Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 38 by Zingiber Zingiber

Does Samuel hold out? How about Gary's turn, or Bernie and Peggy?

Samuel lets Gary get off first, and a long afternoon begins.

"What an ass," Samuel said. "Man."

Samuel knelt behind Gary on Peggy and Samuel's big bed, slowly thrusting his cock in and out of Gary's ass. His broad brown hands held tight to Gary's pink buttocks.

"Better than Hank's?" Peggy asked.

"Oh, Pegs," Samuel said. "It's rude to compare a father and son. Pay my wife no mind, Gary."

Peggy laughed out loud. "You weren't shy about comparing Jim and Peter!" she said. "Sorry Gary."

Samuel worked up to a slow, easy rhythm, letting out a little growl of satisfaction now and again. "Yeah. Ass."

Bernie sat close to Gary's head, watching his expression. It had started out tense, but with Samuel's unhurried fuck, she saw Gary's face relax. Gary's penis had softened after Samuel had penetrated him, swinging with Samuel's slow thrusts, but Bernie watched it twitch, swell, and harden.

Peggy murmured in Bernie's ear. "Sam loves new bottoms," she said. "He really likes to make it good. He was the first up my ass. Stars and fireworks and everything."

"Hey Gary, how's it feeling?" Samuel asked.

"Good. Really good. Kinda warm though, maybe a little sore," Gary said.

"All right, we better wrap it up," Samuel said. "Bernie, Pegs, want to give this fine man a happy ending?"

Peggy smiled at Bernie. Bernie laughed, then nodded.

"Sure," Bernie said.

Two stroking hands brought Gary to the whimpering edge of climax. Gary's cock twitched and his ass squeezed down on Samuel's cock.

"Oh yeah," Samuel said. "Oh yeah, I love that feeling. Sweet ass. Squeeze on my dick." He chuckled. "Girls? Finish him!"

Peggy stroked her hand quickly over the crown of Gary's cock. Gary squeezed his eyes closed, thrust back at Samuel's cock, and roared out his orgasm, shooting his load through Peggy's fist. Samuel laughed happily as Gary's ass squeezed down on his cock with each shot. "Yeah, get it, man, get it!" he said.

Samuel let Gary settle down for a minute. "Easin' on out now, Gary," he said, withdrawing. "Back in a sec." Samuel stepped into the bathroom to dispose of his condom and get a quick wash.

Peggy got the wet wipes and a towel and cleaned up Gary, back and front.

"Hey Bernie," Peggy said. "Want to get me started? If I know my husband, he's gonna want my ass next."

"You know it, precious!" Samuel called from the bathroom.

"Ladies first!" Peggy said.

Peggy and Bernie got Gary settled down in a towel-covered chair. Peggy arranged herself on the bed where Gary had been. Bernie crouched behind her, kissing Peggy's broad pink buttocks before spreading them to indulge the hunger that had gone unsatisfied so long, from when she'd lost Habiba up till the party a few weeks ago.

"Oh yeah," Peggy said. "I've been waiting for this. Oh you...ah, yes. So good. Eat my ass. Baby, yeah."

Samuel stepped close, holding a camera-phone. "Can I?" he asked.

"Mm, mm-hm," Bernie said, nodding. She spread Peggy's butt wider so Samuel could get a picture to share with Gary and Bernie.

Samuel framed a picture of Bernie in profile, curly dark hair falling over her forehead, a look of hunger and joy in her face, her wet tongue on Peggy's anus. "Got it," Samuel said. "As you were, ladies, and don't dawdle."

Peggy laughed. "You know you like it when I keep you waiting," she said. "Don't h--uh! Yeah." Peggy squeezed her eyes shut, feeling Bernie's tongue go back to work. "Ooh. Yeah, that. There. Yes."

Bernie reached a hand back, masturbating as she licked Peggy's ass. Peggy sighed and grunted in pleasure, rocking her ass up and down on Bernie's tongue. The excitement of the act, of hearing and feeling Peggy's pleasure, were too much for Bernie, and she moaned into Peggy's ass, reaching her climax in a sudden spasm of joy.

Though Samuel was eager to get up Peggy's ass, he called Gary up. "Your girl needs you."

Gary and Peggy cuddled Bernie as she rolled through the aftershocks of her climax. Gary's cock twitched and started rising again as he held Bernie close and smelled Peggy's ass on her lips.

It was the beginning of a long afternoon, going from bed to shower to chair. Samuel and Peggy showed off a slow, sensual buttfuck for Gary and Bernie, getting off together, and things went on from there. Gary had a turn on top with Samuel, taking Peggy's husband from the front so he could watch Samuel stroke his long brown cock and shoot a load while Gary fucked his ass. Cunts were eaten and stroked and fucked. Bernie gave everyone back rubs. A couple of threesome positions were tried.

Finally Gary and Bernie slumped on the couch together across from Peggy, damp from the shower and wearing old bathrobes. A naked Samuel was cooking dinner, cheerfully joking at the fucked-out three in the living room.

"Let's do this again," Peggy said as Gary and Bernie were leaving.

"Yes," Bernie said, leaning forward to kiss Peggy on the doorstep.

"You bring that big dick of yours back, Gary," Samuel said. "You didn't play all eight holes."

How do things go in Gary and Bernie's new world?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)