Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 3 by ManRayMansker ManRayMansker

What did you get presented with?

Show off?

You always believed you were boringly average in every way. At thirty-four, you held a forgettable desk job processing insurance claims, drove a gray sedan indistinguishable from a thousand others in the parking lot, and spent evenings microwaving the same frozen dinners while half-watching sports highlights. Your face was neither handsome nor memorable—brown eyes, brown hair, average height, average weight. You told yourself this made life simple. The truth you never voiced, not even in the dark, was that your penis was less than average in every measurable way: barely four inches hard, narrow in girth, and your balls small, tight, and high-riding like an afterthought. You had confirmed it with a ruler and a quiet shame that kept you single and safely alone.One Tuesday night, scrolling X out of pure habit, you paused on a single post. It showed a pair of jeans with an unmistakable outline and a cheeky caption about “pants that don’t lie.” The account was @xxxdickpants

Without thinking, you tapped the heart. The algorithm noticed.

By morning your feed had fractured. @smdickworld appeared first—memes, confessions, and gentle roasts about guys exactly like you. You lingered on a thread titled “Small Balls, Big Feelings.” Reading it felt like someone had opened a locked drawer in your brain. The effect was immediate and strange: a hot flush of recognition mixed with unexpected arousal. For the first time you felt seen, yet the teasing tone also made your stomach tighten in delicious humiliation. You liked three posts before you could stop yourself.Next the feed served @DrKatie_DGQ

The profile belonged to a no-nonsense urologist who mixed medical diagrams with dry humor. A pinned video explained “below-average anatomy and why it still works.” You watched twice. Dr. Katie spoke directly to the camera as if she knew your ruler was hidden in the nightstand. The effect was clinical relief—you bookmarked the video, googled her cited studies, and for an hour felt less like a freak and more like a patient with options. You even replied to one post with a burner account: “This actually helped.”

Chaos accelerated. @Lilywithbuldge slid into view next. The account posted confident, teasing photos of a woman whose tight outfits revealed an unmistakable bulge of her own. The contrast hit you like a slap. Where you were small and hidden, she was proud and prominent. You stared, pulse racing, imagining yourself on your knees, smaller still beside her. The effect was pure fantasy whiplash—your boring vanilla mind suddenly flooded with submissive scenarios you had never dared name. You followed without hesitation.

Finally @hotcelebritycrotches arrived, a relentless parade of zoomed-in paparazzi shots: actors, athletes, influencers, all captured mid-stride with outlines that dwarfed your own. You found yourself comparing, measuring, flinching. The effect was raw envy laced with voyeuristic hunger. You spent an entire lunch break studying a soccer player’s sweatpants, then hated yourself for it, then went back for more.Each account pulled a different lever inside you.

@xxxdickpants made you laugh at your own pants in the mirror, turning shame into silly selfie attempts you immediately deleted.

@smdickworld kept you up past midnight reading community threads that normalized your size while teasing it mercilessly, leaving you hard and conflicted.

@DrKatie_DGQ armed you with facts and gentle hope, prompting secret searches for exercises and acceptance podcasts.

@Lilywithbuldge unlocked fantasies that made your smallness feel erotic instead of embarrassing.

@hotcelebritycrotches fed the cruel comparisons that somehow made every ordinary day feel secretly charged.Your once orderly feed was now a storm. Work emails went unanswered while you refreshed between meetings. Friends texted asking why you seemed distracted; you lied about “new hobbies.” Nights blurred into a cycle: chuckle at @xxxdickpants, blush at @smdickworld, learn from @DrKatie_DGQ, fantasize with @Lilywithbuldge, then ache with envy at @hotcelebritycrotches. The algorithm had done its job too well. You were no longer boringly average—you were quietly obsessed, your secret inadequacy now the center of a digital universe you had accidentally invited in.You tried clearing your cache, muting keywords, even taking a day off the app. Nothing worked. The five profiles had colonized your timeline and, worse, your thoughts. You caught yourself adjusting your jeans at the grocery store the way @xxxdickpants joked about. You smiled at a small-bulge meme from @smdickworld while waiting in line. You wondered what Dr. Katie would prescribe if she knew the truth.You set the phone down one quiet evening, screen still glowing with fresh notifications from all five accounts..

Whose profile will you spend time on now?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)