Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 21 by buape

What's next?

Sorority games

The silence in Lily’s apartment after the video uploaded was a physical thing, a thick haze that seemed to mute even the distant city sounds. John stood by the bed, wearing the borrowed sweatpants, feeling scraped raw inside and out. The phantom sensations of the trailer—the brutal thrusts, the **** fullness—played on a loop behind his eyes.

Lily watched the screen for a few minutes, refreshing the page. The view count ticked upward: twelve, then forty, then one hundred and three. Comments began to pop up, a scrolling feed of vulgar praise. Damn, she’s taking it like a champ. Need a turn on that. More of this whore.

She closed the laptop with a soft click.

“We’re not done,” she said, her voice cutting through the haze. She turned to him, her expression unreadable. “You violated my privacy. You watched me. Now you get to be the show. But a one-act play is boring.” A sly, dangerous smile touched her lips. “My sisters are having a little… initiation party tonight. And you’re the main event.”

John’s stomach, already hollow, turned to ice. “Sisters?”

“Sorority sisters,” Lily clarified, as if speaking to a child. “Theta Gamma Phi. They’ve seen the video from the site. They think it’s hot. They want to play.” She walked to her dresser, pulled out a long strip of black silk. “Come here.”

He approached, every instinct screaming to run, but his feet carried him forward. The memory of the camera, of the online post, was a chain. She positioned him in front of her and wrapped the silk tightly around his head, covering his eyes. The world vanished into oppressive, scratchy darkness.

“No peeking,” she whispered, her breath warm on his ear. “Makes it more fun for everyone.”

She took his hand, her grip firm, and led him. Out of the apartment, into the elevator, through the lobby. He stumbled in his socked feet, disoriented. She’d made him leave the shoes behind. Cool night air hit his face, then the sound of her car door opening. She pushed him into the passenger seat.

The drive was short. He heard the squeal of other, younger voices, laughter, the thump of bass from a passing car. They stopped. She guided him out, across what felt like gravel, then onto smooth concrete. A door opened, and the air changed—it became damp, close, smelling of mildew, cheap perfume, and the distinct, sweet tang of spilled ****.

They were descending stairs. Each step down was a descent into a more profound auditory chaos. Music pulsed—a deep, rhythmic electronic beat. Female voices chattered, laughed, called out to Lily.

“You brought him!”

“Is that the little cocksucker from the video?”

“He’s taller than I thought.”

Hands touched him as they passed—pinching his arm, patting his ass, stroking his shorn head. He flinched with each contact.

“Easy, puppy,” one voice cooed, mock-soothing.

Lily stopped him. The music was turned down slightly. He could sense bodies circling him in the dim, basement air.

“Okay, ladies. Here’s the game.” Lily’s voice was loud, cheerful, a party hostess. “Our guest here has a little fetish for me. He likes to watch. So he thinks he knows me… intimately. We’re going to test that.”

A ripple of excited giggles.

“He’s blindfolded. You’ve all got your straps on, nice and wet. He’s going to taste each and every one of you. He can feel your tits, too. But no other clues.” Something cold and metallic was clipped to his earlobe. A wire trailed down his neck. “This is a little trainer. Every time he guesses wrong… he gets a zap. We go until he gets it right. Or until he’s a drooling mess on the floor. You all got your numbers?”

A chorus of affirmative murmurs.

“Who’s first? Number one?”

A new presence stepped close to him. He could smell a cloud of vanilla body spray and, underneath, the musk of arousal. Hands—different from Lily’s, with long nails—guided his head down. “Open up, sweetie,” a breathy, unfamiliar voice commanded.

He opened his mouth. The silicone head of a strap-on pressed against his lips. It was already slick, coated in a flavor that was tangy and unfamiliar. He took it in, the cool, unyielding material gliding over his tongue. The woman pushed forward, fucking his mouth with shallow, testing thrusts. Her free hand grabbed his wrist and placed it on her breast. It was large, soft, spilling out of a lace bra.

“Guess,” Lily’s voice came from nearby.

“Not… not you,” John stammered around the intruding toy.

A sharp, violent jolt of electricity screamed through the clip on his ear. His whole body convulsed, a pained cry tearing from his throat. The women laughed.

“Wrong! Number two!”

The first woman withdrew with a wet pop. Another immediately took her place. This one tasted different—sharper, more acidic. Her breast was small, pert. He groped blindly, desperately trying to find something, anything familiar.

Lily?”

Another zap, fiercer than the first. His knees buckled. Strong hands kept him upright.

“So eager! Wrong again. Three!”

It became a hellish cycle. Each new silicone cock carried the unique, intimate flavor of a different woman. Some were bland, some musky, some tasted of soap or sex or something sour he couldn’t name. The breasts he squeezed came in all shapes and sizes—big, small, firm, soft, adorned with lace or cotton or nothing at all. The electric shocks followed each wrong guess, a punitive scorch that erased thought, leaving only animal panic.

By the eighth woman, he was shaking uncontrollably, saliva dripping down his chin, his jaw sore. The shocks were accumulating, turning his nerves into live wires. The ninth woman was particularly rough, grabbing the back of his head and driving her strap deep into his throat until he gagged, his nose pressed against the plastic harness.

“Guess, fucktoy.”

He couldn’t speak. He just shook his head, a sob hitching in his chest.

ZAP. The current felt like it lit up his spine. He cried out, a broken sound.

“Ten!”

This one was slower. She rubbed the slick tip over his lips, his cheeks, painting him with her juices before sliding it into his mouth. She let him suckle for a moment, her hands gently cradling his head. For a second, it felt almost tender. Then he felt her breast. It was medium-sized, with a familiar, specific weight and curve in his palm. The taste in his mouth… it was complex. Not just arousal, but the faint, ghostly hint of Lily’s perfume, the unique scent of her skin he’d breathed in for years from afar, now translated into a salty, intimate tang on a plastic toy.

His heart hammered against his ribs. Hope, treacherous and ****, bloomed.

Lily?” he whispered, the name a prayer.

The shock that ripped through him was catastrophic. It wasn't just his ear; it felt like his teeth vibrated, his vision flashed white behind the blindfold. He screamed, a raw, tearing sound, and collapsed to the cold linoleum. The women roared with laughter, a sound of pure, unadulterated delight.

“Oh my god, he really thought it was you, Lo!”

“That was pathetic!”

Through a haze of pain, he heard Lily’s voice, cool and amused. “Silly boy. I’m number twelve. The grand finale. Get him up.”

Hands hauled him upright. He was limp, barely conscious, his body a map of tremors. They positioned him. The final presence approached. He could smell her now—her real scent, cutting through the basement dank. Jasmine and steel.

Her strap-on pressed against his lips. It was warm, as if heated by her body. The taste was an explosion of memory—the exact, specific flavor he’d conjured and been wrong about moments before, but now undeniably, irrevocably her. It was Lily, condensed into this awful, intimate act. He opened his mouth, defeated.

She didn’t just feed it to him. She gripped his hair and fucked his face with a steady, possessive rhythm, the silicone hitting the back of his throat with each deep push.

“Who am I, John?” she growled, her voice low, for him alone.

Lily,” he choked out around the violation.

“Good boy.”

No shock. Instead, she pulled him off the toy and spun him around, bending him over the arm of the worn couch. The coarse fabric scratched his stomach. He heard the rustle of her skirt, the shift of the harness.

“This is what you wanted, right?” she hissed. Her hand came down hard on his ass, a stinging slap. “To be part of my world?”

She didn’t wait for an answer. She spit onto her hand, slicked the toy, and drove it into him in one brutal, reaming thrust.

He shouted, the invasion a blazing shock after the focused torment of his mouth. His body, already savaged from the construction site, screamed in protest. She set a punishing pace, each plunge deep and deliberate, using the strap-on to claim the last untouched part of his dignity. The plastic base of the harness slapped against his skin with a loud, rhythmic crack.

“You’re mine now,” she grunted, her breath coming fast as she slapped him a final time and pulled out. “Every hole. Every fucking video."

The words were still vibrating in the air when a hand, not Lily’s, snaked around his hip. He flinched, expecting another shock, another violation. Fingers, slick with something cool and greasy, slipped a vibrating plug inside him. A sharp twist, a click, and a low, insistent buzz erupted inside his bowels, making his legs quiver.

“Gotta warm up the main event,” a sister giggled, her voice too close.

“My turn on his mouth,” another voice cut through the haze, petulant and eager.

“Yeah, don’t hog the good parts.”

Before he could slump, hands grabbed his shoulders, spinning him roughly onto his back across the couch arm. His head dangled over the edge. A different silhouette blotted out the ceiling lights.

He saw the dark shape of a harness, a glint of metal on the plastic cock, before it pushed against his lips. This one was bigger. It didn’t ask. It **** its way in, stretching his sore mouth wide, hitting his palate. He gagged violently.

“Swallow it, bitch,” the sister above him commanded, grinding the toy against his tongue. He could taste cheap vodka and her distinct, pungent arousal. Her thumbs hooked into the corners of his mouth, stretching him wider. “You like watching, right? Now you get a really close-up view.”

On the other side of the couch, he felt more hands. They pulled his thighs apart, exposing him where Lily’s strap had just been. A cold drizzle of lube hit his ravaged hole. Then pressure, different from the silicone—warmer, softer. A tongue. It lapped at him, rough and curious, then pushed inside, fucking him with wet, sloppy strokes.

“Tastes like construction worker,” a muffled voice commented, followed by laughter.

The sister at his mouth picked up her pace, her plastic cock sliding in and out with a wet, rhythmic slurping sound. Her hips snapped forward with a brutality that rattled his teeth. The one at his ass replaced her tongue with two fingers, scissoring him open, the stretch burning. The vibrating plug continued its relentless hum, a background torment.

“Switch!”

Bodies rotated around him with practiced, party-game efficiency. The cock in his mouth was replaced by another, this one ribbed. The fingers in his ass were swapped for a thumb, probing deeper, twisting. A new mouth descended on his neck, biting a sharp, possessive mark into his skin. He was a puppet of feverish hands and demanding flesh.

He lost count. Sensation blurred into a continuous stream of invasive textures and tastes. A particularly aggressive sister with a peppermint taste on her toy grabbed his hand and **** his fingers into her own soaked cunt, making him finger her while she fucked his face. “Feel that? That’s what you missed out on, you creepy little bitch,” she panted, riding his hand.

Another knelt over his face, lowering herself not onto the toy, but onto his mouth itself, grinding her pussy directly against his lips and nose, smothering him in her musk. “Lick it clean,” she demanded, and he did, his tongue moving on pure, debased instinct. The buzz in his ass climbed to a higher setting, making his stomach muscles cramp.

Lily watched from a chair, one leg crossed over the other, sipping from a red cup. Her expression was one of detached appraisal, like a director reviewing a scene. She occasionally lifted her phone, the screen glowing in the dark, capturing a particularly lurid angle.

A sister with a heavy, swaying chest pressed his face into her cleavage, smothering him in soft, perfumed flesh while another worked a smaller, tapered strap into his ass, the stretch a new, sharp agony. “Think he’s gonna come from just this?” someone asked, incredulous.

“Without anyone touching his little dick? That’d be pathetic.”

“Let’s find out.”

The pace became frenzied, coordinated. One fucked his mouth, another his ass, a third whispered filthy encouragement in his ear, her hands pinching his nipples viciously. The vibrations, the friction, the overwhelming, **** fullness short-circuited his nervous system. A tight, shameful heat pooled low in his abdomen, entirely separate from his will.

His back arched, a strangled sound tearing from his throat around the silicone filling it. He spilled into the pink dress Lily had **** him back into hours ago, a weak, pulsing release that brought no relief, only a devastating wave of humiliation. His body jerked through the pathetic climax under their relentless use.

A collective, mocking “awww” rose from the circle. The sister at his mouth pulled out, wiping his spit and her juices on his cheek. “Disgusting.”

Everything stopped. The vibrations clicked off. The hands withdrew. He lay wrecked on the couch, a used object, trembling through the aftershocks. The music lowered again. Footsteps approached.

Lily’s familiar hand removed the blindfold. The sudden, unfiltered basement light was a physical ****. He blinked up at the ring of young women, their faces flushed with excitement and cruelty, their strap-ons glistening with his spit. Lily’s face hovered above his, a smile playing on her lips. She held her phone steadily, recording his shattered expression.

“See?” she said softly, for the microphone. “Everyone wanted a piece of the action.” She panned the phone around the room, capturing the grinning sisters, their harnesses, the scene. “Theta Gamma Phi’s little bitch. Episode two.” She stopped the recording.

She leaned down, her voice a whisper only he could hear. “The trailer video got ten thousand views in six hours.” Her eyes were dark and limitless. “This one will break the internet. And you’ll be back for episode three. Because you’re mine now. Aren’t you?”

He tried to form a word, any word. All that came out was a shattered exhale. It was answer enough.

What's next?

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)