Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 11 by styxmaster styxmaster

What's next?

Sarah stops by for another go

You haven’t even been in bed for 10 minutes when you hear the door open. The light footsteps tell you that it’s Sarah, you pretend to be asleep as she walks up to your bed.

“I know you’re awake Doug, stop pretending to sleep. I want to do it more.” You ignore her command and close your eyes tighter.

Sarah huffs as she sits on the bed next to you. “Look Doug, I was maybe a bit too rough with you in the shower. By the time you tried to stop I was too horny to think.” She remains silent for a moment then continues. “Look, just tell me what you want, if you want me to stop I’ll stop, just say something!”

“Why don’t you just take what you want?” You respond, finally opening your eyes to look at Sarah. She flinches back, guilt covering her face.

Sarah stands up and walks to the door, her voice a whisper as she says “That’s not how I wanted to treat you”.

You realize she’s not getting the hint and you blush, embarrassed at what you’re about to say. “Maybe that’s how I WANT you to treat me.”

Sarah spins around, you bury your face deeper into your pillow to hide your growing shame. You swear you can hear her erection spring to life. With a squeal she jumps onto your bed and flings off the covers.

She pulls your pajama bottoms down to your ankles and then leans forward, whispering into your ear “In that case I won’t stop halfway this time.”

You want to ask her what she means by that, but instead you just raise your butt in the air, wiggling it again, this time to entice her instead of block her.

Grabbing your hips again she lines up and immediately plunges into you. Hilting right off the bat. “mmm… It feels even better than the first time!” She exclaims, a sentiment you share, a moan issuing from your mouth, damped by the pillow you’re buried in.

Sarah starts off slow, instead of thrusting she rolls her hips back and forth, practically massaging your prostate as she does. Your orgasm builds slowly as she does this precum leaking from both your cocks, hers filling your anus, and yours soaking your sheets. You cry out as you cum, which was apparently the signal for Sarah to begin thrusting. Your cock doesn’t have any time to rest as the **** of her giant cockhead rubbing against and crushing your prostate brings you to full mast once again.

You realize that Sarah was still going easy on you in the shower, her thrusts knock you off your knees and rock the bed. “Come on Doug” she says as she pulls you back up and slaps your ass. “I can’t get a good angle like that.”

You lift up and grab the headboard to stabilize yourself. You try to hold steady but each thrust rocks you forward and back and makes your legs feel like jelly. The second time your legs give out Sarah sighs, she drags you backwards until your legs are lying off the side of the bed. Your face is now resting in the small puddle of your own cum as Sarah picks up the pace, thrusting hard and deeper than before.

Sarah moans as the now familiar feeling of her cum flooding your guts overwhelms you. Sarah doesn’t stop fucking you however. Not a minute later she cums again, pushing her last load deeper inside you, your insides begin to feel a little tight. “Sarah… I think I’m too full now.”

“Nonsense” she grunts, not even stopping to respond, “You wanted me to take charge and I’m doing it, I’m sure you can take it all!”. Even as she says this you feel her cum again, you burp as she does, you’re alarmed as a salty taste fills your mouth. Looking down in alarm you see that your stomach is bulging outwards, your sister is literally filling you with cum!

You push off the bed and try to convince her to stop again, but instead you cough, cum now covering your throat. Sarah pushes you back onto the bed, following you down to prevent her cock (And cum) from slipping out). “No Doug, I said you have to take it all.” With this she grunts and another load enters you.

You feel cum climbing up your throat now, you try to hold it in but it becomes too much as cum starts shooting out of your nose. Panicking you open your mouth and begin puking cum, allowing you just enough time to catch your breath before yet another load fills you. You have a brief moment to wonder how your smaller sister is able to produce enough cum to completely fill you and keep going before the you begin to cough up more cum.

When Sarah finally finishes your entire bed is drenched. She pulls out and laughs as a geyser of cum rockets out of you, allowing you to deflate slightly. “That was great Doug” She says, once again giving you a pat on the ass, she giggles “though maybe next time we should do this in the shower, less of a mess… hmm… Or we could do it outside.” She ponders this as she walks out of the room, her work done.

You groan and then promptly pass out, tonight has been glorious

The next day you wake up, the sheets pulling off the bed as you get up, dried cum keeping them stuck to your body. As it's the weekend you take your time and rinse off, throwing your sheets in the wash and take your mattress outside to air out. When you walk back in you find that

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)