More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 18 by fantaghiro fantaghiro

What is Natalie's next wish?

Sarah as Natalie's mother

She said "I wish that my sister Sarah was like she was before, Tom's 39 year old wife, and that instead of her twin I'm now her daughter but otherwise unchanged from how I am now. I wish that Sarah only remembered me as her daughter but was completely turned on by sharing Tom with me."

Tom felt a rush of changes but didn't see anything different. Natalie continued to grind herself against against him, trying to **** him fully into her. He was about to relent and finally fully penetrate when his phone rang. He saw it was Sarah!.

He stopped moving with the tip of his penis barely in Natalie. She moaned and tried rubbing it along the edge of her pussy. "Shh.." he said, before picking up the phone in one hand. "Sarah?" he answered.

"Did you pick up Natalie?" he heard her ask. "What's taking so long? Did she convince you to fuck in the parking lot again?" She sounded put out. "I told her before, I don't mind you two playing your games, but can't you do it at home so I can join in, or at least watch?"

Tom's eyes widened in amazement. "Wow!" he mouthed at Natalie. She stopped her wriggling for a moment to whisper "See, I said you would love it!"

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)