contact was like a spark to dry tinder.

Lilith’s body convulsed instantly, her hips bucking wildly as a deep, primal groan tore from her throat—a raw, guttural sound that seemed to come from the depths of her soul, shaking the room. Her eyes squeezed shut, her face twisted in exquisite agony, tears mingling with sweat as the orgasm crashed over her like a tidal wave. Orphelia grabbed her hand, their fingers intertwining, Orphelia’s own trembling anchoring Lilith through the storm.

“Ohhh, fuck!” Lilith screamed, her voice shattering the silence, raw and unrestrained. Her body spasmed uncontrollably, a powerful gush of liquid hitting the floor with a sharp, wet slap that echoed in the room. Aftershocks rippled through her—limbs jerking, breaths hitching in sobs—as she rode the waves of release, her desperation finally fracturing into ecstasy.

“Oh fuck, oh God, oh God…” Lilith panted, her voice hoarse and spent, collapsing forward into Orphelia’s arms, her pale body limp and quivering, slick with sweat and tears.

“That was the most incredible thing you’ve ever experienced, wasn’t it, Lilith?” I said, my heart still racing, a rush of triumph flooding me. I’d pushed her beyond the edge, and the power was intoxicating.

“Yes… the most incredible thing…” she murmured, her voice weak but fervent, her eyes fluttering open, still hazy with afterglow.

“That orgasm was completely addictive, and you’d do anything to feel it again.”

“It was addictive… I’d do anything…” Her gaze shifted to Orphelia’s lips, a lingering hunger in her eyes, her breaths still shaky and uneven.

“Orphelia, would you do her the favor?” I asked, my mind already spinning with possibilities. I could feel the weight of the moment, the line I was crossing, but I couldn’t stop now.

“What?” Orphelia’s voice was breathy, startled, her eyes flicking to me, then back to Lilith’s ruined face—makeup streaked into a chaotic mess, eyes red from crying, lips trembling with exhaustion.

“Orphelia, from now on, you have the power to give Lilith that orgasm by kissing her on the lips. But each time, the kiss needs to be just a little longer or more intense to trigger the same effect. You don’t have to, of course.”

Orphelia hesitated, her eyes locked on Lilith’s wrecked appearance. The room still hummed with residual energy, the fire’s heat almost suffocating now. Slowly, she leaned down and kissed Lilith again, this time letting their lips linger a fraction longer.

Lilith broke away from the kiss as another tremor shook her body. This time, an even larger gush of liquid followed—she must have lost all control of her bladder. “Oh God, I’m sorry,” she gasped, her voice laced with exhausted embarrassment.

“No, Lilith, it’s okay,” Orphelia said softly, her voice gentle and reassuring. “I hope you had an amazing experience.”

I stood up, ignoring Lilith’s lingering moans as her orgasm tapered off. My erection was not faded away it was a constant reminder of the surreal intensity of the night. “Orphelia, show me the bathroom. I’ll take care of Lilith. I want you to go to bed now and think about what I said earlier.”

Orphelia nodded and headed upstairs. I heard a door open and close softly behind her. I can't say behind all that white makeup what she was thinking about this.

I stood there, heart pounding, staring at Lilith’s trembling form. I still had a raging hard-on. What a fucking surreal situation.

What's next?

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)