Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 6 by The Smutsketeer The Smutsketeer

Who do you pick?

Rose

"I want Rose" you told your lover, kissing her hard on the lips as right after. "I want to see if we can corrupt that pretty little thing"

"I'm sure we can" Carmen replied. "Even her."She bit her lip when you went balls deep inside of her ass for a few seconds then grinned. "I've seen her naked, you know. She looks so good."

"Tell me about her" you said, picking up the pace of your thrusts. You were getting worked up, thinking about Rose who was definitely a close second to Carmen.

"She is so sexy" Carmen said, smiling. "She has the tightest little ass. It's so fucking cute and gropable." As she spoke she put her arms around you, pulling you close. "Sometimes I think back to when we had our threesome with Alison and I start looking at other women like you do."

"I don't look at other women" you said with a laugh, giving her a good, deep thrust. Carmen let out a moan then laughed, tapping your noise even as you fucked her.

"I know you do. Even if it is just to compare them to me" Carmen replied.

"You always win" you said, kissing her again. For the moment you were taking it slow, fucking your fiancée's ass at a leisurely pace.

"Thank you" she said, moaning softly. She held you close as you thrust into her, closing her eyes as she luxuriated on her back.

"Tell me more about Rose" you said, smiling down at her. Gazing up at you through partially closed eyelids she replied your smile.

"Ever since you made me bi I've looked at her differently" Carmen admitted. "Not just her, either."

"Oh, tell me more" you said again.

"Well, I like women now, thanks to you and Alison. So you can imagine I love looking around when we hit the showers" Carmen told you, biting her lip. "So I look and I get really, really horny. I've masturbated a few times, right then and there."

"Jesus" you said, grinning, "And nobody noticed?"

"I wish they had. I mean, I've seen porn that started that way" your lover said. "It would've been hot to get an orgy going."

"So who did you masturbate to?" you asked. This made Carmen blush something fierce, so when she just said Rose, you knew she was keeping something from you. "Who else?" you insisted, giving her a few good, deep thrusts to get her to talk. After her moans subsided she looked up at you, her cheeks red.

"Okay, fine. I masturbated to your little sister twice" she admitted, looking away.

"You little slut. So does that mean I get to jack off to someone else?" you asked, smirking as you thrust into her again, so hard that it made Carmen cry out in pleasure.

"Fine" she said after recovering. "You can jerk off to someone else, but I still get your cum."

"Yeah? Like who?" you asked with a grin. "Remember how we talked about your mom or your sister? It'd only be fair."

"I guess" Carmen replied, looking up into your eyes. You knew she wasn't sold on the idea, even if she'd teased you about it just after you'd started having sex.

"Alright baby. I'll pick someone else. But not Rose" you told her, pulling out. Carmen whimpered when you did, trying to keep you from pulling away. You shook your head and flipped her on her stomach before entering her again, laying down on top of her so your lips were right next to her ear. As you thrust into her ass, you began giving her suggestions. "What about some of the other players, huh? Alexandra, maybe? Or Aurora?" you asked as you fucked her. Underneath you, Carmen clutched at the carpet, moaning loudly.

"Yes, yes! I don't care! Anybody, baby! As long as you fuck me, I don't care!" she exclaimed.

"Luci?" you asked, grinning as you nipped at her ear.

"You're already fucking one Dodson" she told you. "So no."

"It doesn't count when I make you a Doe soon" you pointed out.

"Fucking technicalities" she said, letting out a loud moan. "Just shut up and fuck my ass, okay?"

"Yes ma'am" you said, thrusting into her hard, making the gorgeous woman you loved cry out in pleasure over and over, your balls slapping against her cheeks with audible slaps. As you railed her, Carmen put an arm behind her and pulled you closer, her moans beginning to get more and more breathless as you fucked her ever closer to orgasm.

"Oh..yes...right there" she moaned, her hand finding your hair and curling her fingers into it. As she squirmed with pleasure her fingers tugged at your locks but you don't even care. The pain was nothing compared to the intense pleasure of Carmen's forbidden hole squeezing around your dick. You kept on pounding her ass, her moans turning into squeals going ever higher until she came, her body thrashing with pleasure underneath you. Panting heavily, Carmen went limp, her eyes closed. You withdrew from her ass slowly, laying down on your side next to her. She smiled and reached out to take your hand. "I ever tell you I love you?" she asked.

"Once or twice" you said, smiling.

"Well, I love you" she said, opening her eyes and moving a little to kiss you.

"I love you too, Carmen. Should we take this to the bedroom?" you asked.

"Shower first" she told you. "After a break." She closed her eyes and as you held her close.

"Oh...oh yeah" Carmen moaned as you gave her a back rub. The two of you had made it to the shower and now you were just enjoying the hot water and each other's company while getting the make up off of Carmen's face and chest.

"You love that, huh?" you asked.

"Yeah, you can get my knots just right. Plus there's a little extra something between my thighs that I like" she told you.

"Huh. I hadn't noticed" you teased.

"Well, I had. It's kind of hard to miss, darling" your fiancée said, smiling. She reached between her legs and slowly started rubbing your cockhead with her thumb, making you moan. "Yeah, it's sensitive, isn't it? Even after fucking my tight little ass. Go on, baby. Moan some more." She kept toying with your tip, rubbing her palm across it with the help of the warm water cascading down on you.

"Mmh, fuck" you said, moaning just like your lover wanted. "You got so good at pleasing me."

"Thank you for teaching me " she said, smiling. "It was a lot to take in, but you were so patient and kind."

"Literally" you said, grinning. Carmen laughed and pushed back against you, making you gasp when you were pressed up against the cold tile wall.

"You are the worst" she said, turning around before pushing herself up against you. Her soft breasts against your chest felt so good, especially her hard little nipples grinding against you. She smiled up at you and reached out to hold you close while moving slowly. The beautiful brunette moaned as her nipples were stimulated. At the same time, you reached down and gripped her ass, squeezing her firm cheeks. She moaned again and grinned. "Every part of me is an erogenous zone now, it seems" she told you.

"I love it" you replied, kissing her lips. With a smile Carmen replied, grinding against you happily while continuously rubbing your dick against her stomach. Before long, though, she had taken you inside of her again. Lifting her up, you used gravity to fuck your wonderful fiancée, impaling her on your dick, going balls deep inside of her with every thrust. Carmen moaned out loud in pleasure, her noises of pleasure echoing off the tile walls.

"Yes, fuck, yes!" Carmen exclaimed, biting her lip as you manhandled her. "Give it to me, baby!"

"I am" you said, grinning happily and kissing her again.

"Harder!" your wife-to-be encouraged you. "Fuck me like you mean it, John. Make me hurt!"

"Yes, ma'am" you replied, unable to stop yourself from grinning like a loon.

"That's right, be polite to your beautiful future wife. She loves it when you fuck her, but you still need to be a gentleman" Carmen told you with a smirk. She kissed you one more time before you pushing a finger up her ass made her crane her head back in pleasure. "Ah, fuck! You sneak! Well, now that you've probed my ass, you might as well fuck it."

"Happily" you said, kissing her again before putting her down and bending her over. With her hands on the wall she couldn't spread her cheeks, but she moved her ass from side to side to entice you. Putting your hands on her hips, you pulled her closer before taking your cock in hand and thrusting into Carmen's beautiful asshole. She cried out in joy and began pushing back against your cock, taking your cock up her ass happily.

"Oh, yeah! Fuck me like you're going to fuck Rose, baby! Give it to me! Don't be gentle! Ram my ass!" she threw at you.

What's next?

  • No further chapters
More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)