Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 13 by fantaghiro fantaghiro

Is Tom aroused by seeing her with someone else, so he encourages it with another wish? Does his jealousy cause him to make a different kind of wish?

Sarah is conflicted - but not too much

After a couple hours of grinding her body against different sexy guys on the dance floor, Sarah was so horny she didn't think she could take it anymore. As she pushed her breasts into the chest of her latest dance partner, she leaned in to whisper in his ear "Fuck me! Now!"

The dark haired man's eyes widened. He was attractive enough but seemed like he wasn't used to places like this. He had admitted to her that he'd just turned 21 two days ago and finally got the guts to try out this club. She grabbed his hand and pulled him off the dance floor, down a dark hall to the bathrooms. He was clearly a bit nervous but his expression was that of someone who had just won the lottery.

Sarah hungrily kissed the guy (she couldn't remember his name) and pushed open the bathroom door with her hips. Ignoring another woman by the sinks, she led him into one of the stalls and kicked the door shut. Within seconds she had pulled his pants down and wrapped her legs around him. He held her against the stall, fucking her, murmuring "Oh my God, you're freaking amazing...so beautiful..."

She gasped, drinking in the flattery and enjoying each sensation. Briefly a pang of guilt shot through her. How could she do this to Tom? In their 20 years of marriage she had never considered cheating on him. She loved him more than anything!

But that was quicly pushed aside by other thoughts. "I'm young, beautiful, and sexy. Why shouldn't I fuck who I want, when I want? Why am I even with that old geezer? He's kind of a creep anyway, wanting someone like me ... young enough to be his daughter. And what's with him wanting to be called 'daddy'?," she asked herself. "Oh...ohhh...." she gasped as she felt an orgasm building.

Other thoughts crept in. "Oh yeah, he takes care of me. Even if he's a creeper, he does pay for all my stuff. And it's so much fun to tease him!" With that, she held out her phone and awkwardly took a video of herself. She smiled straight at the camera and made a kissy face. "Hope you like this, 'daddy'!" she said, then threw her head back and cried out as she climaxed. She barely managed to hit send on the video before dropping her phone to the floor.

She fell onto the guy for a minute, trying to hold him inside her. She heard someone outside the stall muttering "Damn, some people...what a ho..."

That made her smile at first. Then she looked at the man holding her and down at herself. "What did I just do?!" she thought. She pushed herself away from him and pulled her short dress back down, then picked her phone back up.

"That was the most incredible thing that's ever happened to me," the man stammered with an expression of awe on his face. "Can I see you again?"

Sarah stumbled out of the stall. "Uh, sorry, no....." she said, hurrying from the bathroom and straight out of the club. She had just seduced a guy in a club and had sex in a bathroom. And sent a video of it to Tom! What had she been thinking!?! The guilt and shock of her actions were almost equally balanced by a deep satisfaction - both by the sex itself and by her behavior toward Tom.

Sarah’s mind was a riot as she stumbled into the Uber, the city lights streaking past in blurred neon ribbons, music and conversation from the club still pulsing behind her eyelids. Her body was warm, tingling, buzzing with aftershocks, the sweet ache of orgasm still thrumming between her legs. She pressed her phone to her chest, half-expecting it to vibrate with a reply from Tom—but part of her didn’t care. Not really. The thrill had been hers. The control had been hers. The exhibition, the tease, the raw delicious power—it was all hers.

And yet… she remembered him. Tom. Daddy. The old perv who had handed her a key to this new existence with the flick of a magical coin, who had made her young, reckless, and insatiable. Her fingers flexed around the phone as a mischievous thought struck: He’s watching. He has to see. That’s what makes it even better.

Her mind replayed the bathroom stall, every gasp, every moan, every thrust. The dark-haired guy, nervous and inexperienced, had been hers to guide, hers to dominate—or at least to let feel like he was. She had teased, seduced, exposed herself for her own pleasure, yes, but also for Tom, feeding the voyeuristic hunger he couldn’t resist. Her lips curved into a smirk: Daddy’s going to lose it when he sees this. Absolutely lose it.

The guilt tried to edge in, whispering reminders of decades of marriage, of the love she felt—of the old Sarah who would never, ever consider betraying him. But the new Sarah, sharpened and emboldened by the wishes, simply brushed it aside, a playful, knowing smirk spreading across her flushed face. I’m young, beautiful, and completely irresistible. Why shouldn’t I have all the fun I want? And if I’m honest… it’s Daddy who made this possible.

Her thoughts flicked between selves, teasing the edge of each reality. The ‘wife of twenty years’ part of her felt like a dream she’d watched on a screen: distant, almost nostalgic, but utterly irrelevant in the heat of her current body and mind. Now, she was the party girl—the young, sexy, liberated Sarah—living the ultimate thrill. And yet… she liked having Tom dangling just out of reach, a willing sugar daddy paying, indulging, and silently aching at the knowledge that she was completely untouchable tonight.

The Uber hummed smoothly through the night streets, but Sarah’s mind was far ahead, racing through future possibilities. Who else could she tease? How far could she push this power dynamic? She could feel her libido still simmering, hunger unspent, a lust sharpened to a blade. And the phone—oh, the phone—was the perfect instrument. Every snap, every video, every smirk sent to Tom was a thrill of dominance and seduction rolled into one. She could make him ache, flinch, squirm, and still keep control.

Her mind finally settled, a smug, victorious curve of her lips: I’m untouchable. I’m free. I’m Daddy’s ultimate plaything when I want to be… and completely my own queen when I don’t. A part of her—tiny, flickering—acknowledged the magical coin, the latent threat it still held. But she smiled wider at that, reveling in the delicious irony. She had the tools now: her youth, her body, her daring mind, and the perfect knowledge of how to bend Tom to her will without ever giving up her power.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)